Tuesday, September 07, 2010

Tom Horner's big lies

Independence Party gubernatorial candidate Tom Horner is betting his campaign on two false claims: The first is that his tax and spending proposals are not regressive, and the second is that it is impossible to hit rich Minnesotans with higher tax bills without compromising the state's competitiveness and job environment.

In order for a third party candidate to win the governor's office in Minnesota he or she must draw sizable numbers of voters from both Democrats and Republicans. Otherwise he merely becomes a spoiler, splitting one unlucky party and ensuring the election of the candidate who carries his own party's voters. As a former staffer for a Republican Senator and a professional flack Tom Horner is spinning false tales about taxes and spending. He's hoping a public convinced that all politicians are extremists in the Teabagger fashion will fall for lies about the impact of income tax increases on the wealthy and about the effects of his plans to close a $6 billion state budget shortfall.

In 2002 former Democrat Tim Penny ran as an independent and siphoned off 16 percent of the vote - mostly Democrats -  leaving Tim Pawlently the winner with only 44 percent of the vote - not even close to a true majority. In 2006 another former Democrat, Peter Hutchinson, ran as an independent but failed to get many votes from either party, ending up with a paltry six percent of the vote, making the election more like a traditional Minnesota governor's race. Hutchinson managed to siphon off enough liberals and moderates to allow Pawlenty to win again, but this time only by one percent of the vote.

This year a former Republican, Tom Horner, is trying to thread the political needle by carving away enough traditional partisans to follow the footsteps of Jesse Ventura into the statehouse. Only Horner has neither the celebrity nor the personality of a Ventura, making his task that much the harder.

As a former "moderate" Republican Horner should automatically pick up the marginal Republican voters who aren't religious or ideological crackpots like the ones who have run the state party since the 1990s. The core Republicans are so extreme they wouldn't even nominate a sitting governor of their own party - Arne Carlson - for governor in 1994.

Horner might be popular with whatever is left of those moderates following the party's  nominating for governor an empty suit who essentially lobbies for drunk drivers, can't do budget math, doesn't show up for votes, and who promotes family values but has an out of control family.

But that block of disaffected sane Republicans isn't nearly enough to be elected governor. A recent MPR poll shows Horner getting only 13 percent of the vote, with 19 percent still undecided and the Democrat Dayton and Republican Emmer tied at 34 percent. The high undecided share shows that many Minnesotans have not yet tuned into this race, making the poll highly suspect.

Still, even if Horner were to get every one of those undecided votes he would still be two percent behind Emmer and Dayton.  So how does Horner peel off votes from either Dayton or Emmer and prevent his long campaign from being simply a vanity project?

Usually Minnesota Independents running for governor merely position themselves as "centrists," opposed to the supposed extremes of the two major parties. In reality this is a joke. Only the state Republicans are extreme; the Democrats, if anything, lack a spine on any issue, and have been held out of the governor's mansion for more than two decades. Still - this is the prime play being made by Horner as exemplified by his inept and frankly creepy ad campaign.

The MPR poll, for what it's worth,  had Horner getting 15 percent of the Democratic vote, 26 percent of the Independent vote (compared to Dayton's 23 percent), and only nine percent of the Republican vote. The MPR story asserts, without quotes, that Horner is "not yet attracting the kind of support he anticipated from Republicans, his former party." It would be hard to imagine a Republican gubernatorial candidate getting less than 34 percent of the vote (even though Democrat Skip Humphrey managed just 28 percent against Ventura), so, unless Dayton opens up a large lead in the polls,  the chances of Horner getting more than his current nine percent of the Republican vote seems unlikely.

That means to win Horner must peel off large chunks of Democratic and Independent voters -- certainly more than his current three point lead with independents over Dayton. Winning those voters is directly at odds with winning more hard-core Republicans, so it seems there is no "centrist" path to victory that includes more Republican votes, and his centrist claims are more a pose to appear reasonable than a political reality.

On the surface Democrat Mark Dayton's campaign of increasing taxes on the wealthy would seem to alienate him from a certain percentage of voters, potentially opening up some space for Horner between Republican Emmer's no new taxes strategy and himself. In reality, a large proportion of Americans believe in Dayton's approach; just last month a nationwide poll showed a whopping 69 percent in favor of letting the Bush tax cuts on the top two brackets expire. Just a year ago a Minnesota Poll showed that two-thirds of voters in the state are cool with increasing taxes on the rich.

And therein lies Tom Horner's big, unspoken problem. In an era of severe political polarization his two gubernatorial opponents have actually staked out diametrically opposed positions on taxes and spending, leaving Horner to try and split the baby in half. Unfortunately for him the Republican half of the baby, being virulently anti-tax,  is virtually unavailable to him. Any attempt to make members of his former Republican Party pay more in taxes not only shuts off his hopes for more of their votes, it might actually threaten the paltry nine percent he's already got.

The fact that two thirds of the state is okay with raising taxes on the rich closes Horner's economic box. Mark Dayton's alignment with majority views on taxing the rich forces Horner to find some way of appealing to Independents and Democrats that won't alienate his rich friends. Horner needs to simultaneously make it appear that he will reverse the disinvestment of the Pawlenty administrations while not hurting the wealthy taxpayers who have skated during those years. That means either drastic further cuts in spending, or getting more money from low and moderate income voters. Unfortunately for Horner, those low and moderate income voters will essentially be deciding the election.

To thread this needle Horner is relying on an economic slight of hand, claiming that Dayton's proposed taxes on the rich will hurt businesses and competitiveness in the state. Instead of engaging the tax debate on a fairness or moral basis, he instead is essentially saying that  raising taxes on the rich hurts everyone. Horner's technocratic argument has the advantage, for him, of not having to overtly choose whose ox gets gored in the process of raising the revenue needed to operate a modern American state. The argument has the disadvantage, if one cares about honest discourse, of not being true, and obscuring who will really pay the bill in Tom Horner's Minnesota.

It is really a two-fold lie that Horner is telling Minnesota. First, he's telling voters that his proposed budgeting will not disproportionately hurt the poor, even though he claims to be able to save $2.5 billion through unspecified budget cuts, and raise another $2 billion from expanding the state sales tax and increasing sin taxes on alcohol, tobacco and gambling, all three of which disproportionately affect poorer citizens. Over at the Rowdy Crowd blog Horner himself admitted this fact, blithely advising the less affluent to merely not indulge in those activities if they don't want to finance the lifestyles of his rich friends. Horner may be an Independent these days, but that sounds a lot like Republican class warfare.

