Wednesday, January 09, 2008

Drinking Liberally tomorrow (Thursday) night

Six to nine at the 331 Club, as usual.

What is maybe not so usual is that Spot suggests a couple of questions for discussion, maybe even debate:

If you're male, and you prefer another candidate to Hillary Clinton, does that make you presumptively a misogynist?

Is your answer to that question different than it would have been last week? If so, why?

This one's for the Wege

"People feel that the media is piling on Hillary Clinton; they're coming to her defense with their votes."

Tuesday, January 08, 2008

Spot's car ride

Recently, Spot got to go for a car ride and he saw some of the new McMansions here in Edina. Here's some of what he saw. It deserves a narration, which it will get, but in the meantime, enjoy the ride:

Technorati Tags: ,

 

Update:

Please see the new version with subtitles! You can find it at a post above called Spot's Car Ride Take IV. (There have been a couple of cuts that Spot would rather not talk about.)

Rachel's pity party

Katie's column yesterday was about Rachel's Raw Deal. Spot wrote about it in Flogging a dead horse. The column produced outpourings of grief from the expected places, but Avidor wrote about one that deserves more attention. It's by Drew Emmer at Wright County Republican:

This morning Katherine Kersten wrote a brilliant piece about how U.S. Attorney Rachel Paulose was run out of town on a rail. As is typical of the leftist press they didn't bother to vet the facts and play the role we used to expect from the media. Had teh [sic] media done its [sic] job the hardest working US Attorney we've had in decades might still be showing up for work in Minnesota.

Paulose was hot on the trail of uncovering a significant corruption issue in Minnesota. Amazing how expendable the U.S. Attorney becomes when there is big money on the line.

Boy, Spotty, it sounds like they got rid of Paulose just in the nick of time!

Well according to Drew, but Drew exposes a laughable ignorance of the Paulose fiasco from coronation to humiliation.

But what to make of his statement that "Paulose was hot on the trail of uncovering a significant corruption issue?" Our boy Draw obviously has no first hand information about ongoing investigations at the US Attorney's office, so a couple of alternatives present themselves.

First, and frankly the more likely, Drew is just full of so much doo doo. He was so carried away by the drama of Katie's prose that he made the statement up "out of whole cloth" as lawyers like to say.

Second, Drew has a source of this information. If so, it is, directly or indirectly either someone in the U.S. Attorney's office or perhaps a grand juror. In either case, such a leak would be a serious matter, worthy of investigation by federal authorities. Spot will remind Drew that there isn't even a federal journalist source shield law, just some guidelines at the Justice Department. When the alleged leaker is one of its own, Spot doubts that the guidelines would be much of an impediment to an investigation.

Spot calls on Drew Emmer to say whether it is alternative one or alternative two that is true.

Monday, January 07, 2008

Flogging a dead horse

What does that mean, Spotty? Flogging a dead horse. It sounds kind of useless, not to mention icky.

Where did you hear that, grasshopper?

Oh, somebody said it about Katie's column today praising the now departed Rachel Paulose. Apparently, Friday was her last day on the job:

Last Friday, Rachel Paulose walked out of the U.S. attorney's office in Minneapolis for the last time.

Ah, yes, the former and little lamented, in a lot of circles anyway, US attorney for Minnesota.

But Katie said that she did a really good job, and some other people thought so, too.

On the other hand, there are others, including several people who worked in the office, who thought she was a venomous little witch:

When Paulose took over the office, she told several of the career officials there that she demanded total personal loyalty. At least one replied that loyalty was owed to the Constitution, not to her. Many of the allegations [against Paulose] raise the possibility that Paulose crossed the line while seeking to punish personal disloyalty.

That's City Pages quoting Eric Black. But let's get back to flogging dead horses. It's a metaphor, grasshopper.

For what?

Doing something entirely useless. You can't make a dead horse walk or run faster or pull harder by flogging it.

Oh, I get it! Sort of like the futility of writing glowingly about a person who already lost her job!

Exactly, grasshopper.

Running away II

Alternate title: DON WAN HUCKABEE!

