Wednesday, April 05, 2006

DeLay haiku

Spot doesn't know about the rest of you Minnesota bloggers, but he does sometimes take umbrage when others fish in our water. When it comes to Powerline, however, there is plenty to go around. From Rox Populi, some De Lay haiku. Go read the rest, including some in the comments.
Whither Powerline?
Very simple prediction
They'll blame Bill Clinton

Spot got the link somewhere, but he cannot remember where.

Separated at birth?
















The wicked witch of the South and North, respectively.

Et tu, siste?

A bus ride to the Capitol: $2.00. A vending machine lunch: $2.45. Watching Senator Michele Bachmann get busted in the chops by her step-sister: priceless. Now Spot wishes he had gone to the hearing.

The Minnesota Senate Judiciary Committee voted yesterday to kill the senator’s baby. By a 5 -4 (party line, surprise, surprise) vote, the committee rejected Bachmann’s bill to put a gay marriage ban amendment on the November ballot for a public referendum. The interesting part though was the family dynamics.

Bachmann must have seen her step-sister, Helen Lafave, at the hearing, and she must have known it was not a Helpful Thing to the senator. You see, Helen Lafave is a lesbian who sat behind the senator while she testified, and then testified herself against Michele’s Baby. Spot says check out the pictures at the link.

And you thought your Thanksgivings were tense because you’re a Packer fan and your brother-in-law loves the Vikings! Spotty bets that family keeps a lot of therapists employed.

Bachmann, of course, vows revenge. What else could she vow? Certainly not acceptance or understanding.

Spot was looking at the picture of the senator in the linked story. Michele Bachmann and Katherine Harris: separated at birth? Spot’s inclined to believe it.

Tags: does not heart

Tuesday, April 04, 2006

What's an overdog?

One of the things that has always impressed Spot about Katie is her willingness to stick up for the overdog.

What’s a overdog, Spotty?

Well an overdog, grasshopper, is the opposite of an underdog. Underdogs are like the plucky George Mason basketball team in the Final Four. Regrettably, underdogs usually get knocked off right away, as did George Mason. Underdogs have the potential, though, to upset the Established Order of Things. They feel a little revolutionary, which is why some people – and some dogs, too – root for them. But not Katie. Katie prefers things Just The Way They Are.

So Monday, Katie defends the Coca-Cola Company in a column titled Coke’s real sin is being a big U.S. corporation. With Katie in its corner, how could Coke lose? Anyway, there have been protests around the country, and around the world, really, over alleged human rights abuses (the death of several labor activists) by, apparently, a Coke franchisee in Colombia. And now the students as Macalester College are joining the ranks, tut tuts Katie, of places like Carlton College in Northfield and the University of Michigan. The students are trying to organize a boycott of Coke products. (Spot says, boys and girls, you should avoid them because they rot your teeth, but that’s for another day.)

Like some Asian food, Katie’s columns often leave the consumer hungry – hungry for some more information in the case of Katie, that is. Spot put his figital digitals to work on Google, and got over 400,000 hits for the search string coca cola protests Colombia. Allowing for duplicates, that probably leaves, oh, several at least!

A perusal of the links is interesting. In addition to the aforementioned callow fools, the Teamsters have joined the call for a Coke boycott.
In January the University of Michigan joined the universities of New York and Rutgers in banning all Coke products, bringing the number of bans to 21 in North America. The University of Michigan said it implemented the ban after the company missed a 31 December deadline to set up third party investigations and protocols to assess events in Colombia and India.

Another 130 colleges and universities are thought to be considering their options, according to the Center for Informed Food Choices.

With the Teamsters joining in the protests Coca-Cola is finding itself on the receiving end of snowballing protests. Teamsters members on Tuesday unanimously endorsed a resolution authorizing its leadership to seek a resolution to the dispute between Coca-Cola and student, labor and human rights groups.

Here’s an article about the NYU boycott in the lefty publication Business Week Online. It also seems that those pesky Irish – always a revolutionary bunch – are in on it, too!