Though he claims to support establishing a tax-credit fund to offset these regressive actions, there are no details, nor is there any guarantee that that fund will end up in real legislation, where a governor Horner would probably have to negotiate with his former allies in the Republican Party.

But Horner's biggest lie is his gambit against Democrat Mark Dayton's plan to raise taxes on wealthy Minnesotans. According to Horner's slippery formulation it is impossible to raise income taxes on the rich without harming small business and job creation.  Several studies have attempted to assess the impact of raising income taxes on the wealthy; the most recent is more than a decade old, and even that one predicted minimal jobs losses - fewer than a thousand - and is fraught with uncertainties. 

Really there is no need to get into the weeds on this issue - Horner is basing his campaign on an unproven  assertion about the behavior of wealthy tax payers, all to avoid having them pay their fair share of taxes. Horner is further conflating Dayton's plan to tax wealthy tax payers with taxing business, which is plainly false. Income taxes are paid on income (profit), not on revenues. Profit is what is left over after deducting expenses. He's essentially saying that small business owners will forgo investment in their businesses, even if it would increase corporate profits - all for the sake of paying a lower personal income tax rate, which is irrational. It is plainly advantageous or at least a wash for businesses to increase revenue and profits even if it means paying a larger share of a bigger profit in taxes. Who's to say which would be more advantageous to individual tax payers - paying a lower rate of smaller profits, or a higher rate on larger profits? It is anything but the clear cut picture that Horner paints of higher income taxes on the wealthy leading to lower competitiveness and overall job losses.

The impact of increased taxes on the wealthy is further confused by what is done with those increased revenues to the state. If the money is used for things like building infrastructure, hiring teachers, or providing health care, those expenditures would necessarily increase employment. Improved infrastructure also has the undeniable impact of increasing productivity in the future, in effect making everyone wealthier.

The difficulty in analyzing Horner's economic statements puts journalists in a quandary since most do not have the time nor expertise to evaluate his claims. Hence, they are ignored and he gets to assert as fact dubious claims that when repeated create a false impression about Dayton's tax plans. This confusion is no accident - it is required for Horner to fool Independents and Democrats into believing that his economic plan is equal or superior to Dayton's in terms of revitalizing Minnesota's economy and job picture. If he can at least confuse the picture enough to neutralize Dayton's tax-the-rich plan - the basis of his campaign - on technocratic grounds he has opened up the electoral field.

It's hard to say if Horner's centrist scam and economic lies will work; if it doesn't it won't be from lack of support from the Star Tribune. This past Sunday the paper had no fewer than three items that fall for Horner's narrative: The first describes a new Horner TV ad and is headlined "Tom 'common sense' Horner releases new ad." Nothing like catapulting the propaganda, huh? The second doesn't mention Horner specifically, but hits at the supposed extremists in "major parties" headlined "Minnesota pushes back at partisan extremes." The third is a misleading and slanderous op-ed by the Republican propagandist Doug Tice, who both edits and writes for the commentary page, in which he declares, in a statement cynical even for him, that "I fully endorse the view that all politicians are scoundrels," who then goes on to parrot Horner's spin, calling him a "sensible" candidate selling "grown-up medicine." Notice that not one of these newspaper items attempts to asses the virtues or veracity of Horner's claims. No need to wait for the paper's endorsement editorial the weekend before the election - we already know who it is lining up behind.

Tom Horner is an experienced PR professional - a skilled spinner of the dark arts. He is dishonestly positioning himself as a centrist, with an economic plan that he says won't hurt the poor and middle class. It is apparent by now that the state's major newspaper is going to help him with this campaign. It remains to be seen if voters who really care about the decline of our state will fall for it.

And you thought that Andrew Mellon was dead

This morning, the Strib had one of those point/counterpoint op-ed pages — so beloved by the MSM — on the issue of financial stimulus. Mark Weisbrot has the affirmative, while Andrew Mellon has the negative:

The Keynesian solution was wrong when it was first proposed, and it's wrong now. Stimulus doesn't help one whit. Tax cuts and austerity do.

Really, that’s William Shughart II (sounds better than “Junior” apparently; wonder if his dad is William Shughart I) channeling old Andy.

But here’s the genuine Andy on what do in the teeth of the Depression:

Mellon became unpopular with the onset of the Great Depression. He advised Herbert Hoover to "liquidate labor, liquidate stocks, liquidate farmers, liquidate real estate… it will purge the rottenness out of the system. High costs of living and high living will come down. People will work harder, live a more moral life. Values will be adjusted, and enterprising people will pick up from less competent people."[7] Additionally, he advocated weeding out "weak" banks as a harsh but necessary prerequisite to the recovery of the banking system. This "weeding out" was accomplished through refusing to lend cash to banks (taking loans and other investments as collateral), and by refusing to put more cash in circulation. He advocated spending cuts to keep the Federal budget balanced, and opposed fiscal stimulus measures. In 1929-31, he spent much of the time overseas, negotiating for repayment of European war debts from World War I. In February 1932, Mellon left the Treasury Department and accepted the post of U.S. Ambassador to the United Kingdom. He served for one year and then retired to private life.

You know why he left his Treasury post, don’t you? He was impeached by the House, but Hoover sent him into exile in England for a while before the Senate could try him, rendering a trial moot.

I have always loved the Mellon quote. Here’s a guy, like so many financial quacks, born with a silver foot in his mouth (allusion cheerfully stolen from Molly Ivins, RIP), never knowing a day of want in his life, but ever ready to point out the path of grace for everybody else.

And Shughart Two could be Andy Two.

Let’s turn to Paul Krugman to describe the situation:

The U.S. economy has been crippled by a financial crisis. The president’s policies have limited the damage, but they were too cautious, and unemployment remains disastrously high. More action is clearly needed. Yet the public has soured on government activism, and seems poised to deal Democrats a severe defeat in the midterm elections.

That sums it up pretty well doesn’t it?

But here is where the economic historian in Krugman drops the bomb:

The president in question is Franklin Delano Roosevelt; the year is 1938. Within a few years, of course, the Great Depression was over. But it’s both instructive and discouraging to look at the state of America circa 1938 — instructive because the nature of the recovery that followed refutes the arguments dominating today’s public debate, discouraging because it’s hard to see anything like the miracle of the 1940s happening again.