You'd think these guys were being chased! Well they are, in a way. In his last post, Spot observed that the Republican establishment was really frightened of Mike Huckabee's traveling evangelical freak show, especially after the Iowa caucuses, and how it was working hard to discredit it. Ironic, in view of how the Republicans have courted the evangelicals for years. Spot used Power Line as Exhibit A for how the party insiders were trying to get the anti-Huckabee message out.

There was a final candidates' debate this weekend before the New Hampshire primary. Guess how Power Line scored it? C'mon, guess. That's right.

Here's Paul:

Mitt Romney, in my view, was the winner. His answers were crisp, knowledgeable, and poised. He was solid on each substantive issue and effective in defending his so-called attack ads. My guess is that he's cemented himself as the choice of Republicans in New Hampshire, but still faces the prospect of having independents override that choice.

Mike Huckabee looked to me like tonight's loser. Scott has already shown how weak Huckabee was during the debate on taxes.  . . .

Crisp? You pickin' a candidate or a head of lettuce, Paul?

And as Paul intimates, Scotty came to the very same conclusion: Mittens won and Huckabee lost:

I score this round (on immigration) for Romney and am calling the event for Romney. I thought that Giuliani and McCain came in tied for second, a few points behind Romney. For an extraordinarily attentive account to check against mine, I recommend Michelle Malkin's here.

Note the link to another member of the Republican talking points Play Doh extrusion machine, Michelle Malkin.

A Romney adviser also passed this cautionary tale on to the boys at Power Line:

With Mike Huckabee’s victory in Iowa, however, the Republican party is now entering what might be called its Jesse Jackson moment.

If Huckabee goes on to win more primaries he will have a reasonable claim to the nomination. He may, of course, lose New Hampshire, New York, California and Michigan. But let’s suppose that he manages to win enough primaries in the southern and border states to make the results in those three states [by Spot's count, that's four states] irrelevant. It’s all a question of numbers. In spite of itself, the party might end up with him as its nominee, and with it, heading down the shortest road to disaster since the Goldwater debacle of 1964.

Romney's advisor is trying to make the point that the Republicans may have to pay the price for courting evangelicals just as the Democrats did with blacks.

They did, Spotty? Has this clown ever seen a picture of Barack Obama?

Apparently not, grasshopper. Obama won in Iowa, the "whitest place south of the North Pole," according to the CNN's Jack Cafferty. Spotty say that now, Johnny and Scotty and Paul, since you've invited all the snake handlers,  medicine show peddlers, and all the other magical-thinking nut balls into your home, you're going to have to live with them. Have fun.

Friday, January 04, 2008

Running away

Talk about your existential crises! There were two really good ones that Spot noticed today. Republicans are running hard from both of them. The first was the national Republican crisis, occasioned by Mike Huckabee winning the Iowa caucuses on the Republican side. The Republican establishment is beside itself; the beast that it has fed and nurtured since Nixon's Southern Strategy has gotten off its leash and threatens, nay promises, to lead the party into exile for a generation.

All the people who are into the apocalypse are about to create one! Live by the evangelical nut job; die by the evangelical nut job. This stuff about red heifers and pale riders and lakes of fire was just fine, but now it's pretty clear that these people want to own the Republican party. And it has the party scared. Want proof?  Here's one of the most reliable party organs today:

Remember the attack ad against Mitt Romney that Mike Huckabee said he wasn't going to air, but played for reporters so they could publicize his attacks on Romney? It turns out that Huckabee did air the ad -- at least 10 times on four different stations in Davenport and Cedar Rapids, according to FactCheck.org.

Moreover, FactCheck found that Huckabee's attack ad contains several "misleading claims" about his rival. For one thing, the ad says Romney's record as governor of Massachusetts includes "no executions." That's true, but the reason is that Massachusetts doesn't have a death penalty. Indeed, Romney tried but failed to get the death penalty reinstated.

