Monday, February 18, 2008

Steve Sarvi pulls out all the stops

Steve Sarvi, candidate for Congress in the 2nd district, gets serious about fund raising. Steve was at DL a couple of weeks ago.

Jack Nelson-Pallmeyer on the race for the DFL endorsement

Again from his session at Drinking Liberally:

Spot has gotten some emails congratulating him on the JNP videos. Although there is a credit at the end of each one, it bears repeating that the videographer is Jonathan Carlson of Epic Media.

Update: But the bone-head editing is by somebody else.

Actually, it's Cary Teague

This one is for the boys and girls out here in Cakeville:

In December, the Edina City Council directed the Director of the Planning Department to consider additional changes to the city's zoning ordinance to deal with the" McMansion" issue and report back to the Council. Mr. Teague does not seem enthusiastic or well-suited to the task. He has, remember, the valet parking concession for builders at city hall.

As Spot recalls, the Council was going to consider additional zoning changes in about 90 days; that's coming up pretty soon now.

Technorati Tags: , , ,

Saturday, February 16, 2008

Nelson-Pallmeyer talks about Iraq at DL

At his DL session, Jack Nelson-Pallmeyer fielded a couple of questions about Iraq:

Friday, February 15, 2008

Nelson-Pallmeyer's remarks at Drinking Liberally

Jack Nelson Pallmeyer was at Drinking Liberally last Thursday. He offered some remarks to the group, and then he took some questions. Here's his comments:

Some of the Q and A will be posted in subsequent videos.

Thursday, February 14, 2008

Drinking Liberally - Bring your sweetheart

Remember Drinking Liberally at the 331 Club tonight, six to nine, with a visit by Jack Nelson-Pallmeyer around seven.

Technorati Tags:

Wednesday, February 13, 2008

Jack Nelson Pallmeyer on climate change

There are some videos out there of Senate debates. Here's a clip of Jack Nelson-Pallmeyer's comments about climate change from a debate at Roosevelt High School last November.

Remember, Jack will be at DL tomorrow night.

On behalf of the future

Spot noticed the re-emergence of a couple of perennial issues at the Legislature this year: bonding for road and bridge repair and a dedicated sales tax for the environment. Now, Spot thinks that all these things are good ideas, but he thinks that future generations ought to be given the opportunity to disagree. Here are Spot's musings about some of these same things from a couple of sessions ago:

It seems that everyone in Minnesota these days has a plan to tie up or bind the future in a way that takes a pet political issue off the table. It is sort of like writing in a will that Johnny is disinherited if he marries Jill (or Jack!) or fails to go to medical school, or whatever. Boys and girls, let’s look at some examples.

The gay marriage amendment ban is the pre-eminent example. Moral clucks like Katie who have an out-sized view of their own moral understanding and authority want to decide the issue of gay marriage rights not only for themselves, but for others and for the future. On behalf of the future, Spotty is offended. But Katie is not the only one.

The governor’s proposal to borrow a few billion dollars and try to bond our way (the governor calls it “investment”) out of the transportation mess in Minnesota is another. By refusing to raise more gas tax revenue (Spot has posted too many times about the governor’s veto of the transportation bill with a dime a gallon increase last year to link to), the governor is proposing tie the hands of future generations who will be saddled with the debt service on things we should have paid for out of current revenues.

And how will we pay that debt service? Well, the governor says, the dedication of the motor vehicle sales tax to transportation, on the ballot for a constitutional amendment this fall, will cover it.

Presently, the motor vehicle sales tax goes into the general fund. The state is barely in the black, as you know, boys and girls. Dedication of funds currently unallocated will result in shortages elsewhere, as City Pages writes in the article The Road to Perdition. More binding the hands of the future. [This is now law, boys and girls, perhaps exacerbating the current budget shortfall.]