Now, we weren’t supposed to find ourselves replaying the late 1930s. President Obama’s economists promised not to repeat the mistakes of 1937, when F.D.R. pulled back fiscal stimulus too soon. But by making his program too small and too short-lived, Mr. Obama did just that: the stimulus raised growth while it lasted, but it made only a small dent in unemployment — and now it’s fading out.

Just how did we get out of the Depression, finally?

Consider Gallup polling from March 1938. Asked whether government spending should be increased to fight the slump, 63 percent of those polled said no. Asked whether it would be better to increase spending or to cut business taxes, only 15 percent favored spending; 63 percent favored tax cuts. And the 1938 election was a disaster for the Democrats, who lost 70 seats in the House and seven in the Senate.

Then came the war.

From an economic point of view World War II was, above all, a burst of deficit-financed government spending, on a scale that would never have been approved otherwise. Over the course of the war the federal government borrowed an amount equal to roughly twice the value of G.D.P. in 1940 — the equivalent of roughly $30 trillion today.

And tax rates during the war went way up.

I’ll bet most of the boomer readers here remember being taught in government and economics classes in high school that a Depression could never happen again, because we’d wised up on how to prevent them.

One of my other favorite quotes is from Karl Marx. But it could have been Groucho.

History happens twice; the first time as tragedy, and the second time as farce.

Here’s one you may have missed in your corn dog induced stupor

Team Torture is still on the job

But Professor David Luban didn’t. This is a story about the continuing infection of the legal landscape by George W. Bush’s “Team Torture.”

Today the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals overturned the conviction of Daniel Millis, convicted of littering because he left sealed bottles of drinking water in a desert wildlife refuge. He explained that he left them "along frequently traveled routes for unlawful entrants to the United States." He belongs to a group called "No More Deaths," and the opinion quotes his testimony: "humanitarian aide [sic] is never a crime."

This will never do, of course, because it is much cheaper and better if these people just die in the desert, rather than be rounded up and deported, or even worse, get a job picking lettuce.

The Ninth Circuit found that calling sealed water bottles “litter” or “garbage” an, um, stretch. But not Team Torture alum Jay Bybee, who dissented.

Judge Jay Bybee - he of the torture memo - dissents. Littering is littering, and Bybee finds that the regulation is as clear as a sunny day in the desert. This is the same Jay Bybee who thinks that terms like "torture" and "severe suffering" are so vague that it would be unfair to apply statutes prohibiting them to interrogators who waterboard people and keep them awake for a week at a time, naked and hanging in chains.

You really do have to appreciate such a fine legal mind. Remember, Bybee has a lifetime appointment.

Monday, September 06, 2010

Emmer's Budget Plan? Increase the Deficit

Tom Emmer's strung along Minnesota voters for months with promises of a plan to balance the state budget without raising taxes on anybody. Today we found out that he plans on reducing revenue by at least $626 million dollars in the next biennium. Actually, it's "more than that," Emmer told a reporter at his Labor Day press conference at Permac Industries in Burnsville.

This news conference displayed the full blast of Emmer's condescension; calling the media "impatient" for wanting details of his plans, chiding Mark Dayton for not having the Department of Revenue run the numbers on his (actual) budget plan, and declaring windily "they just don't get it."

Watch live streaming video from theuptake at livestream.com


You're right, Rep. Emmer, we don't get it.

We don't get how you can increase an already nearly $6 billion deficit by more than $700 million and declare that this deficit is "only on paper" because the government "wants to grow." Tell that to the students whose schools who would see a $2 billion dollar shift become a permanent cut, or to the people who would lose their health coverage. They're just "on paper."

We don't get why you continue to propose programs that you voted against (small business tax credits), or decry the lack of programs that already exist and that you also voted against (Veterans GI bill.)

We don't get why you think Indiana is a paragon of job creation to be emulated when they have an unemployment rate over 10%, a rate 3% higher than Minnesota. Or why you think South Dakota is some sort of economic powerhouse when their economy pales in contrast to ours, "high taxes" and all.

We don't get why you chose a site for your news conference that happily accepted government funds that you find wasteful. A federal stimulus program called the TANF Emergency Fund was used by Minnesota to increase subsidized hiring through country workforce programs. Permac President Darlene Miller gushed about the program just 4 days ago:
“The subsidized jobs program has provided us with a wonderful way to identify dedicated and dependable workers like Royal,” said Permac Industries President Darlene Miller. Permac Industries has hired five employees through the jobs program, expanding Miller’s business while training candidates for unsubsidized positions.
Let's be clear, I think this program is great. But TANF is what Emmer calls "welfare" and stimulus funds are what he calls "waste." Despite Permac President Miller's declaration that they received no federal stimulus dollars ("it was a county program,") Minnesota used these federal funds to double the number of subsidized positions. Her subsequent amnesia is highly suspect, considering she was happy to be used as an example in the Center for Budget and Policy Priorities news release supporting the federal program.

But what we really don't get is why you think no one will notice that the only details in your plan to balance the budget have taken you even further away from balancing the budget.

You said you didn't want to peak on September 1st. At this point it looks like you peaked on April 30th.

Follow me on Twitter @aaronklemz

Sunday, September 05, 2010

Sheila, you already jumped the shark

The Suttonese Libelization Army

Several days ago, The Activist Next Door put up a post accusing Mark Dayton of not having been a school teacher in New York City!

I pointed out that absence of proof is not proof of absence, and Charlie debunked the breathless report without stirring from his chair.

Now, the same blogger intimates that Mark Dayton was a draft dodger because he was opposed to the Vietnam war; no proof of course; it wasn’t even a good innuendo.

She admits that she was too young to experience that era; she’s apparently unaware that many people opposed the Vietnam war; some were drafted, some weren’t.

For your real gold-plated draft dodger, though, you have to look at a guy like Richard Bruce Cheney. Or even George W. Bush.

Saturday, September 04, 2010

"Bullying is a Serious Issue"


Some have chosen to frame the Tripp Emmer Facebook Photo Fiasco as a matter of underage drinking. It's not. As we pointed out in our earlier post, the more important issue is about the conduct of a paid staffer/endorser toward an incapacitated young woman.