In a less egregious but somewhat misleading claim, the ad also holds Romney accountable for the fact that his state's health care program covers abortions. But Romney didn't make the decision to provide abortion coverage for a $50 co-pay. Rather, the health care legislation Romney signed provided that an independent agency would implement the law and would “develop criteria for plans eligible for premium assistance payments.”

Meanwhile, FactCheck blows the whistle on another Huckabee ad in which he touts his record as a "tax cutter." Among other problems with the ad, Huckabee's tenure as governor actually resulted in a $505.1 million net increase in taxes.

That's Paul at Power Line (no link; you can find it if you really want to, boys and girls). Poor Mittens: he had to be the governor of a state with no death penalty. Come to think of it, that's gonna hurt Governor Pepsodent in any bid for national office, too!

And then Johnny Rocketseed chimed in with this (again, no link):

I caught the first few minutes Hugh Hewitt's radio show driving home from the airport a little while ago. I won't say that Hugh sounded suicidal, but he certainly wasn't happy about yesterday's Iowa caucus results. Hugh attributed today's stock market drop to the prospect of an Obama administration.

That strikes me as a little premature. For what it's worth, I'm not sure the Iowa results changed the landscape much on the Republican side. I'm pretty sure McCain will win New Hampshire, which means that Romney's "slingshot" strategy will have failed, but I don't think it follows that Romney's candidacy is dead. As Paul and Scott have said, Huckabee isn't going much farther, and Thompson shows little sign of life. Which means that there are still three credible Republican candidates. Of the three, Romney might well emerge from the early primaries in the strongest position.

Wishin' and hopin' and dreamin'. How does that song go again? (Spot also notes that Johnny thinks it is important for you to know that he was coming from the airport, implying that he was, of course, off doing important things. Johnny is, Spot regrets to say, a blowhard.)

The second existential crisis happened a little closer to home. It is the defeat of Ray Cox by Kevin Dahle in the special election in Senate District 25. The local Republicans certainly think it was a upset, and a lot of DFLers thought so, too. Some Republicans got up extra early to start the finger pointing:

THE FIRST-EVER MINNESOTA DEMOCRATS EXPOSED “MAN NOT IN THE ARENA” AWARD GOES TO…

By Michael B. Brodkorb | January 4, 2008

Drew Emmer of the Wright County Republican. By his own admission, Drew did nothing to help out with the Republican effort in the SD 25 special election but he wasted no time this morning pointing out how everyone else stumbled.

The comments to Mikey's post are compelling. Well, maybe just entertaining. Spot's favorite was the comment exhorting Mikey to "remember the 11th commandment." Spotty thinks the 11th commandment is going to be recognized more in the breach that the observance this election cycle!

You know what the 11th commandment is, don't you, grasshopper?

No clue, Spotty.

Ronald Reagan came up with it, or perhaps more likely somebody working for him: Never speak ill of another Republican.

Thumps of the tail to Phoenix Woman and Charlie.

The Spotty™: Visual Arts Division

The first Spotty™ of 2008 introduces a new category: visual arts. The Spotty™ goes to Spot's friend and DL drinking buddy (she doesn't drink much, but never mind) Tild. The graphic is contained in Tild's post Katie Kersten: More Than A Seasonal Creep. Indeed! This one is especially pleasing to Spot, because Tild is also the designer and artist of the handsome Spotty™ award medallion that appears on his posts that announce a new Spotty™ award winner. Like this one:

Tild's muse for the graphic she created was Katie's column about the University of Minnesota's uncertain navigation of the issue of Christmas or holiday parties at this public university, and Spot's imagining of a conversation about that column that Katie had with boss Doug Tick Tice. (God, that was Freudian.) Spot is too modest (yeah, right Spotty) to reprint all the nice things Tild said about Spot's post, but here's just a bit:

I’ve been thinking that Katie was much too modest about her little “seasonal creep” bon mot.  As Spot has so ably pointed out in 2007, creepiness of Kersten’s caliber transcends the limits of a single season.  In actuality,  Katherine Kersten is….

That paragraph introduces the winning graphic:

Now, it took Spot a little while to get used to the notion of sharing cherub duties with Swiftee, but on reflection, it does have sort of a yin and yang feeling to it that Spot likes. It's a wonderful HOLIDAY treat for Spot.