One final example: Ron Schara writes today about an effort to pass a constitutional amendment to dedicate a portion of the general sales tax to natural resource protection. The environment is an issue pretty close to Spotty’s heart, but again, we’re trying to tell the future how to spend its money. Maybe the future will decide, if a depression comes around, that it would rather spend the money to keep people from starving. Shouldn’t the future be able to make that choice?

Each of these cases springs from a belief that the proponent knows best for all of us for all time, coupled often with a desire to avoid present responsibility for what we want.

Spotty says consider these issues with humility before you decide you know what is best for future generations.

We hire the Legislature to make these decisions for us. It's a frustrating bunch sometimes, but Spot prefers it to the dead hand reaching into the future.

JNP @ DL!

That looks like an email address, Spotty.

No, no, grasshopper, it's a text message. It means DFL candidate for US Senate Jack Nelson-Pallmeyer will be at Drinking Liberally tomorrow night for a meet and greet, and perhaps offer a few words. Jack is a terrific speaker with a great grasp of the issues. Be sure to come, grasshopper; you'll probably learn something from the professor.

We will, Spotty. Where and when again?

The 331 Club in Northeast Minneapolis, a block north of Broadway on University. Here's a map. The usual meeting time is six to nine. Jack is slated to arrive around seven. But he'll probably be on Candidate Standard Time, so don't grouse if he is a little late.

We won't Spotty!

See you there.

Tuesday, February 12, 2008

Who you gonna call? Mythbusters!

Health care policy is really not Spot's thing. But it's not Sticks or Janet's thing, either. If you read the links to Spot's earlier posts, you will see that the Canadian Mark Steyn certainly isn't the answer.

But Sara Robinson just may be. She wrote a two-part series: Mythbusting Canadian Health Care. Here's part ONE; here's part TWO.

Both Sticks and Janet quote Mark Steyn's cautionary tale of a woman who had to wait ten months to deliver quadruplets, and when she did, she had to go to the United States to do it: Ten month wait for a maternity ward. The quads were actually delivered early, but never mind.

Here are just a couple of Sara's observations from part one:

Canada's health care system is "socialized medicine."
False. In socialized medical systems, the doctors work directly for the state. In Canada (and many other countries with universal care), doctors run their own private practices, just like they do in the US. The only difference is that every doctor deals with one insurer, instead of 150. And that insurer is the provincial government, which is accountable to the legislature and the voters if the quality of coverage is allowed to slide.

The proper term for this is "single-payer insurance." In talking to Americans about it, the better phrase is "Medicare for all."

.  .  .

Wait times in Canada are horrendous.
True and False again -- it depends on which province you live in, and what's wrong with you. Canada's health care system runs on federal guidelines that ensure uniform standards of care, but each territory and province administers its own program. Some provinces don't plan their facilities well enough; in those, you can have waits. Some do better. As a general rule, the farther north you live, the harder it is to get to care, simply because the doctors and hospitals are concentrated in the south. But that's just as true in any rural county in the U.S.

You can hear the bitching about it no matter where you live, though. The percentage of Canadians who'd consider giving up their beloved system consistently languishes in the single digits. A few years ago, a TV show asked Canadians to name the Greatest Canadian in history; and in a broad national consensus, they gave the honor to Tommy Douglas, the Saskatchewan premier who is considered the father of the country's health care system. (And no, it had nothing to do with the fact that he was also Kiefer Sutherland's grandfather.). In spite of that, though, grousing about health care is still unofficially Canada's third national sport after curling and hockey.

And for the country's newspapers, it's a prime watchdogging opportunity. Any little thing goes sideways at the local hospital, and it's on the front pages the next day. Those kinds of stories sell papers, because everyone is invested in that system and has a personal stake in how well it functions. The American system might benefit from this kind of constant scrutiny, because it's certainly one of the things that keeps the quality high. But it also makes people think it's far worse than it is.