Of course, Tripp Emmer is not a minor, nor would his actions have been subject to the anti-bullying law that his father voted against. But juxtaposing Tom Emmer's position on anti-bullying laws with this episode is illustrative.
"I'll tell you right now, bullying is a serious issue. You're talking to the parent of seven kids - Jacquie and I have seven kids - we're very, we're very aware of what happens when a child is faced with an uncomfortable situation at school or out in a public place. But tell you what, it's up to the parents, Jacquie and I, to educate our children, how they handle that situation. We're the ones who have to be the front line of defense for our children. I don't want the government doing that for us."
- Rep. Tom Emmer, explaining why he won't commit to signing anti-bullying legislation, September 3, 2010 (State Fair Debate, around 28:00 mark)

How do you think he would react if the photo above was of a young man posing next to his daughter after someone had drawn penises on her arms and cheek? As you think through this, remember, this is someone's daughter. How would Emmer respond to a tearful phone call from his daughter after she had spent fruitless hours attempting to scrub away the marks of her "uncomfortable situation?" How would he act as a "front line of defense?" (Or would she even make that call?)

Could turning the scenario around change the boys-will-be-boys-wink-and-nudge routine exemplified by this "man on the street" reaction captured by John Croman at the Minnesota State Fair?
"It's just kids being kids," [fairgoer Ace Bartkowicz] said, "what can you say? Everyone's doing something they're not supposed to be doing. Who are we to cast judgment when we probably did something similar to that ourselves?"
One of the staple beliefs of the libertarian right wing is that laws that affect minors cause parents to lose their authority. Rep. Emmer and former buddy and Campaign Manager Rep. Mark Buesgens' opposition to laws that restrict teen drivers provide an example of the argument. While the law is different, Buesgens' statement on Almanac clearly summarizes the principle:

"The problem . . . is it allows parents to abdicate their responsibility, and that's a slippery slope. At the end of the day, we need people to be responsible. And when you only do things because government says it's right or wrong is when we lose our own sense of moral responsibility and that's a bad direction for society to be taking."

For Emmer and his ideological brethren, the family is under assault from a nanny-state government that seeks to usurp its natural authority. In his campaign story, Emmer's family is a prop, a shining example of the blessings of liberty, and the future of a Minnesota freed from nattering nanny-state busybody liberals. You know, the same busybodies who try to prevent kids from being bullied into depression, even suicide.

It's the difference between empathy for the bully and a desire to keep the matter "in the family," and empathy and justice for the bullied. In short, it's the difference between identifying with the unmarked, and identifying with the marked-upon.

Even in the libertarian utopia of the Emmer household, where parents are responsible and not government, misconduct happens. Young adults frequently do stupid and harmful things, and part of the process of growing up is learning about the consequences of these actions. But violence and intimidation have devastating impacts on the victims, and to see actions like those depicted above as solely the purview of the family is wrong. The "man on the street" dismissal of Tripp Emmer's trophy hunting photo as "boys will be boys" and Emmer's justification for opposing anti-bullying laws spring from the same philosophy.

While Rep. Emmer practically invites people to hold his parenting responsible for the actions of his campaign staffer/endorser/son, that's not really the point. These photos and the actions depicted therein are now part of the Emmer campaign narrative of small government, family values, rugged individualism, and social darwinism/bullying, whether he likes it or not.

Follow me on Twitter @aaronklemz

Thursday, September 02, 2010

Tripped up

Don’t blow your wad in the first period. Tom Emmer, Jr.

That’s advice from dad to son.

On learning about the indiscreet Facebook photos of Tripp Emmer's underage drinking in the City Pages' story that was published today, we were inclined to dismiss them because the families of candidates aren't ordinarily legitimate campaign material. On reflection, though, this one is different, and it is different on multiple levels.

This is unlike the abuse heaped on Amy Carter or Chelsea Clinton by the likes of Rush Limbaugh.

Tripp Emmer is an employee of the Emmer for Governor campaign. Candidate Emmer has also sought the limelight for his children in the campaign, including Tripp, who offered an endorsement of his father in the current Emmer television commercial. It wasn't just a seven year old saying, "Vote for Daddy!" either. Tripp made a statement about lowering taxes and reforming government.

The moral character of a spokesman and endorser in such a case is a legitimate issue. If you don't think so, consider what happened to Tiger Woods when it became known what a philanderer he was. That's harsh, all right, and it would be too harsh here if it was only a little underage drinking. But it's not only a little underage drinking. Here is the most disturbing photo from the City Pages' Facebook photos (there are several), on the left.

trippemmer6closeUSE Picture 4

That's Tripp Emmer, grinning and giving the thumbs up over an unconscious young woman who has had penises crudely drawn on her cheek and arm.

Let’s be direct: this is assault.

And the picture on the right?  It’s a screen shot taken from the Emmer campaign commercial linked above. It’s about fifteen seconds into the video, and it shows Tripp Emmer giving the “thumbs up” after taking out the trash. A job well done in both cases, eh?

The Emmer campaign has mostly avoided talking about traditional family values issues in this campaign, supposedly focusing on bread-and-butter economic issues. It can do this by using the Emmer family as an enthymeme. Look at Tom Emmer's fecundity! He's pro-life! Just a big, good old fashioned heterosexual family here! Just like his patron Sarah Palin, Emmer's learned that you don't to say a word about these issues; you just need to use your family as a prop. And like Bristol Palin, Tripp Emmer's demonstrating that when you use your family as an symbol, their conduct becomes relevant.

Consider also the role of innuendo in the Republican effort: the recent episode of Luke Hellier "raising the spectre" of documents from Mark Dayton's divorce being "removed from the public record." This was viewed by some to be a fishing expedition that backfired, but the purpose was no more complicated than reminding everyone that Dayton's been divorced.

In a campaign where no one will talk about social issues like reproductive freedom and gay marriage directly, all that is left is whispering and innuendo.

Steve Timmer and Aaron Klemz

Update #1

I’ve decided to move this up from the comment stream (I left the comment):

Here's a serious sounding Kate Parry talking to David Brauer about why the Strib didn't run the story:

Where is that bar? Parry says the circumstances are complex. If the arrest had been for a DUI, it would’ve been more serious and upped the chances of seeing print; had there been damage to property, same thing.

So, Kate, if Tripp and his buddies drew penises on the wall, rather than a girl, you would have published the story?

Update #2

I’ve gotten some comments and email about whether the conduct shown in the photograph is assault. Just college kids being college kids! I don’t think so, but even if it is, it’s assault. Here’s a little exercise to show you why.