Spot does have a word of warning for you, boys and girls. When you go over to Tild's post, linked above, if you click on the winning graphic, it will send you back here to the Cucking Stool. You risk being caught in an electronic whirlpool from which you may never, ever emerge! Be careful!

Remember, boys and girls, a Spotty™ is awarded to the author of an op-ed piece, a letter to the editor, a blog post or comment, and now a graphic, that Spot wishes that he had authored himself.

Update: Tild now takes her place in the pantheon of Spot's blogroll, too.

Wherein Michael Brodkorb again reveals himself as a doofus

The GOP's favorite slime-slinger, Michael Brodkorb, recently proclaimed in his usual breathless manner that Secretary of State Mark Ritchie was somehow "hiding" information about the upcoming caucuses here in Minnesota. Given the hyperventilating that Mr. Brodkorb's been doing about Mark Ritchie, I wanted to check out whether the information about caucuses was indeed hidden on the site.

I went to the Secretary of State home page, and right there on the top was a link entitled "Voting and Election Information" link, complete with a little illustration of a button that said "vote." So I clicked it and lo and behold at the very top of the list of links that came up was one for "Caucus information." This link led me to this document, providing accurate dates, how to contact parties to determine locations, frequently asked questions, even a handy-dandy list of definitions and terms.

This - shockingly enough - didn't strike me as "hiding" anything, so I tried to post a comment on Mr. Brodkorb's post explaining that the information was far from "hidden." The fact that the comment was not allowed does speak volumes about Mr. B's penchant for never letting the facts get in the way of a pretend outrage, especially when it comes to Mark Ritchie.

Now, unlike elections in the State of Minnesota, precinct caucuses are not administered by any governmental unit. They are set up, funded, administered, and conducted by the political parties, not the Secretary of State or any of the county elections administrators. So our outraged friend purposely gets lost on the website of the people not running the caucuses, can't find the thing he's hoping to not find, treats this as some startling revelation, proclaims his incorrect conclusion, and then deletes comments that point out that he's again wrong on a simple fact.

Michael, you'll find in life that those who want to be lost often are.

Update: Charlie really does his homework on this one. And he repudiates his own name-calling, unlike me.

Further update: Having gone back to the SoS website and following the simple instructions in the comment he wouldn't post, Mr. B now finds the information and proclaims loudly that he, Brodkorb caused Secretary of State Ritchie to post the caucus information!

Judge Easterbrook of the Seventh Circuit wrote this week a legal opinion upholding a finding of fraud against the purveyors of the“Gold Deluxe” Q-Ray Ionized Bracelet and explored that old logical fallacy: post hoc ergo propter hoc to analyze the claims of the charlatans who sold the junk bracelets. Recognizing that merely because one thing happens after another does not mean the second thing is caused by the first thing, the wise judge described it this way: "the 'testimonial' of someone who keeps elephants off the streets of a large city by snapping his fingers is the basis of a joke rather than proof of cause and effect."

Mr. Brodkob's eventual location of the caucus information after he roared his outrage falls squarely into the "joke" category, not the "cause and effect" category.

Wednesday, January 02, 2008

Mitch the whiner

Make that the insufferable, incessant, retching whiner Mitch. Dear God, deliver us from Mitch, the man who thinks that sackcloth and ashes are a fashion statement. Mitch the hot dryer vent of human beings, taking the crease out of your slacks and the curl out of you hair. Mitch, the man who sells a line of custom hair shirts. Mitch . . .

We get the picture, Spot. Why the rant?

Poor Mitch put up a post today lamenting the problems of the core cities:

The inner cities have their issues. If you’re in Minnesota and reading this, you know about them; you’ve either fled them, are paying for them via your taxes, or are - like me - living among them.

Where does Mitch live, Spotty? The near north side of Minneapolis?

Actually, grasshopper, he lives near Hamline University in St. Paul. But Mitch is so put upon, so besieged by something called "local government aid" that he can't stand it.