Critics should be reminded that the American system is not exactly instant-on, either. When I lived in California, I had excellent insurance, and got my care through one of the best university-based systems in the nation. Yet I routinely had to wait anywhere from six to twelve weeks to get in to see a specialist. Non-emergency surgical waits could be anywhere from four weeks to four months. After two years in the BC system, I'm finding the experience to be pretty much comparable, and often better. The notable exception is MRIs, which were easy in California, but can take many months to get here. (It's the number one thing people go over the border for.) Other than that, urban Canadians get care about as fast as urban Americans do.

.  .  .

You don't get to choose your own doctor.
Scurrilously False. Somebody, somewhere, is getting paid a lot of money to make this kind of stuff up. The cons love to scare the kids with stories about the government picking your doctor for you, and you don't get a choice. Be afraid! Be very afraid!

And here's one that Spot wants Janet, who worries so about health-care rationing to read:

Publicly-funded programs will inevitably lead to rationed health care, particularly for the elderly.
False. And bogglingly so. The papers would have a field day if there was the barest hint that this might be true.

One of the things that constantly amazes me here is how well-cared-for the elderly and disabled you see on the streets here are. No, these people are not being thrown out on the curb. In fact, they live longer, healthier, and more productive lives because they're getting a constant level of care that ensures small things get treated before they become big problems.

The health care system also makes it easier on their caregiving adult children, who have more time to look in on Mom and take her on outings because they aren't working 60-hour weeks trying to hold onto a job that gives them insurance.

And from part two:

Government-run health care is inherently less efficient -- because governments themselves are inherently less efficient.
If anything could finally put the lie to this old conservative canard, the disaster that is our health care system is Exhibit A.

America spends about 15% of its GDP on health care. Most other industrialized countries (all of whom have some form of universal care, either single-payer or entirely government-run) spend about 11-12%. Canada spends about 8-9% -- and most of the problems within their system come out of the fact that it's chronically underfunded compared to those other nations. If they spent what the UK or Germany do, those problems would mostly vanish.

Any system that has people spending more and getting less is, by definition, not efficient. And these efficiency leaks are, almost entirely, due to private greed. There is no logical way that a private system can pay eight-figure CEO compensation packages, turn a handsome a profit for shareholders, and still be "efficient." In fact, in order to deliver those profits and salaries, the American system has built up a vast, Kafkaesque administrative machinery of approval, denial, and fraud management, which inflates the US system's administrative costs to well over double that seen in other countries -- or even in our own public systems, including Medicare and the VA system.

Not incidentally: one of the benefits of single-payer health care is that it largely eliminates the entire issue of "fraud." You can only "cheat" a system that already views its primary business as rationing and withholding care. In Canada, where the system is set up to deliver health care instead of profits, and medical access is considered a right, this whole oversight machinery is far cheaper and more compact. In general, the system trusts doctors and patients to make the right choices the first time. As a result, people generally don't have to lie, cheat, and grovel to get the system to deliver the care they need. They just go and get it -- and walk out without a moment's dread about the bills.

Shareholder profit, inflated CEO salaries, and top-heavy administration -- all of which serve to work against the delivery of care, not facilitate it -- are anti-efficiencies that siphon off 20-25% of America's total health care spending. These are huge sums; yet it's mostly money down a gold-plated rathole. In the end, it doesn't provide a single bed, pay a single nurse or doctor, or treat a single patient.

We'll have rationed care
Don't look now: but America does ration care. [are you paying attention, Janet?] And it does it in the most capricious, draconian, and often dishonest way possible.

Mostly, the US system rations care by simply eliminating large numbers of people from the system due to an inability to pay. Last year, one-quarter of all Americans didn't go to a doctor when they needed one because they couldn't afford it. Nearly that many skipped getting a test, treatment, prescription, or follow-up appointment recommended by a doctor. In Canada, those same numbers are in the 4-5% range; in the UK, 2-3%. Also: nearly 20% of all Americans had a hard time paying a medical bill last year; and these stresses now trigger over half of all personal bankruptcies in the country.