What are the students’ demands? The liquidation of Coke? The crucifixion of Coke executives? Nah. The boycott is directed at obtaining an independent third-party investigation of these deaths. From the Business Week Online article:
That summer [2003], Coca-Cola declined to meet with concerned students from several universities. "At the time, we thought individual meetings [with individual schools] would be more helpful, because we could have more in-depth discussions," explains Coca-Cola spokesperson Kari Bjorhus.

In response, CKC [a student organization at NYU] members stepped up their demands, calling for an immediate ban of Coke products unless the company agreed to a third-party investigation. During the fall, CKC members talked up student senators and collected more than 1,500 student signatures on a petition, which was adopted as a formal proposal by the senate's student-life committee. In November, 2004, the student senate voted 16-4 to ban Coke products from the school unless Coke O.K.'d an investigation.

Katie thinks that’s rilly, rilly radical, although she doesn’t describe the students’ objective in her column. How hard would that have been?

The thing that really frosted Spot, though, was Katie’s gratuitous swipe at Vietnam War-era protests by students. It’s all part of the silly romanticism of liberal students, she says. Spot doesn’t remember it that way, Katie. It was college students, of course, that got the anti-war movement started against the Vietnam War. A lot of the same bunch, now grayer and rounder, are the activists against the rumble in Iraq. And no, Katie, Kent State – Four Dead in O – HI – O was not the least romantic.

One thing for sure. Spotty isn’t going to be buying any Coke until we get this thing sorted out.

Tags: tut tuts over the

Reading material

Spotty hates to mess with his blog template. Spot predates html, bloggerspeak, or whatever. However, he did move to a new template over the weekend, trying for posts that were a little more horizontal and less vertical. You, boys and girls, will have to the judge of how well Spot got everything carried over.

While he was in the neighborhood, Spot decided to add some links that have been in his news aggregator for quite a while. They are perhaps more familiar to you than Spotty is, but if not, check them out.

Norwegianity

The Power Liberal

Three Way News

Yowling from the Fencepost

But Spot was first!

Dahlia Lithwick is a lot younger than Spot. That's why it annoys Spot so much that she writes about legal stuff so well. Take this article in Slate, for example, about Zacarias Moussaoui's death wish. Spot did write about it too. Spot's post was first but Lithwick's is better.

Reopen the Koufax voting!

The Wege certainly earned one for new lyrics to one of Oklahoma's most durable tunes. A taste:
There's a bright golden haze on the capitol,
There's a bright golden haze from the lies,
With indictments as high as an elephant's eye,
An' it looks like it's climbin' clear up to Cheney.

Monday, April 03, 2006

Peek a Boo

For those of you who subscribe to the Cucking Stool, and bless you if you do, Spot has experienced some trouble with the atom.xml feed out of Booger, er, Blogger. He thinks it is fixed now. You might want to have your newsreader "rediscover" the feed. Sorry for the inconvenience.

This is why

Why Spotty is a Malthusian.

Sunday, April 02, 2006

Another rebuttal

To the private and religious school apologists like Captain Fishsticks, Katie, John Brandl, and many Republicans, including the governor and Spot's state Senator, Geoff Michel. A recent Department of Education study says public schools do better. Christian private schools do the worst.
In "The Manufactured Crisis: "Myths, Fraud, and the Attack on America's Public Schools" Dr. David Berliner and Bruce Biddle argued that ongoing criticism of America's public schools is baseless and partisan. [read review of book in Christian Ethics Today]. A new study released January 2006, funded by the US Department of Education, by researchers at the University of Illinois at Champagne Urbana rebuts claims on the alleged low performance of public schools [ click here for PDF of full report ]. Meanwhile, the ongoing assault on America's public schools comes from many quarters . . .
Via the always excellent Media Transparency.

wer-sal (n)

Another word for weasel. Greg Wersal, at least that’s the name he is using today, filed petition Friday for the investigation of past and current members of the Minnesota Supreme Court. You remember Wersal; he’s the knave who changed his name to “Carlson” in an unsuccessful run for the Minnesota Supreme Court in 2000. Here’s the story from the link:

Wersal? Carlson? Carlson-Wersal? What’s His Name?