Wait a minute, Spot. I thought that LGA in effect took money from guys like you, Spot, and used it to provide services to core city residents like Mitch. Right?

Well, yes, that's right.

Why is he complaining and not you, Spot?

An interesting point, grasshopper. Perhaps it is because Spot recognizes that the entire metropolitan area is a community. Or perhaps it is just the nature of whiners. Regardless, Mitch, Spot says that you should get out of the house more: clean your garage, shovel your walks, mow the grass; you need the exercise.

Tuesday, January 01, 2008

His paw is in a sling

Boys and girls, you ol' friend Spot injured a typing paw (two typing paws and a nose; it usually goes pretty fast) in a gruesome accident here in the doghouse. While he heals up—and Swiftee, Spot will heal to write again, sorry—he won't be posting too much. Spot did want to call one thing to your attention, though. It comes via Mercury Rising.

Apparently El Presidente Bush signed the Sudan Accountability and Divestment Act of 2007. But as he often does, Bush included a signing statement—much like crossing your fingers behind you back when you don't mean what you're saying—that Spot reproduces with Phoenix Woman's highlights:

Today, I have signed into law S. 2271, the “Sudan Accountability and Divestment Act of 2007.” I share the deep concern of the Congress over the continued violence in Darfur perpetrated by the Government of Sudan and rebel groups. My Administration will continue its efforts to bring about significant improvements in the conditions in Sudan through sanctions against the Government of Sudan and high level diplomatic engagement and by supporting the deployment of peacekeepers in Darfur.

This Act purports to authorize State and local governments to divest from companies doing business in named sectors in Sudan and thus risks being interpreted as insulating from Federal oversight State and local divestment actions that could interfere with implementation of national foreign policy. However, as the Constitution vests the exclusive authority to conduct foreign relations with the Federal Government, the executive branch shall construe and enforce this legislation in a manner that does not conflict with that authority.

GEORGE W. BUSH
THE WHITE HOUSE,
December 31, 2007.

PW charitably calls this "weaselly."

You notice the sleight of hand, don't you, boys and girls? First, the statement says that foreign policy is up to the federal government, but then it says that it is up to the executive branch to decide what that policy is.

Of course, by adopting the Sudan Accountability Act, Congress already announced the foreign policy on the subject. The signing statement is a claim the the executive somehow makes foreign policy in a vacuum without any role for the Congress. This has Professor Organ Failure, John Yoo, and "unitary executive" written all over it.

Sunday, December 30, 2007

For only $200, you too can be rehabilitated!

Canada takes DWI very seriously. It's a felony in Canada and can make you inadmissable to Canada if you're a US citizen. (If you are a Canadian citizen, they have to take you back.) For the most part, of course, a DWI, especially the first one, is not a felony in the US. Well, okay, fair enough. But that's not the end of it.

You see, you can still get into Canada. You'll just get trimmed of an extra $200 bucks:

Canadian immigration officials say that in many cases, would-be visitors with minor records are provisionally admitted -- either by paying about $200 in U.S. money for a temporary permit or paying the same amount and following a months-long process to "rehabilitate" their record permanently.

So, if you're a practicing alcoholic, you may be able to drive into Canada by paying $200, but if you've had a single Friday night indiscretion, and you're on a bus but without the necessary cash, you won't get in.

Gee, Spotty, that sounds like it is more about the raising of some revenue than keeping inebriated drivers out.

That's what Spot was thinking, too, grasshopper.

Technorati Tags: , ,

Thursday, December 27, 2007

The last Spotty of 2007!

Spotty, why don't cops often write blogs?

Because they're like lawyers: generally not very funny.

But you told us about a funny one once.

Ah, yes, the Discordian Stooge who writes At the Hillocks of Hysteria. He is pretty funny. In fact, DS wins a Spotty™ for a post he wrote a few days ago. It's called A Public Service Announcement Followed Me Home the Other Day. Here's the opening graf:

People call the police for a lot of strange reasons. Many calls involve criminal or suspected criminal behavior. Others involve people with honest to god problems that the police are in a position to help with (e.g. Cars stuck in the middle of the street; Lost stuff that needs to be given to somebody). Then there are the other calls ...