Furthermore, nominally having health insurance is no guarantee against financial ruin, as Sicko amply illustrated. Being cut off or denied by your insurance company is rationing, too. And there are vast numbers of fairly well-off Americans -- many of them middle-aged, and too young for Medicare -- who have pre-existing conditions that render them uninsurable at any price. They're one heart attack, one diabetic event, or one bad turn away from financial disaster. Please don't insult these people by telling them that the American system doesn't ration care.

Another persistent (and ridiculously mendacious) rationing myth about the Canadian system is that old people are cut off from treatment and left to die. I've never heard about a single case of this in Canada; but it happens routinely to Americans on Medicare and many private policies, which have strict limits on how long you can stay in the hospital with an acute illness. When the benefits run out, ready or not, they send you home. If you die, you die. The Canadian plan has no such limits: you stay for as long as you need to. But in the US, these limits fit the very definition of "rationed care."

Effectively shutting one-quarter of the population out of the medical system entirely, and putting many of the rest on short rations, certainly does make things so much nicer for those happy few who are still in it. In fact, Americans have these missing millions to thank for their system's impressively short wait times. Only 4% of American have to wait more than six months for non-elective surgeries, while 14-15% of Canadian and Britons do. (Don't blame this on government care, though: in Germany and the Netherlands, the number is closer to 2%.) When conservatives start bellowing about Canada's terrifying wait times (which, by the way, are carefully triaged: it's rare for people to die waiting, though it happens), we need to remind them that there are 75 million Americans who have been wait-listed forever. If my friend's Aunt Millie gets her emergency hip surgery today because I'm willing to hobble along for an extra couple months before getting my knee surgery -- well, for any morally serious person, that choice should be a complete no-brainer.

Spot has probably already cribbed more than he should, but these are two really excellent posts. Read them, print them off, and use them in discussion with the gas bags.

Update: Nick Coleman has a good column today profiling a Minnesota legislator and her experience with the efficient health care system we have in the US:

Shelley Madore has lived through the health care crisis. Even though she had health insurance, Madore was nearly bankrupted when her kids became ill. And the financial and emotional strains of the ordeal helped lead to the end of her marriage, too.

But Madore didn't take her troubles lying down. She stood up. And ran for election. And won. Now, she hopes to change a rotten system from the top.

Madore, 45, is a DFLer from Apple Valley who ran for the state House of Representatives in 2006 after encountering the indifference of legislative leaders to people in her situation. At the time, Madore and her husband, Paul, were earning about $50,000 a year and struggling to make the payments on their modest home and the $908 monthly premium on their health insurance.

Monday, February 11, 2008

Is that what's got you down?

Can't choose between Clinton and Obama? Is that what's got you down, Bunky?

Here are a couple of things that will help you choose:

Obama vs. Clinton

A Calumny a Day To Keep Hillary Away

Ha ha.

Bitch, bitch, bitch

Steve Sack in the Strib on Sunday:

And here's the lede in an op-ed by political science professor Kathryn Pearson in the Strib today:

In my political science courses, I stress that the "rules of the game" matter. This is evident in Minnesota's caucus system, which purportedly values citizen deliberation and engagement in the political process, but at great cost to widespread citizen enfranchisement.

You would almost think that the caucuses last Tuesday night were an abject failure, not the most successful precinct caucuses in this old dog's memory. Any human endeavor is fraught with peril and the prospect of error. And there were undoubtedly errors in the process last week. But nobody who Spot is aware of is claiming the kind of shenanigans that may have occurred in the Washington State Republican caucuses this weekend. Or that the people who were selected to their district or county conventions fundamentally misrepresent public or party opinion.

But compared to, say, getting Hannah Montana tickets, or shopping the day after Thanksgiving, admit it people: the caucuses were pretty easy. The parties run the caucuses and they are staffed by volunteers. Keep that in mind when forming your criticisms of the process.

Spot agrees that "widespread citizen enfranchisement" is a good thing, but getting out of the Barcalounger for a couple of hours every four years to express a preference for president of the United States isn't that big a burden.