Let’s say you’re standing at a corner in downtown Minneapolis, waiting for the light to turn, and a college boy, perhaps drunk, comes up to you and says, “I want to draw penises on your face and body.” You tell him politely, but firmly, “no.” He does it anyway.

That’s assault, whether you’re harmed beyond the scrubbing needed to remove the penises or not. You would be entitled to defend yourself against the penises being applied, too.

The situation of the unconscious young woman is no different. She is entitled to say “no” to the obscene drawing on her body, and she is also entitled to defend herself against them. But she can’t, because she is unconscious. This brings up a very important concept in the law: an unconscious person cannot give consent to be drawn on, to be undressed, or to be raped. There are no exceptions for drunken college boys.

Update #3

A belated thump of the tail to MNO for calling the CP story, and especially the photo above, to our attention.

Drinking Liberally: help kiss summer goodbye

331-panorama-grainy-b&w-wit

The Labor Day weekend is coming up. The kids will be in school soon (or already are); the state fair (no logo) is winding down. Come and observe the end of the season tonight at Drinking Liberally.

We’ll be at the 331 Club in Northeast Minneapolis from six to nine (and probably later). Hope to see you there.

One Million Six!

Republican bean counter and statistician Michele Bachmann eyeballed the assembled at Beckmania, and cried that there were 1.6 million sycophants who laid siege to the Lincoln Memorial to hang on the Word of Beck. Let’s compare that with other famous invasions in history.

The Normandy Invasion on D Day

On D-Day, the Allies landed around 156,000 troops in Normandy. The American forces landed numbered 73,000: 23,250 on Utah Beach, 34,250 on Omaha Beach, and 15,500 airborne troops. In the British and Canadian sector, 83,115 troops were landed (61,715 of them British): 24,970 on Gold Beach, 21,400 on Juno Beach, 28,845 on Sword Beach, and 7900 airborne troops.

The Battle of Gettysburg

In July of 1863, General Robert E. Lee's Army of Northern Virginia of 75,000 men and the 97,000 man Union Army of the Potomac, under George G. Meade, concentrated together at Gettysburg and fought the Battle of Gettysburg.

The Battle of Waterloo

The French army consisted around 69,000 soldiers with 250 guns, 7,000 artilleries, 14,000 cavalries, and 48,000 infantries. To fill in the ranks of the French army throughout the rule, Napoleon had used conscription but he did not conscript men for the campaign in 1815. All of the troops in the French army were veterans and had been already involved in one or more campaign already. The cavalries of the French army were both formidable and numerous. It also include 7 highly versatile lancers and 14 regiments of heavy and armored cavalry. Meanwhile the armies under the Coalition only had armored troops and Wellington only had a handful of lancers.

Wellington admitted that he had inexperienced, ill-equipped, very weak, and infamous staffs in his army. His troops only consisted of 67,000 soldiers with 150 guns, 6,000 artilleries, 11,000 cavalries, and 50,000 infantries. 24,000 of the soldiers in the troop were British and another 6,000 were from the King’s German Legion. All of the British soldiers in the troops were regular soldiers wherein 7,000 of there where veterans of the Peninsular War. In addition to Wellington’s army there were 3,000 soldiers from Nassau, 6,000 from Brunswick, 11,000 from Hanover and 17,000 Dutch troops.

According to Bachmann, Beck marshaled ten times the Allied landing forces on D Day, about sixteen times the men that the Union Army had in the field for the battle of Gettysburg, and over twenty times the men fielded by Napoleon at Waterloo.

Impressive. Or something.

Wednesday, September 01, 2010

I regret the error

Republicans in Minnesota have been reaching to personally tar Mark Dayton for some time now - sadly aided by innuendo about the Gubernatorial candidate's mental status offered by some otherwise friendly and rational websites (looking at you, Rowdy Crowd).

Last week one Luke Hellier harassed Dayton at a press event announcing his endorsement by the Minneapolis Police Officers union, demanding that he release documents from his second divorce that had been removed from the court record. Hellier implied that Dayton had something to hide in the documents. In its unfortunate headline, Minnpost.com declared that Dayton had "gained...a new controversy."

Smelling blood in the water, the stooges over at Powerlineblog jumped on the smears, accusing Dayton and his lawyers of having the documents removed. Only now it turns out that the documents were removed by attorneys for Dayton's ex-wife, not the candidate, implying they were more about protecting her reputation than his. Without changing the post, Scott Johnson at Powerlineblog merely appended a short correction, said, "I regret the error," and moved on.

The incident, more than anything, proves how selfless, stable, and magnanimous Dayton himself is - refusing to even comment on the incendiary implications of the charges leveled by the human slime that is the Minnesota GOP.

Scary News!

Click on the picture for the full story.

Capture

License smischense

Absence of proof is not proof of absence

The Dayton campaign offered this today to show his teaching credentials in New York:

dayton-license

Minnesota’s version of Orly Taitz was on the case, doubting whether Mark Dayton was a teacher in New York. It remains to be seen whether she will now claim that the license is a forgery or a clever ruse, issued by the Board of Education in 1969 to give Mark Dayton a cover story in 2010.

A thump of the tail to the Twitter.

Update: It is hardly surprising that forty year old personnel records in New York City cannot be “found.” But Charlie has the whole story.

Tuesday, August 31, 2010

Tax the Rich: DWI Edition

Here's a note from the "wouldn't this be a fun campaign proposal" desk.

Consistent with Mark Dayton's "make the richest Minnesotan pay their fair share of taxes" slogan, I propose that Minnesota adopt a system of DWI enforcement that levies fines proportional to income and assets. Something like this:
A Norwegian businessman was ordered Tuesday to pay a fine of 700,000 kroner (80,000 euros, 109,000 dollars) for driving 400 meters while drunk, a court said.

Due to the man's wealth, the court in the southern Norwegian county of Aust-Agder handed down a heavier-than-usual sentence, which would normally be equivalent to a month-and-a-half's gross salary for the accused.

"The principle of proportionality implies that we should take into account the entire wealth of the person in cases where the defendant is more well off than most other people," a copy of the verdict obtained by AFP read.

The 49-year-old man is the heir of a rich shipping family.

His wealth totalled 228 million kroner (26 million euros, 35.5 million dollars) in 2008, when he had a gross annual income of around 752,000 kroner.
The framing you'd get from such a proposal would be brilliant: Let's talk about DWIs again! It's consistent with Dayton's revenue raising strategy, only it's harder to feel sorry for the job creators that are weaving all over the road.