What follows are several vignettes of citizens misapprehending the function of law enforcement. A couple of examples:

What you should do in your personal life, however, is another matter. I don't know if you should let so-and-so move in with you. Chances are, I haven't met the person. I'm not an accountant, and can't tell you what to do with your money (I will advise you not to store hundreds of thousands of dollars in the crawlspace under your house, though, if you ask). I can't enforce a non-existent court order to get your kids back from Dad's house when you are unwilling to go get them yourself.

If a bouncer kicks you out of a bar, it was for a good reason. I can't get you back in (and probably wouldn't even if I could). If the bouncer insulted you, that's not a crime, and I don't know what you should do to get over the experience. Maybe find a therapist. Or another bar.

That's just the beginning. Go and read the rest. Humans, you gotta love 'em!

Remember, boys and girls, a Spotty™ is awarded to the author of an op-ed piece, a letter to the editor, or a blog post or comment that Spot wishes that he had written. In addition to the award, and in accordance with practice here at The Cucking Stool, an award winning blog also gets a place on the blogroll.

Wednesday, December 26, 2007

A Very Katie Christmas!

The scene: a darkened bar frequented by reporters. A man walks in, stamps the snow off his feet, and notices a tall, astringent stranger at the bar nursing what looks like a double whiskey neat. Yet, she looks familiar somehow. Of course! Now he recognizes her. He walks up and sits beside her.

Hello, Katie. I don't think I've ever seen you here before.

Oh hi, Nick. And I prefer Kathy.

I know, Katie, I mean Kathy; I'll try. What's the matter?

As you may know, Monday—the day for next my column—is Christmas Eve.

That oughtta be a natural for you.

I know! But I've wracked my brain trying to tie in condemnation of gays, Muslims, or even public schools, into the Christmas Story, but nothing is coming up. All this "peace" and "good will" stuff has got me all stopped up.

Maybe I can help.

You?

What do you mean, me? Of course, me. I've been a newspaperman a lot longer than you, and I've plowed through writer's block a time or two myself.

Really? Would you do that for me?

It is Christmas, and we are [shudder] colleagues.

That would be great! What do you suggest?

Well, first maybe you should drop the polemics for Christmas Eve.

You think so? That might confuse some of my readers. It would be really hard for me, too.

Ah, you can do it, Katie—Kathy. I've got it! You could write about a private act of charity. That would be killing two birds with one stone, so to speak.

That's a great idea, Nick. I know this white woman who has been really nice to a Hmong family for three years! I could call her a "surrogate Santa," or do you think "surrogate Santa" sounds too much like "surrogate mother?"

Nah, works for me. It's actually the kind of white man's burden story you like, only subtle for the holidays, I mean Christmas.

You're right! What do you think of this line?

Santa is very much alive, full of magic and mirth, and ... living in Maple Grove.

Gripping, give me some more.

How about:

You may imagine Santa ho-ho-hoing in a state-of-the-art workshop amid a wonderland of prosperity. In fact, Schulz [the actual kind lady in question]-- like many Americans -- doesn't have a lot to spare, though she has one of the largest hearts you'll ever encounter.

The imagery is magic, Katie.

Kathy.

Right. Any more good details you can flesh out?

Well, "Santa's" grandchild got little May [a little one in the Hmong family] a "Hello, Kitty!"

I'm sorry, did you say "Hello Katie?"

No, silly, "Hello Kitty." Maybe you'd know if you had a daughter among those three rug rats you have at home.

It sounds like you have the situation under control. Just be sure to peg the saccharine meter!

Oh, I will, Nick. Thanks for the help. [rises to leave, downs the rest of her whiskey, throws a quarter on the bar for a tip, and departs]

[to the bartender] I didn't need a drink when I came in here. But I do now. Bushmills neat.

Sunday, December 23, 2007

Yeah, and Merry Christmas to you, too!