In August 2000, Kiffmeyer ruled that Minnesota Supreme Court candidate Greg Wersal could use his wife’s maiden name, Carlson, on the ballot. Critics charged that the move was an attempt to pander to voters of Scandinavian descent. Wersal had not (at least not for any public purpose) used the name “Carlson” before the election, nor has he used it since. Wersal is an attorney, listed in the Martindale-Hubbell lawyer directory, but his name appears there as “Gregory F. Wersal.” Additionally, Wersal was the petitioner in a U.S. Supreme Court case relating to his candidacy (but not relating to this issue). His brief to the Court listed his name as “Gregory F. Wersal.” Greg and Cheryl Wersal also have their phone number listed under "G & C Wersal.” Still, Kiffmeyer decided that she would be engaging in gender-based discrimination against Wersal if she denied his request to adopt his wife’s name on the ballot, when wives have traditionally taken their husbands’ names.


Here’s what Carlson-now-back-to-Wersal seeks:

Wersal asked the Board on Judicial Standards and the Lawyers Board of Professional Responsibility to look into Chief Justice Russell Anderson, Justice G. Barry Anderson, Justice Paul Anderson and former Chief Justice Kathleen Blatz.

"The public needs to know if judges on our highest court have engaged in unethical conduct by giving pledges, promises, assurances or mere hints as to how they would rule on an issue likely to come before the court," Wersal wrote in a letter to the two boards. He released the letter to reporters. [of course he did, Spot] [italics are Spot’s, too]


You can see how ol’
Greg might think it would be useful to have Scandinavian name!

The conduct that Wersal is complaining about arises, of course, out of l’affaire de johnson, the ethics charge made against Senate Majority Leader Dean Johnson that was recently dismissed. Conservatives have been trying to keep the issue alive to try to hurt Dean Johnson politically and try to force a floor vote in the Senate on the gay marriage amendment ban bill. Captain Fishsticks has labored mightily at the project, and Spot comments here. Katie had a column excreting outrage, and Spot commented in post titled The feces-flinging monkey. Spot has a couple of other posts about the flap, too.

And now comes Wersal. For years, Wersal has been jumping up and down like the Eddie Murphy donkey in the movie Shrek shouting PICK ME PICK ME in a effort to get a seat on the Minnesota Supreme Court. He can’t get a governor to do it, so he has run for the office – unsuccessfully – a couple of times. Wersal the weasel’s petition is just a transparent attempt to set himself up to do it again.

The person with the least amount of standing on planet earth to bring a petition alleging the discussion of issues by Justices outside the court is Greg Wersal. You see, boys and girls, Greg Wersal along with the Republican Party in Minnesota are the agents of destruction in dismantling the rules against party endorsements for judges and the discussion of specific issues in judicial campaigns.

It's not the first time Wersal has taken on Supreme Court or its members. He twice tried and failed to win a seat on the Supreme Court during elections. And he was the driving force in a federal lawsuit that successfully eased restrictions on judicial campaigning.

Ironically
, he helped persuade the U.S. Supreme Court to strike down Minnesota rules barring judicial candidates from talking about disputed legal and political issues during campaigns.

Wersal said in his letter that the 2002 decision doesn't allow judges to make pledges or promises on issues that are likely to come before them. [italics are Spot’s]


Spotty says more than ironically, how about hypocritically? No one ever said, least of all
Senator Johnson, that a Justice made a pledge or promise about a DOMA vote. Nor is this the first time that Wersal has tried to harm the reputation or position of a public official. In 2001, he was part of a scheme to have Attorney Mike Hatch recalled for not defending the State’s anti-sodomy law, which was struck down.

Wersal is just another Republican trouble maker. One who thinks that he and his agenda should be on the Minnesota Supreme Court.

Tags: makes a cameo appearance in

Saturday, April 01, 2006

She got flowers; what did he get?

Here's Helen Thomas surrounded by some of the roses sent to her as a thank you for her questioning of Chimpy McFlightsuit at a recent newsconference.