In all seriousness, the deterrent effect of DWI fines are proportional to the income of the offender. Other Scandinavian countries have adopted the "day-fine" approach to equalize the impact of fines on offenders who have different incomes.

Additionally, there's a strong disincentive for prosecutors to go after wealthier people with lawyers over DWI offenses, and a strong incentive to plead them down. This is part of the reason that Tom Emmer has convictions for lesser offenses despite the involvement of alcohol. On the other hand, working class folks end up experiencing the full force of the law and the fixed fine has a much larger impact on them.

And since we're being serious for a moment, you could earmark these fines for enhanced enforcement efforts and mandatory ignition interlock devices for offenders, which would address the two factors that are most often cited in reducing DWI's - strong penalties and more certainty of being caught.

Follow me on Twitter @aaronklemz

Mark Dayton’s churlish luncheon companion

Imagine, if you will, a lunch hosted by Mark Dayton for Power Line’s Scott Johnson and a “friend.”

First of all, which of these two is more likely to have the poor taste to talk about the lunch?

And second, which one is more likely to have been the churlish companion?

At a charity auction in 1994 or so I won the opportunity to have Mark Dayton take me and a friend to "power lunch for two" at the Minneapolis Club. The lunch occurred toward the end of Dayton's tenure as the Minnesota state auditor. The lunch was extremely unpleasant because Dayton seemed to be unable to disagree agreeably. [ ]

So, we know it was Scotty who has the poor taste to talk about it, but Scotty says Dayton was the unpleasant one.

Run that one through Louis Nizer’s Rule of Probability, boy and girls, and see what you come up with.

Scotty’s rich story telling ability was brought to bear here as a preamble to a real scoop obtained by the Republican cub reporter Luke Hellier:

It turns out that affidavits filed by his wife were removed from the court file of his second divorce. They appear to have been removed by Dayton's attorney on Dayton's behalf [ ] and their removal was resolved by a subsequent court order returning most of the the divorce file to the parties.

Except, of course, they weren’t removed on Dayton’s behalf. Oops.

I took out the reference to a correction in the quote above, because I wanted it to be a surprise for you, boys and girls. Here it is, from the same post:

Luke Hellier has corrected his MDE post to reflect that the affidavits were removed from the court file by the attorney for Dayton's wife, not by the attorney for Dayton. That seems to me to make it more likely that the affidavits raised issues personally sensitive to Dayton's wife rather than to Dayton. I regret the error. [But he doesn’t regret the smear.]

You have to love the guys at Power Line. They certainly do. They are each others’ favorite commenters — in fact, they are each others’ only commenters. They’ll pop in on somebody else’s post, snap a few towels, and engage in some locker room jocularity. John, the performer formerly known as Hind-rocket, did it on this one:

JOHN adds: In 2006, Alan Fine was the Republican nominee for the Congressional seat that Keith Ellison ultimately won. At that time, the Minneapolis Star Tribune took a gleeful interest in Fine's ten-year-old divorce proceeding. The Strib's coverage was misleading at best, and was based on court files that may have been leaked illegally. Will the Strib show a similar level of interest in Mark Dayton's personal history?

I know, I know. Just kidding.

Just for the record, there were police reports of domestic abuse in the Fine case.

Monday, August 30, 2010

Unaware who their gods really are

From a James Kunstler post today:

[  ] The masses still truly believe that prayer will save them from bankruptcy, foreclosure, penury, the loss of status, and the cut-off of precious air-conditioning, so Glenn steps onto a national monument like an Aztec priest ascending the Pyramid of Huitzilopochtli [I added the link] to soothe the angry god with worshipful incantations, and incidentally maybe a few dozen sacrificial hearts cut out -- just as the tea-bagger right-wing glorifies the sacrifices of US soldiers blown up by roadside bombs for the sake of American military adventuring in lost causes like the war to turn Afghanistan into a functioning western-style democracy.

Glenn Beck's sidekick nowadays, Sarah Palin, is exactly the kind of corn pone Hitler that America deserves: a badly-educated, child-like, war-mongering opportunist easily manipulated by backstage extremist billionaires who think they don't have enough money yet. Sarah Palin is going to run for president in 2012. In the process she'll turn the sad remnants of the Republican party into a suicide cult, but she might just get elected and you can kiss the 230-year-long experiment in representative government goodbye for good.

“Backstage extremist billionaires who think they don’t have enough money yet.” Gosh, I wonder who Kunstler could be referring to? Could it possibly be, inter alia, these three?

There’s just one element missing from these snapshots [the lower Manhattan mosque protests and Glenn Beck at the Lincoln Memorial] of America’s ostensibly spontaneous and leaderless populist uprising: the sugar daddies who are bankrolling it, and have been doing so since well before the “death panel” warm-up acts of last summer. Three heavy hitters rule. You’ve heard of one of them, Rupert Murdoch. The other two, the brothers David and Charles Koch, are even richer, with a combined wealth exceeded only by that of Bill Gates and Warren Buffett among Americans. But even those carrying the Kochs’ banner may not know who these brothers are.

Your average Tea Partier almost certainly does not know who’s behind the “movement.” It’s a movement of the easily led, duped into thinking this was all their idea. You have to wonder if it even occurred to the average attendee at the Beck rally to ask who paid for their bus ride.

That quote above was from Frank Rich, writing in the Sunday NYT. He was, in turn, referring to an extensive profile in The New Yorker magazine by Jane Mayer.

Kunstler wraps up with this question:

The bigger mystery in all this -- if I may perhaps engage in some nostalgia of my own -- is: what happened to reasonable, rational, educated people of purpose in this country to drive them into such burrow of cowardice that they can't speak the truth, or act decisively, or even defend themselves against such a host of vicious morons in a time of troubles?

What indeed? Regrettably, Paul Krugman may have the answer:

It will be an ugly scene [after the November elections, should the Democrats lose a house of Congress], and it will be dangerous, too. The 1990s were a time of peace and prosperity; this is a time of neither. In particular, we’re still suffering the after-effects of the worst economic crisis since the 1930s, and we can’t afford to have a federal government paralyzed by an opposition with no interest in helping the president govern. But that’s what we’re likely to get.