This story won't be up much longer at the Strib, so Spot reproduces it entirely:

Muslim student's aid in New York City subway attack leads to interfaith friendship

Associated Press

Last update: December 12, 2007 - 5:13 AM

A suspected bias attack on four Jewish subway riders has resulted in a friendship between the Jewish victims and the Muslim college student who came to their aid.

Walter Adler is calling Hassan Askari a hero for intervening when Adler and three friends were assaulted on a subway train in lower Manhattan on Friday night.

The altercation erupted when Adler and his friends said "Happy Chanukah" to a group yelling "Merry Christmas" on the Brooklyn-bound train.

The 20-year-old Askari said he tried to fight off the 10 attackers, giving Adler a chance to summon police by pulling an emergency brake.

"I did what I thought was right," said Askari, a student at Berkeley College in Manhattan, who was allegedly punched and beaten. "I did the best that I could to help."

Eight men and two women have pleaded not guilty to assault, menacing and other charges in the case. Prosecutors have said the charges could be upgraded to hate crimes.

"That a random Muslim kid helped some Jewish kids, that's what's positive about New York," said Adler, 23, who suffered a broken nose and a lip wound.

This happened on a Friday night, the beginning of the Sabbath for Jews, during Chanukah. Have a Merry Christmas, or we'll kick your ass!

The interesting twist on this story is, of course, that the guy who broke the thing up was a Muslim. A really gutsy Muslim at that. Talk about not having an, er, dog in the fight! It's enough to make one stop and think when he hears Peace on earth and good will to men! from the pulpit tomorrow night.

Friday, December 21, 2007

Spot's DL Christmas!

After a rush through post production today.

 

 

Update: After a hectoring by the video scolds, and you know who you are, Spot presents Spot's DL Christmas postcard.

 

 

 

Thursday, December 20, 2007

Katie, come in here a minute

Sure Mr. Tice, what's up?

I just read your column this morning.

Boy, it was zinger, wasn't it? I made a pun on "seasonal creep" and everything! I think it was one of my best efforts. What did it go? 350 words?

You have no idea what I am thinking about, do you?

[smiling, but a little uncertainly] That you really liked the column?

[smiling back, but tiredly] It was, well, acceptable, IN A VACUUM!

What do you mean by that?

On Monday, you wrote about the religious influence of Muslims at Normandale Community College. And you seemed to take a dim view of it, championing a view of the separation of church and state.

That was another good one, wasn't it?  My good friend Scott Johnson picked that one up, He even said:

One might wonder how news of this breakdown in the wall between church and state becomes the preserve of the Star Tribune's lone conservative columnist. Perhaps the creeping Islamization of Twin Cities public schools is no longer newsworthy.

I know that Scottie thinks you're special, Katie.

[Katie smiles, less uncertainly] Yes, he does!

But your current column clouds up and rains all over a couple of people at the University of Minnesota who seem to be trying—although perhaps a little clumsily—to keep religion out of Christmas—I mean holiday—parties at the University, which is, after all, a public institution.

Whatcher point?

Don't you see at least a little inconsistency between lambasting an educational institution on Monday for making religious accommodations, and then criticizing another educational institution on Thursday for failing to be tolerant of religious observance?

[frowning, and thinking for a long moment] I guess. But it's different somehow.

How?

On Monday, I was talking about Normandale and the, well, you know.

You mean Muslims?

You make them sound so, so human.

I'm sorry Katie, but have you ever looked at it from the Muslim perspective?

Like you have.

Have too.

Have not.

Have too. At any rate, I want you to try really hard to be at least logically consistent between Monday and Thursday. Do you think you can do that?

I'll try, Mr. Tice. Thank you.

[walking out] Have not.

Have too.

DL festivities tonight!

Remember, boys and girls, tonight is the Drinking Liberally winter solstice party at the 331 Club. Spot will be observing Christmas, and many others there will be too. Santa? Spot doesn't think he will. But he'll be there!

Bring an unwrapped toy or gift for Toys for Tots which Santa has graciously agreed to deliver for us. You might think about something for an older kid.