Here's a news article about Helen and the flowers.

Friday, March 31, 2006

Sticks to Katie to Wersal

Spotty wishes he had posted his prediction to his inner dog that this would happen. CP at minvolved called it to Spot's attention this afternoon. Spot will have more on this in coming days.

The feces-flinging monkey

Katie’s Thursday column, titled We need to know who is telling the whole truth, is breathtaking. Rarely in the field of human polemics have so many been libeled in so many ways by so few ill-crafted words. Spot predicts that We need to know who is telling the whole truth will stand as a monument to the art of the smear for a generation. Just when you think that Katie couldn’t possibly get any more bilious, she goes out and draws a new mark on the tree for the hacks and hackettes at MOB and Pajamas Media to shoot at.

The subject of Katie’s harangue, of course, is l’affaire de johnson. Spot has written about this before. Here, too. He has also posted about Craig Westover’s lament that the drama is drawing to a close. Spotty has told you, boys and girls, that with Katie, subtext is everything. Why is she trying to reanimate this corpse? It is pretty simple, really. Katie wants to damage Majority Leader Dean Johnson as much as possible, hoping to help bring pressure on Johnson to bring the gay marriage ban amendment to the Senate floor for a vote. The Republicans want the amendment on the ballot this fall really, really bad, because they face a massacre this November if they don’t get their entire base out to vote.

Now, boys and girls, let’s spend some time at the examining table with the rancid remains.

The flingees in Katie’s blast include Senator Majority Leader Dean Johnson, Minority Leader Dick Day, the ethics subcommittee that examined the complaint against Senator Johnson, Chief Justice Russell Anderson, and the Senate DFL Caucus. Did Spot leave somebody out? Oh, yeah, the governor, too.

Katie starts out by telling us that either Dean Johnson or Russell Anderson is a liar (actually, she slyly puts the words in the mouths of our protagonists). Spot wants to start with a question: What do Russell Anderson and Katie have in common?

They both went to law school?

Yes, but that’s not what Spot had in mind.

They both have kinda geeky hair?

Spotty will not be the judge of that.

Okay, we give up.

The answer is that neither Katie nor Russell Anderson has any first-hand knowledge of the conversations that make up l’affair de johnson. If the definition of a liar includes actually knowing the falsity of the utterance, Russell Anderson cannot be a liar. An officious fool, perhaps. Spotty, that was uncalled for. Apologize! Ok, Spot is sorry.

On the other hand, Senator Johnson, through his lawyer, said he was willing to name names and call witnesses. Putting his money where his mouth is, so to speak. Suddenly, the Chief Justice clams up, a couple of members of the ethics subcommittee admit that Johnson’s version is “plausible,” and Dick Day and the Republicans back away slowly. Spot says connect the spots.

Katie also shrieks about the breach of judicial (and legislative) ethics that must have occurred here. She wants us to accept as fact that a breach occurred, but it isn’t so. First, let’s remember that Dean Johnson (for better or worse, probably better) is neither lawyer nor judge. The Code of Judicial Conduct does not apply to him.

Moreover, you will search the Code of Judicial Conduct that Spot just linked to in vain for the prohibition of a judge talking to a member of another branch of government. CANON 1 states that a Judge Shall Uphold the Integrity and Independence of the Judiciary. CANON 2 states that a Judge Shall Avoid Impropriety and the Appearance of Impropriety in All of the Judge's Activities. That’s as close as it gets.

Do these canons mean that a lawyer and a judge can’t have lunch and even talk “shop” about issues other than ones before the judge at the time? No, of course not. Nor does it mean that being a judge is such a priesthood that he or she cannot talk to a member of another branch of government. Do you suppose that Abe Fortas never spoke to Lyndon Johnson? Okay, bad example. How about Dick Cheney and Antonin Scalia? They shared a duck blind and a private jet when cases that included the name “Cheney” were before the Supreme Court. As friends in politics for a long time, don’t you suppose that they talk “shop” maybe even a little, from time to time? Of course. History is full of examples of governors or legislators who became judges. The oath of office doesn’t include an oath of conversational celibacy.