If I were President Obama, I’d be doing all I could to head off this prospect, offering some major new initiatives on the economic front in particular, if only to shake up the political dynamic. But my guess is that the president will continue to play it safe, all the way into catastrophe.

An altogether likely prospect.

Tony Angelo: Tom Emmer is the Gold Standard

In missed votes, anyway. Alliance for a Better Minnesota has been running an ad about the percentage of votes Emmer has missed in the Minnesota House of Representatives.

And Tony, who I am coming to learn, often asks the next question, asks it again, “And that’s compared to what?”

And here’s what Tony found:

So while Alliance for a Better Minnesota claims Tom Emmer missed one out of every five votes (it's actually more, over 22% if you figure 142/621) according to my database Tom Emmer "only" missed over 18% of votes. The word only in that sentence is in quotes because Tom Emmer only missed more votes than any other legislator and it's not even close.

Again according to the database I compiled of roll call votes Tom Emmer missed 147, second in missed votes was Doug Magnus with 111 and they're the only two who missed more than 100. The mean number of votes missed was 19, but in a skewed data set like this one mean is not the measure that you want to use for average, median is and the median number of votes missed was 9.

That's rather staggering when put into context, Tom Emmer missed 147 votes and the average legislator missed 9. The z-score, standard deviations from the mean, of Tom Emmer's missed votes is an out of this world 4.61. You could say that Tom Emmer is the Babe Ruth of missing votes.

Tom Emmer is the Black Swan, not predicted using ordinary statistical methods.

I have one small disagreement with Tony; Emmer is more like Mark McGwire. He had to be using steroids to pile up a record like that.

Incidentally, this is the first time I’ve linked to Tony’s blog, minn-Donkey. Try it; you’ll like it.

A lonely nut grinding an imaginary axe

The comment was left on the Minnesotans achieve “Intelligence Report” status post. I didn’t approve it, so it isn’t in the comment stream; I wanted to give it a place all by itself.

Capture2

A crackdown on and labeling of all Americans? The Klan, white supremacy groups, the National Socialists (those loveable Nazis), nativists, gay bashers, and plain old garden variety racists, sure, but all Americans?

Please go to the Southern Poverty Law Center website, and just look at some of their recent activities:

Settlement Ends Louisiana Police Shooting Lawsuit

SPLC Files Suit Against Georgia Police Officers Who Beat Latino Man
SPLC’s New Anti-Bullying Film and Teaching Kit Now Available
SPLC Sues Mississippi Authorities, Hospital for Illegally Taking Immigrant's Newborn
Intelligence Report: Movement at Root of Recent Police Murders Growing
Guestworker Teachers Defrauded in International Labor Trafficking Scheme
Children with Disabilities Face Discrimination in New Orleans Schools
SPLC Files Suit After New Orleans First-Grader Handcuffed

That’s just on the front page.

You have a funny idea of “all Americans,” Dan.

The SPLC’s summer Intelligence Report, subtitled Meet the Patriots, is a virtual encyclopedia of right wing hate groups.

The Southern Poverty Law Center has brought many cases on behalf of minorities, the disenfranchised, and the poor. Here’s a docket of some of the more important cases it has brought.

Feidt’s comment is an insult — an ignorant, baseless insult — of a scrappy and courageous civil rights law firm that has done a lot of people a lot of good since it was founded in Birmingham, Alabama in 1971.

Feidt cites the fact that the Hutaree militia group was released on bail as proof of the “dodgy” character of the SPLC. The Hutaree militia was in fact on SLPC’s “watch list” of hate groups. But it is important to be mindful of a couple of things: the SPLC didn’t start the prosecutions, a United States Attorney in Michigan did. And those terrorism and conspiracy charges are still outstanding; the charges themselves have not been dismissed.

The SPLC wasn’t even in court, but it is ignorant and absurd to think — and again ignorant and foolish to write — that the charges were “laughed out of court.”

This comment has made me wonder whether Dan Feidt is just a lonely nut grinding an imaginary axe, or perhaps whether he is part of something at least a little more formally organized. A concerted effort to damage the SPLC is certainly not out of the questions; there have been threats against the organization before — and threats on Morris Dees’ life, too. I hope it’s the former, but I wouldn’t be surprised by the latter.

Sunday, August 29, 2010

Breakfast at Delta Airlines

I just got back from a short trip to Montana. Beautiful place.  My wife and I flew from the Twin Cities to Missoula, via Delta Airlines. The flight itself went smoothly enough - perhaps because the flight was actually run by something called "Compass Airlines," not Delta itself.

When we booked the trip Expedia told us that we were to be served a "breakfast" on both flights - coming and going. Of course we knew that was just so much bullshit - we'd flown NWA and Delta before. What is surprising is the absolute penny pinching going on these days. To begin with, any checked bag now costs $25 each way; for two people checking ONE bag each, that amounts to a $100 surcharge, added on to the $700 roundtrip fare. You'd think with that kind of money changing hands an airline wouldn't have to so blatantly lie about what was served on the flight, but you'd be wrong. Take a look at this picture of "breakfast" according to Delta:

That might constitute breakfast for something like a squirrel, but for a human? Notice how the bag itself is nothing more than an advertisement for something called "Hilton Garden Inn." Did Delta have to pay anything for this "breakfast"? I took the bag home, opened it, and counted 20 peanuts:


$700 for a round-trip airplane ticket; $100 hidden charges for bringing some luggage; 20 peanuts for breakfast. Priceless. This is what late-stage monopoly capitalism looks like.

Minnesotans “achieve” Intelligence Report status

The Southern Poverty Law Center has been following the Patriots, nativists [spell checker helpfully offers satanists], and gay bashers for a long time. One of the publications of the SPLC is the Intelligence Report, a quarterly report on the activities of this crowd. The fall Intelligence Report is just out. It contains this:
bradlee dean at 1280 Pulido's [an unsuccessful Republican candidate for Congress in Illinois] coziness with the gay-bashing IFI was no more notable than that of some Minnesota elected officials' with You Can Run But You Cannot Hide Intl. Inc., a music ministry [I would have put “ministry” in quotes] that brings punk rock evangelism into public schools in the Midwest. On a May 15 radio show, the ministry's front man, Bradlee Dean, applauded the call of some Muslims for violence against gay people. "Muslims are calling for the executions of homosexuals in America," Dean said. "This just shows you … they seem to be more moral than even the American Christians… . They know homosexuality is an abomination."
Emmer at 1280
After Minnesota Independent writer Andy Birkey reported his comments, Dean backpedaled, saying he does not favor the execution of homosexuals. Despite those remarks, Republican State Rep. Tom Emmer defended the ministry as a "pro-traditional marriage group" composed of "nice people." And last November, Minnesota congresswoman and Tea Party darling Michele Bachmann was the keynote speaker at a fundraiser for the ministry.
This is Bachmann’s second consecutive appearance in the Intelligence Report. She was in the summer issue, too, named as one of the top congressional enablers of the Patriot movement in the article entitled Meet the Patriots.