That's tonight from 6 o'clock to 9 o'clock at:

331 Club
331 13th Avenue NE
Minneapolis

The 331 Club is at the corner of University and 13th NE.

Wednesday, December 19, 2007

Amy, are you there?

Spot tried to take his own advice on contacting Amy Klobuchar about FISA. This is the email address you get if you click the "Email Senator Klobuchar" link on her Senate webpage: senator@klobuchar.senate.gov.

But when you send a message to that address, this is what you get back:

This is an automatically generated Delivery Status Notification
Delivery to the following recipient failed permanently:
senator@klobuchar.senate.gov
Technical details of permanent failure:
PERM_FAILURE: SMTP Error (state 13): 550 5.1.1 <senator@klobuchar.senate.gov>... User unknown

The senator may be wondering why she isn't getting more email about this subject! Spot suggests that you make a phone call.

Technorati Tags: ,

Spoliation

Today’s word is spoliation, Grasshopper.

Hey, wait! What are you doing here? Isn’t Spotty supposed to be the one giving us lectures about legal concepts?

Spot’s busy drinking water out of the toilet, Grasshopper, so calm down and listen.

Ok, ok. What’s that big word again?

Spoliation. It’s used in legal circles to describe the act of losing or destroying evidence by someone who is in the middle of a lawsuit or who can expect to be embroiled in one pretty quickly.

But wait, who would want to destroy evidence, Ms. Observer? Don’t you need evidence to prove your point in a trial?

Well, yes, Grasshopper, that’s true. It would be hard to show the jury how things happened without physical evidence about the event in question. But sometimes the evidence doesn’t always prove what you want it to prove. In fact, sometimes it’s downright damaging to your case.

What happens then? Do you get to pretend it’s not there or get rid of it?

No, that’s not supposed to happen. First of all, it’s wrong, violates all sorts of rules, and can even be a criminal act. But sometimes evidence gets lost or destroyed anyway. Sometimes innocently, sometimes not so innocently. Imagine if, say, your garage burned down and you are convinced it was because something in that car caught on fire and destroyed your garage. But – whoops! – you accidentally (or not so accidentally) junk the car before the folks from the auto manufacturer get a chance to have their people look at it to determine that it wasn’t that bad electrical component, but rather that cigarette you left burning in the car.

Wow, if I were the manufacturer, I’d be mad! I couldn’t defend myself! What happens then?

Usually what happens is that the judge at trial will tell the jury that there used to be a car, that the car (while under the control of the now garage-less plaintiff) was destroyed, and that they can draw an adverse inference from the fact that the car is gone and unavailable for inspection. That means that the judge will instruct the jury that they are free to assume that an inspection of the car would have revealed facts that would tank the plaintiff’s case. Our garage-less plaintiff will be able to argue that he didn’t mean to destroy the car, but the jury is free to laugh in his face and say, “Yeah, sure, pal.” Such cases do not turn out well for plaintiffs and this rule about “adverse inferences” actually serves as an incentive for people to preserve evidence, even evidence that is bad for them.

I think I see why, but I have one more question. Why is this all important to us, Ms. Observer?

Well, Grasshopper, you’ve undoubtedly heard that there are some videotapes that purport to show the torture of some Guantanamo Bay prisoners who were being interrogated, tapes that were destroyed back in 2005. Well, it appears that these tapes might have been destroyed after a judge presiding over a lawsuit brought by some Yemeni nationals challenging their incarceration ordered that such tapes be preserved.

So what does that mean?

Most judges don’t take very well to having their orders ignored or disobeyed. United States District Judge Henry H. Kennedy, Jr., the judge in this case, has set a hearing for 11 a.m. Friday to discuss the destroyed tapes. I’m glad I’m not the lawyer representing the United States going in to that hearing. Judge Kennedy might be kind of crabby.

Wow, so that means that if terrorism suspects get to trial and they claim that the people being tortured actually said “No, not him! He’s not a terrorist, he’s just a shoe repairman from Kabul!” there might be some problems?

Now I think you’re starting to understand, Grasshopper.