Professor Pearson not only doesn't like the caucuses for indicating presidential preference, she doesn't like it for other state and federal office either:

When it comes to the selection of candidates for state and federal office [other than president], the caucus system is even more undemocratic. Delegates to congressional and state conventions are selected at precinct caucuses in a haphazard way. Among the many caucus-goers I've spoken to, only one attended a caucus that selected delegates on the basis of sub-caucusing for specific Senate candidates. The rest simply took the names of volunteers with no discussion of the candidates whatsoever.

Of course, the reason that the people who volunteered to be delegates were not quizzed more closely about their choice for senator or congressman/woman is that most precincts had room for anyone who wanted to be a delegate to be one. From what Spot hears, that happened in some heavily-DFL precincts in Minneapolis and St. Paul, too. There was absolutely nothing to prevent anyone from asking who the delegate volunteers supported. Perhaps there is room for the discussion of a more formal primary system for presidential preference - and a discussion of who will pay for it - but what would you have us do for the other offices, professor?

[crickets] . . . [/crickets]

One of the things that caucuses do is test the organization of a candidate, especially among the activists; usually this is a good thing. But not always; think of the sitting Republican governor Arne Carlson who couldn't get his party's endorsement for re-election. (This was a shameful episode in Republican politics, in Spot's opinion.)  Remember, the candidates are competing for an endorsement, not the nomination. The party's endorsed candidate can still be challenged in the fall primary, as Carlson did when he challenged the party's endorsed candidate, Alan Quist, and Arne thankfully won. But it's mostly the activists who will be drop literature, make phone calls, and host fund raisers necessary to get a candidate elected.

Caucuses also favor the better retail politicians. They are one of the few things that stand in the way of entirely media-driven campaigns. Spot likes that and says it is healthy for democracy.

Hope, only different

Via the Dependable Renegade:

Technorati Tags: ,

Sunday, February 10, 2008

Spot tries; he really does

What do you try to do, Spotty?

Avoid reading SCSU Scholars, but sometimes his mind drifts, and he winds up reading something like this:

Before addressing specific fallacies of so called "single payor" (ie government) systems, check this site that includes a graph that corrects life expectancy data for differences in the rates of premature death from non-health-related injury, such as homicide and car accidents. Once these non-health-related injuries are excluded, Americans live longer than anyone else, even with our obesity problem.

So, in other words Janet (the author of that gem), if you manage to avoid getting shot or dying in a bridge collapse, you'll do pretty well in the US, longevity-wise. Boy, that's great!

The balance of Janet's little homily is a screed against "socialized" medicine. Let's be sure we know where Janet is, well, coming from.

This morning, Janet's socialized alarm clock (powered by electricity from a private utility whose status as a corporate entity with limited liability for that nuclear accident is provided by the government, and whose ability to distribute that electricity depends on the power of eminent domain it got from the government), puts her size twelves on a socialized toasty warm floor warmed by a gas utility (see comments about the electric company, supra), takes a socialized shit flushed away by a municipal utility, perhaps eats a private-sector breakfast (but there are probably subsidies in there somewhere), brushes her teeth with socialized water, and then drives her car down a socialized road to work at a socialized public educational institution, or maybe church, since today is Sunday.

And then the thoughtful Janet pens a post criticizing Al Franken for suggesting that health care services might be more economically delivered with a "single payer" system. Not single provider: single payer. Think Medicare, which has a much smaller percentage overhead burden than the private Rube Goldberg system that most of us "enjoy."

You see, boys and girls, the word "socialized" is a Very Bad Word to Janet, never mind that she really doesn't know what it means. She's afraid that health care will be "rationed." All economic goods are rationed, one way or another Janet. Otherwise, they are "free goods," like, until recently, air and water. The only real question is how we ration - or allocate - these goods. Janet is clearly a proponent of "all for me and none for thee" school. But is that really the best way to allocate health care? Janet is a known quantity to society in terms of her utility, but some uninsured poor kid might be the next Einstein, that is, if he gets to grow up. Janet clearly is not.