The two sketches are by Ken Avidor, a frequent contributor here at the Cucking Stool. They depict the on air appearances of Bradlee Dean and Tom Emmer at the AM 1280 radio booth at the Minnesota State Fair.

Saturday, August 28, 2010

No Time to Subsidize Profit: an Overview

Thursday, August 26th was a day of reckoning for the for-profit college industry in America. After years of indiscriminate expansion, fueled by billions of dollars in public money, with virtually no oversight, publicly traded for-profit colleges were forced to turn over some very basic information to Sen. Tom Harkin's Health, Education, Labor and Pensions (HELP) Committee.

These figures include:
  • A spreadsheet with detailed school-by-school data on revenue from sources including Pell Grants, all federal student loan programs, Department of Defense tuition assistance benefits, vocational rehabilitation funds, private loans, institutional loans, state loans, state grants, student-paid tuition, employer-paid tuition, and any and all other sources.
  • For the period July 1, 2007 to June 30, 2010, the number of students enrolled in online, in-person and hybrid programs; the number of new students enrolled each month by program, campus and mode of instruction; the total number of program completers each year; the total number who left by formally withdrawing or by stopping class attendance.
  • Detailed information, with randomized identification numbers, for each student who entered the college between July 1, 2007 and June 30, 2009, including enrollment date and completion or graduation status.
Once these numbers are made available to the public, we will finally start to get a more complete picture of this industry. This information request will be followed by another in September, which asks for even more. You can read the details at the links above.

Harkin's committee has been hot on the heels of the for-profit college industry, which is a good thing, since no one else seems to be. For-profit colleges used to be a small niche, usually privately owned trade or vocational schools. But legal changes abetted consolidation in the industry, on-line education made it possible to reach larger numbers of potential customers, and now we have a number of behemoth for-profit college chains that make huge profits. Enrollment in for-profit colleges has surged, increasing 225% from 1998 to 2008.

The vast majority of their revenue comes in the form of federally subsidized student aid programs, such as Pell Grants and federal student loans. In 2008-2009, $23.9 billion flowed from federal Title IV student aid programs through students to for-profit colleges. According to analysis from Harkin's committee, 50% of the expenses of the publicly traded for-profit colleges went toward education expenses, 31% of their expenses were for marketing and recruitment. Put simply, U.S. taxpayers annually shell out billions of dollars for profit and marketing expenses to for-profit colleges.

When President Obama took office, one of the first initiatives he announced was to bolster college completion rates. This admirable goal was seized upon by the for-profit colleges as their chance to establish themselves as a legitimate and essential component of the American higher education system. For example, consider this quote from the CEO of the Career College Association:
"This is not a slam on community colleges, but the reality is that they do not have the resources to do what President Obama wants them to do."
And here is the nut of the scheme.

State budget stress leads to higher education cuts causing higher tuition. Then politicians decry higher tuition rates that they caused, and attempt to compensate by increasing student aid programs. The public higher education system is forced to cut back just as demand increases. And the natural beneficiaries of this cycle of dysfunction are for-profit colleges. While the public system cuts, they expand. While there is political pressure to hold down public college tuition, there is investor pressure to increase tuition and reduce educational expenses at for-profit colleges. And lost in all of this is a focus on the essential outcomes of higher education: preparing a diverse population for the demands of life in a complex global economy and for their responsibilities as engaged citizens.

It is the students who lose out. Investigations and lawsuits have uncovered a shady world of recruiters who lie to students about the cost of for-profit colleges, the nature of student aid, and the success rates of their graduates. Students who do not complete a program find that their credits do not transfer and they lose their investment. Those who do complete are saddled with enormous debt burdens that they can never repay. And unlike the ways in which wealthier folks easily shed their debts, federal student loans cannot be discharged through bankruptcy.

The for-profit college scam is like so many other right-wing scams - done on the backs of poor and minority folks while being done "for their benefit." For all the trumpeting about choice and access, the fact is that for-profit colleges saddle their students with enormous and unsustainable debt loads.

In Minnesota, we've done more than nearly any other state to subsidize the for-profit college industry. Minnesota has seen a larger and larger proportion of its need based state student aid go to for-profit colleges while it has been rapidly decreasing its support of public higher education. Over $20 million of Minnesota State Grant funds flow annually to for-profit colleges. The proportion of Minnesota State Grant funds flowing to the for-profit colleges has increased at a similar pace to national trends.

Similar to Rob Levine's work here on the Cucking Stool and elsewhere about the charter school and school choice scams, I'll be bringing you a series of posts about the for-profit college industry in Minnesota. And they are very similar - the same ideology and techniques are at play, and the results are similar. I think one paragraph from the HELP committee's report captures it perfectly:
Evidence suggests that for-profit schools charge higher tuition than comparable public schools, spend a large share of revenues on expenses unrelated to teaching, experience high dropout rates, and, in some cases, employ abusive recruiting and debt-management practices. What distinguishes for-profit schools from public and non-profit private institutions is that they have an obligation to maximize profits for their shareholders. Indeed, securities law sanctifies the notion that each corporation must act in the interest of its shareholders. However, this imperative could conflict with the objective of Federal student aid programs, which is to increase access to a quality higher education. This evidence, and the potential conflicts underlying it, points to the need for rigorous government oversight and prudent regulation to safeguard the investments of taxpayers and students.
Investing in a world-class public higher education system will allow Minnesota to compete in a global economy, and attract new businesses and residents. Continuing the trend of neglecting public higher education will lead to a vicious cycle of higher tuition, less access, and a less prepared citizenry.

Next: Minnesota's disinvestment in public higher education and increasing subsidy of for-profit colleges.

Aaron Klemz is an Instructor in the Communication Department at Century College, White Bear Lake, Minnesota. His views here are his own, not that of his employer or any other organization.

Follow me on Twitter @aaronklemz