It must be remembered that no DOMA case is before the Minnesota Supreme Court. Senator Johnson did not receive an advisory opinion, which is a complicated doctrine that has built up a couple of centuries of jurisprudence on things like case and controversy, ripeness and standing, by the way. One might forgive Captain Fishsticks for confusion here, but not Katie – nor the Chief Justice, for that matter.

As Spot has said a couple of times, it was indiscreet of Senator Johnson to refer to conversations that whoever he talked to thought were private and off-the-cuff discussions. And Johnson has apologized for that.

Speaking of forgiveness, Katie says that she is not prepared to forgive Senator Johnson just yet. There isn’t a drop of forgiveness in Katie; we wouldn’t expect you to forgive, Katie. You’re incapable of it. Katie and the rest of the DOMA hyenas will stick the gay marriage issue up the public’s arse every chance and every way they can.

Tag:

Thursday, March 30, 2006

Mea culpa

Probably none of you remembers this post, but Spot does. Check back Spot's original for an update discussion of New York Times Co. v. Sullivan, a celebrated 1964 Supreme Court opinion.

INCOMING!

Katie comes out like a feces-flinging monkey this morning. Because the column is an unusually large specimen of maliciousness and pettiness, and because Spot is rather busy today, it may be a day or so before he can do the autopsy.

But he will.

Wednesday, March 29, 2006

Once more into the Sticksian ooze

Captain Fishsticks sucks his teeth, stares into his monitor with moist eyes, and then releases a long wistful sigh. You see, Sticks has been blowing hot air into the corpse of l’affaire de johnson for as long as Sticks can remember, and longer than most people care to remember. And that’s Sticks’ problem. People just don’t care. Of course, most people don’t live in the tight-assed world of epistemology that Sticks inhabits. Sometimes, Sticks, the pursuit of something turns into obsession; just ask a guy named Ahab.

Sticks’ valediction (Spotty fervently hopes) on l’affaire de johnson came in a Pioneer Press column today, thoughtfully reprinted by Sticks on his blog. Sticks is unhappy that the Senate ethics panel did not do a full Torquemada on Senator Johnson.

It sounds, in fact, like the Senator was well-represented at the ethics panel hearing. The Star Tribune reports today that two of the four panel members have said that Johnson’s version of events was “plausible.” They probably applied the Rule of Probability that Spotty told you about earlier, boys and girls. That and the fact that Johnson was apparently prepared to call witnesses to support him if the panel wanted to go the full-meal deal route. Spotty wonders if Johnson’s lawyer mentioned that Chief Justice Russell Anderson couldn’t be a witness at a hearing, since he had no first hand knowledge of what happened! According to the Star Tribune article, the Chief Justice has no further comment.

L’affaire de johnson is a cautionary tale for legislators, judges, and Spotty says, the voting public. As Spot discussed earlier, the barriers to party endorsement and discussion of issue positions by judicial candidates have fallen. These developments portend far more serious dangers to the impartiality and integrity of the judiciary than Dean Johnson’s little informal chats.

Tags:

What in a name?

A lot. Especially when it comes to the name of a stadium on the University of Minnesota campus. Here are the opening grafs of an article in the Pioneer Press online edition today:
The University of Minnesota's new football stadium strategy passed its first test Tuesday at the state Capitol, but a panel of lawmakers punted several thorny financial issues to another committee.

Two stadium bills moved through the Senate Higher Education Committee on unanimous voice votes, indicating bipartisan support for a basic plan unveiled Friday with the support of Gov. Tim Pawlenty.

One of the bills, backed by the university, says funding should include student fees and a corporate name on the door. The other bill scraps the fee and the naming deal, with a key senator indicating those ideas are fundamentally tacky.

Tacky? Yup, according to Larry Pogemiller:
Sen. Larry Pogemiller, DFL-Minneapolis, whose district includes the university, said charging students $50 annually to help pay for the stadium is inappropriate in light of large tuition increases in recent years. He also wants the stadium name to honor veterans or a former university athletic hero or administrator.