But Janet thinks she can wave the word "socialized" around like a priest with an incense pot and scare the single-payer goblin away. And for the superstitious, it might work. The torch and pitchfork crowd, that is.

Anyway, the centerpiece of Janet's argument is Mark Steyn's ten-month gestation story that Spot posted about before. There's not much more to say, except that Spot is really tired of the cheesy sloganeering on this issue by people like Janet and Mark Steyn.

While sluggards sleep

Rather than trying to describe it to you, boys and girls, here's the opening graphs of Katie's column today, Sunday.

At 6:30 a.m. on a freezing Friday in February, the lights are dark on Frat Row near the University of Minnesota campus. Some students may be sleeping off last night's party, while others are just sleeping in.

An 8 a.m. class? Get real.

But drive down a few blocks, then take a sharp right [get it?] at the U of M Armory. It's a different predawn world there, as 120 young men and women sweat through a grueling workout of timed runs, push-ups and sit-ups.

Katie tells us how thrilling it is that Golden Gopher Army ROTC battalion (now there's a name to strike fear into the hearts of terrorists everywhere!) ranks have swelled from 47 to 120 in recent years.

Boy, that's great, Spotty! How many students go to the University of Minnesota?

You could look it up, grasshopper, but Spot thinks it is about 51,000. And the GGAR draws from other local colleges, too:

These are the cadets of the Golden Gopher Army ROTC battalion. About 75 percent are U of M students; the rest are drawn from nine other metro-area colleges.

Let's lay the other nine colleges aside for a moment, grasshopper. What is 47 divided by 51,000, expressed as a percentage?

Just a second. Spotty, it's .092 percent.

Right, grasshopper. Now, perform the same calculation on 120 and 51,000.

It's .26 percent, if we round that second decimal up.

Right again. Do you think that is a statistically significant difference  to show an increase in student interest in the military life as Katie suggests?

Probably not.

Spot think it may have as much to do with the declining affordability of college for many people as a lust for the military life, although Katie did quote a couple of the more gung-ho types. And the cadets do get paid. Katie asks rhetorically:

Why drag yourself out of bed on a winter morning when your fellow students are still catching zzz's? Is it the free tuition and living stipend that ROTC offers?

College assistance has always been one draw to the military. GI Bill and all that.

But here's the best part yet for Katie:

Army ROTC doesn't have that "everybody's special," feel-good philosophy so prevalent today. Cadets across the nation are ranked from top to bottom during their junior year -- from first to 4,099th.  . . .

As Spot has observed before, Katie loves hierarchy. Katie hates the idea of an egalitarian world; if she can't be better than some people, she has no self-esteem. Spot suspects that she is a product of conditional parental love. Lord knows what kind of a parent she turned out to be.

Friday, February 08, 2008

Drinking Liberally last night

Well, did any of you boys and girls go to the 331 Club for DL last night?

I did Spotty, but there weren't any DL people there!

Of course not, grasshopper, because DL was at the Chatterbox in St. Paul last night. If you had been paying attention, you would have known that.

Sorry, Spotty.

Did you at least wish Alisha Happy Birthday? (It's tomorrow.)

No, I didn't know it was her birthday.

Now you know, so be sure to tell her next week, okay?

We will, Spotty!

Grasshopper, what you missed was a chance to meet Steve Sarvi, a DFLer who is running for Congress in the Second District and for the seat currently held by John Kline.

Sarvi spoke about his time in Iraq and the bond he forged with a mayor in a town in Iraq. He spoke about the issues that we face in Iraq: tribal and sectarian distrust, de-Baaathification (Sarvi expressed some reservations about it), and and the slow pace of reconciliation and progress in the Iraqi government. He also spoke about making health care universal and portable.

Steve had just come from a press conference in St. Paul making the formal announcement of his candidacy. Here's a picture of Steve addressing the DL group:

Steve has some young supporters, too. Here's Robin Marty (a DL organizer, among other things) and her two-month old daughter Violet:

"An amended report correcting this error will be filed when the committee's internal audit has been completed" Part 2

The financial woes of the Republican Party of Minnesota seem to be harbinger of similar woes at the National Republican Congressional Committee. We've mentioned the state party's ongoing and unresolved financial accounting problems before, and yesterday, Minnesota Monitor had a recap of the NRCC scandal and its Minnesota Connections.

Well, things appear to be going from bad to worse for the NRCC:
Rep. Mike Conaway (R-Texas), a certified public accountant, had pushed for months for an internal audit of the National Republican Congressional Committee, according to GOP members, but the committee’s treasurer at the time was reluctant.

Finally, at a recent meeting, the now former NRCC treasurer, Christopher J. Ward, relented, giving Conaway what was supposed to be an official internal audit from 2006. That document was a fake, the GOP members said. Even the letterhead on which it was sent was a forgery.

Revelations about the falsified document touched off an unfolding scandal that has rocked the NRCC and spurred a criminal investigation by the FBI into the committee’s accounting procedures.

And the Minnesota Connections don't just stop at Mr. Ward's position as treasurer of the Bachmann, Coleman, and Kennedy '02/RPM leadership PACs. The chair of the NRCC's management team is Minnesota's Rep. John Kline:
Cole told his colleagues that he wasn’t sure if the committee had done a real audit since 2001, and that could open the door for a lengthy and expensive review of the committee’s financial records.

Cole spoke to members with notes detailing what he could – and could not – say, according to one member present. Conaway and Rep. John Kline (R-Minn.), who chairs the committee’s management team, also spoke.

So the next time you hear one of our local GOP attack dogs hounding a Democratic office holder about some picayune, unfounded technical transgression that is almost immediately found to be lacking probable cause, be sure to ask if it's better to have no audit or a faked audit.

Tuesday, February 05, 2008

Spot's excellent adventure!

When he turned south off of Vernon Avenue onto Tracy Avenue and found himself in an immediate traffic jam, Spot knew something BIG was happening. When he inched over the Crosstown nearly an hour later, he knew it was REALLY BIG; there were cars backed up as far as one could see on the Crosstown for the Tracy Avenue exit. When Spot parked his car a half a mile from Valley View Middle School, where the Edina DFL caucuses were held, and walked the rest of the way, he knew it was a caucus like he had never seen before.

And it was.

The caucuses were mobbed. In Spot's precinct, the vote was one-eighty something to seventy something, Obama over Clinton. Or was it one-seventy something to  eighty something? Either way, it was about two to one for Obama. This in an Edina precinct that did NOT go for Kerry in 2004 (most of them did). There were a lot of people Spot had seen before, but a lot of new ones, too. A great night, all in all.

Garrison's daughter not doing well in school

In a recent Salon piece, reprinted in the Strib on Sunday, Garrison Keillor bemoans the state of education, particularly reading:

And then there is the grief that old righteous people inflict on the young, such as our public schools. I'm looking at U.S. Department of Education statistics on reading achievement and see that here in Minnesota -- proud, progressive Minnesota -- on a 500-point test (average score: 225), 27 percent of fourth-graders score below basic proficiency, and black and Hispanic kids score 30-some points lower than white on average, and the 30 percent of public schoolkids who come from households in poverty (who qualify for reduced-price school lunches) score 27 points lower than those who don't come from poverty.

Reading is the key to everything. Teaching children to read is a fundamental moral obligation of the society. That 27 percent are at serious risk of crippling illiteracy is an outrageous scandal.

This is a bleak picture for an old Democrat. Face it, the schools are not run by Republican oligarchs in top hats and spats but by perfectly nice, caring, sharing people, with a smattering of yoga/raga/tofu/mojo/mantra folks like my old confreres. Nice people are failing these kids, but when they are called on it, they get very huffy. When the grand poobah Ph.D.s of education stand up and blow, they speak with great confidence about theories of teaching, and considering the test results, the bums ought to be thrown out.

But Garrison, the schools have been funded, or rather unfunded, by the "no new taxes" crowd for a long time now; a lot of them do wear top hats and spats. Maybe teachers are liberals, but they aren't miracle workers. Kids in poverty in general do worse in schools? Of course they do. Poor kids live in poor neighborhoods without much of a property tax base to fund the shortfall, growing every year, in the school aid formula. Not to mention all the other strikes that poor kids come in against them. Making the schools scapegoats for these problems is shameful, Garrison.

GK continues:

Liberal dogma says that each child is inherently gifted and will read if only he is read to. This was true of my grandson; it is demonstrably not true of many kids, including my sandy-haired, gap-toothed daughter. The No Child Left Behind initiative has plenty of flaws, but the Democrats who are trashing it should take another look at the Reading First program. It is morally disgusting if Democrats throw out Republican programs that are good for children. Life is not a scrimmage. Grown-ups who stick with dogma even though it condemns children to second-class lives should be put on buses and sent to North Dakota to hoe wheat for a year.

If you follow the link in Keillor's little tirade, it leads not to support for his flimsy proposition that "[l]iberal dogma says that each child is inherently gifted and will read if only he is read to," but rather just a list of recent "liberal" articles on Salon.

This is the cheesiest of straw man arguments, unworthy of Keillor, really. One has to conclude that something else is at work here. The school is an easy lightening rod when a parent is unhappy with a child's progress. Spot thinks perhaps that's what afoot here.

Oh, and it doesn't sound like Keillor likes reading to his daughter much, either.

Goodbye to All That

In 1970, Robin Morgan wrote a break-through essay declaring goodbye to all the sexism she experienced in the new left. Today, thirty-eight years later, she has finally published a follow up, taking on the way two communities, the "joint conscience-kepers of this country," have been so manipulated. Go read it:
Goodbye to a campaign where he has to pass as white (which whites -- especially wealthy ones -- adore), while she has to pass as male (which both men and women demanded of her, and then found unforgivable). If she were black or he were female we wouldn't be having such problems, and I for one would be in heaven. But at present such a candidate wouldn't stand a chance -- even if she shared Condi Rice's Bush-defending politics.

* * *

She's a high-profile candidate with an enormous grasp of foreign- and domestic-policy nuance, dedication to detail, ability to absorb staggering insult and personal pain while retaining dignity, resolve, even humor, and keep on keeping on. (Also, yes, dammit, let's hear it for her connections and funding and party-building background, too. Obama was awfully glad about those when she raised dough and campaigned for him to get to the Senate in the first place.)

I'd rather look forward to what a good president he might make in eight years, when his vision and spirit are seasoned by practical know-how -- and he'll be all of 54. Meanwhile, goodbye to turning him into a shining knight when actually he's an astute, smooth pol with speechwriters who've worked with the Kennedys' own speechwriter-courtier Ted Sorenson. If it's only about ringing rhetoric, let speechwriters run. But isn't it about getting the policies we want enacted?

* * *
Me? I support Hillary Rodham because she's the best qualified of all candidates running in both parties. I support her because she's refreshingly thoughtful, and I'm bloodied from eight years of a jolly "uniter" with ejaculatory politics. I needn't agree with her on every point. I agree with the 97 percent of her positions that are identical with Obama's -- and the few where hers are both more practical and to the left of his (like health care). I support her because she's already smashed the first-lady stereotype and made history as a fine senator, because I believe she will continue to make history not only as the first U.S. woman president, but as a great U.S. president.

As for the "woman thing"?

Me, I'm voting for Hillary not because she's a woman -- but because I am.


I'll work for and support whoever the Democrats nominate, but my vote at the caucus tonight will be for her.