University of Minnesota President Robert Bruininks, on the other hand, thinks the deal which names the stadium after a saving and loan is
hunky-dory. The Prez was accompanied at the hearing yesterday by Spotty’s own senator, Geoff Michel. These are strange bedfellows indeed!

Spot’s readers know that Robert Bruininks is the Prez, but fewer probably know that his academic background is education. He spent most of his career training new teachers in education and child development and running a university department to do that. At a land grant university. A big time supporter of public education, you’d think.

Geoff Michel, on the other hand, is a member of the Minnesota Republican Taliban, a supporter of religious school vouchers, the $185,000,000 budget cut to K-12 education last biennium, and the governor’s hare-brained 65% solution last year, not to mention his partisan support for Cheri Pierson Yecke, the cashiered Commissioner of Education. Spotty says just peruse the archives of www.retiregeoffmichel.blogspot.com/ for more.

Oh, and by the way, Michel’s wife is the niece of former U Athletic Director Tom Moe. No link here, but trust Spot; it’s true.

TCF, the putative sponsor of the stadium that will get the naming rights, is the creature of William Cooper, until recently the Chairman of TCF. Cooper is also one of the big-deal Republicans in Minnesota, a supporter of the Minnesota Taxpayers League. It is ironic, to put it mildly, that a leading member of the bunch so allergic to the public interest, and both K-12 and higher education budgets, would get his company’s name on a stadium at the state’s land grant and leading university. Think the Carrie Nation School of Viticulture.

Senator Pogemiller says that the naming deal is not a “deal-breaker” for him. It ought to be.

Tags:

Tuesday, March 28, 2006

Well, he's not afraid of needles!

Zacarias Moussaoui, that is. It is amazing to contemplate that the prosecution’s best friend in this case is the defendant himself:
Until Mr. Moussaoui took the stand, the momentum seemed to be with the defense, which had contended that he was a fringe figure in Al Qaeda whose leaders held him in low regard.

Moreover, the government's case had been plagued by problems. After the disclosure that a government transportation lawyer had improperly coached some aviation security witnesses, the testimony of two other witnesses about how the F.B.I. handled investigative leads before Sept. 11 raised as many questions over the government's performance as it did about Mr. Moussaoui's culpability.

From the same NYT article from today however, it seems as though ol’ Zacarias may be suffering delusions of grandeur:

Before the day was over, the jury also had the extraordinary experience of hearing a reading of testimony taken in a deposition from Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, who is said to have organized the Sept. 11 attacks and is being held somewhere in the secret overseas detention system of the Central Intelligence Agency.

That deposition, in which Mr. Mohammed answered questions agreed to by prosecutors and defense lawyers, seemed to contradict Mr. Moussaoui's assertion that he was meant to be a pilot on Sept. 11.

Mr. Mohammed portrayed Mr. Moussaoui as a fringe figure who might have been used in a second wave of attacks if needed.

For more than an hour, Michael Nachmanoff, a public defender, recited Mr. Mohammed's answers in what resembled an oddly disembodied literary reading. Mr. Nachmanoff read out testimony that any planning for a second wave of attacks "was only in the most preliminary stages" and that targets had not even been selected.

But no matter. What’s really important is that Moussaoui can now be executed and give us all the catharsis we so desperately desire! There is a God.

Sunday, March 26, 2006

Readin' and 'rithmic and nothing else

This is interesting, and more than a little troubling. The NYT reports today on a trend in US education away from social studies, science, and art. Why? The requirements of No Child Left Behind, of course. For some low scoring kids, this means essentially a full day of reading and math:
About 125 of the school's lowest-performing students [at Martin Luther King Jr. junior high in Sacramento] are barred from taking anything except math, reading and gym, a measure that Samuel Harris, a former lieutenant colonel in the Army who is the school's principal, said was draconian but necessary. "When you look at a kid and you know he can't read, that's a tough call you've got to make," Mr. Harris said.

In the article, some commenters say this might make school a little, well, booooooring. Ya think?

If Katie thinks we're ahistorical now, just give it a generation or two.

Tags: