Saturday, September 18, 2010

A combination death cult and suicide pact

From the platform of the Iowa Republican Party:

The function of law is to protect the free exercise of a person’s God-given rights: life, liberty, and the right to property (pursuit of happiness). [apparently there was some mistranslation in the Declaration of Independence as written]

We call for the repeal of all mandatory minimum wage laws.

We call for reinstating, with proper safeguards, the death penalty for murderers, rapists, kidnappers, and drug dealers, with a firm limit of twenty-four months for appeals and no intrusion of federal authorities. [or that pesky U.S. Constitution]

We believe that claims of human-caused global warming are based on fraudulent, inaccurate information, and that legislation and policy based on this information are detrimental to the well-being of the United States.

We believe all individuals and business owners have the freedom to choose the quality of air in their homes and establishments.

We call for the elimination of the Occupational Safety and Health Administration.

We support the elimination of the Iowa Department of Education and of the U.S. Department of Education.

We support the abolition of the IRS. We call for the repeal of the Federal Reserve Act, eliminating the Federal Reserve, and we support returning to the gold and/or silver standard.

We believe candidates running as Republicans for any local or state office should be required to complete and return to the Republican Party of Iowa a signed questionnaire indicating whether the candidate agrees, disagrees, or is undecided about each plank of the current party platform.

As reported in the October 2010 issue of Harper’s Magazine. No link; the issue is behind a subscriber wall.

Friday, September 17, 2010

Growth without Justice

Hang down your head, Tom Horner

Tom Horner- Targeting the middle ground - StarTribune.com_1278868094518 Here’s the lede in a Strib article about Horner’s proposal to eliminate the corporate income tax in Minnesota:

Hoping to boost job growth in Minnesota, Independence Party gubernatorial candidate Tom Horner said Thursday that he would phase out the state's corporate income tax, simplify regulations and increase state-funded research.

According to the article, Horner would pay for this and increases in spending in education by with an a broadening of the sales tax base.

He would offset some of that new spending, he said, with his proposed expansion of the state sales tax to clothing and unspecified services. He said that food, medical care and prescription drugs and related services would remain untaxed. Horner said he also plans to close tax deductions for the wealthy, increase alcohol and tobacco taxes and cut spending.

Note to readers: there is already a gross receipts tax on medical service providers, intended for the Minnesota Health Care Access fund, but hundreds of millions of dollars have already been diverted from it for the general fund; there is already a sales tax on medical services, in practical effect.

The belief that merely reducing taxes will increase “good jobs” is the kind of “I sat down and worked it out with a pencil” thinking that one might expect from King Banaian or Craig Westover. And that should tell you something right there.

Reducing a company’s costs increase its profitability, but not necessarily its employment. We can demonstrate this with a simple illustration.

Let’s assume that you are a company that needs one employee for every customer you have. You have fifty customers and currently have fifty employees. Tom Horner is elected governor, and he slashes your business taxes, but you have the same fifty customers.

How many more employees do you hire? Tom?

Tom might say, “They’ll hire waaaay more!” but the right answer is zero. The business will hire another person when the marginal revenue generated by that person exceeds the marginal cost of the hire. In our little example, without any marginal revenue, there is no incentive to incur the marginal cost. (If it helps, just substitute the word “extra” for “marginal.”)

It is more complicated in the real world, naturally, but the example does show that simply reducing taxes by itself is not the driver of employment, certainly in the short to medium term. It gets more complicated when the issue is situs of a new factory or other substantial bricks and mortar investment. We’ll leave that for future posts.

For right now, though, let’s talk just about fairness. In a recent op-ed, the unacknowledged Pat Anderson functionary Craig Westover said that we couldn’t afford to be fair, that corporations had us by the short hair, and we might as well get used to it. Well, thanks Benito, but I don’t think it’s come to that.

Raise your hand if you don’t think that corporate business activity consumes state government resources or incurs cost to the state.

Of course it does.

But Tom Horner, the faithful corporate retainer, wants you to forget that.

When Well Fargo Mortgage wants to foreclose on your house, it needs the sheriff, and maybe the courts, to do it. When Target Credit Corporation wants to collect a debt owed by a customer, same thing. When a corporation wants to, well, exist, it needs the Secretary of State. When 3M wants to send its cellophane tape down the road, guess who provides the road?

And who educated most of the people who work for 3M, Target Corporation, and Wells Fargo? Certainly not the corporations themselves.

But to the deadly bloodsuckers like Tom Horner, that doesn’t matter. Corporations should get a free ride.

Corporations want to exist when it comes to things like First Amendment rights, but they don’t want to exist when it comes to other attributes of citizenship, like paying a fair share of the cost of government. And sleek mouthpieces like Tom Horner are there to help every step of the way. But we certainly don’t need to elevate one to the governor’s office.

UPDATE: We had a discussion about the Republican Liberty Caucus at Drinking Liberally on Thursday; the RLC describes itself as “the conscience of the Republican Party.” In Minnesota, the RLC has endorsed Tom Emmer, Mark Buesgens, Pat Anderson, Steve Drazkowski, and Mary Kiffmeyer among others.

On the issue of the elimination of business taxes, the RLC Caucus and candidate Horner are on the same page.

Strib photograph

Thursday, September 16, 2010

Solving Mark Dayton's Math Problem

Mark Dayton's campaign has recognized a fundamental problem with taxation in Minnesota; the wealthiest 10% of taxpayers are paying an increasingly smaller share of their income than the rest of us. The impact of state and local taxes, as a percentage of income, falls heaviest on the middle class in Minnesota. If the wealthiest 10% (and especially the richest 1%) paid the same share of state and local taxes that the middle class pay we'd be a long way toward solving the nearly $6 billion budget deficit.

The problem is getting the tax system to align so that the wealthiest do pay their fair share of taxes. And let's be absolutely clear - we're not even talking about a truly progressive tax system where the wealthy pay a greater share of their income in taxes. We're talking about getting to a state and local flat tax, roughly.

The problem with Mark Dayton's original proposal of increasing the top income tax tier to 10.95% is that relying entirely on the progressive income tax to balance out other regressive taxes won't be sufficient. The Minnesota Department of Revenue demonstrated that when they ran the numbers and found that Dayton's proposal would only raise $1.9 billion. That gap between $1.9 billion and the $4 billion that he sought needs to be filled with revenue that comes from the top decile or it will not get us to a roughly flat state and local tax impact.

One area that Dayton ought to consider is to make the arcane and complex property tax system in Minnesota more progressive. There have been a number of proposals that have been floated in Minnesota and a couple of states that have made tentative steps in this direction. Done carefully and thoughtfully, the property tax burden on middle class taxpayers can be held flat while targeting property tax increases on the wealthiest Minnesotans.

Consider the following chart from Minnesota House Research, outlining the percentage of market value in each property category and the percentage each property category pays in property taxes.



Note that there are a couple of disparities that, if corrected, would move us toward a more progressive property taxation system. First, seasonal recreation property is paying only 60% of it's proportion of value. Second, residential nonhomestead property pays less than it's share of overall property value. A progressive property tax system would tax second (or third) properties and vacation homes at a higher rate. This is not to say that all property categories ought to pay their exact proportion of market value in property taxes. For example, the choice to tax homesteads at a lower rate reflects a desire to avoid regressive taxation impacts on someone's primary residence.

Increasing the progressivity of the property tax system can be accomplished through a variety of means. As MN2020 described, one technique is to eliminate property tax credits that are not tied to income in favor of property tax refunds tied to ability to pay. Or more simply, one could add more taxation levels tied to property value. For example, there are two rates for homesteaded property in Minnesota, one for property values below $500,000 and one for properties above $500,000. One could add a third tier for even higher property values that was levied by the state for the purpose of increasing state revenue. Or there are other techniques one might use (taxing on the basis of square footage, etc.)

Keep in mind as well that people who establish residence in other states for the purpose of avoiding income tax can't move their property from Minnesota in the same fashion. If one goal of Dayton's revenue proposals is to ensure that snowbirds pay their fair share of taxes, a graduated property tax (especially one focused on non-homestead and recreational property) might be the best way to do that.

Property taxes represent the largest portion of state and local taxes collected in Minnesota, slightly larger than income tax. And while only a portion of the property tax collected goes to the state, one of the categories I described above does go to state coffers (recreational property.) There could be state surtaxes on the highest end property for the dual purpose of raising revenues and increasing progressivity.

The Department of Revenue's analysis of Mark Dayton's income tax proposal demonstrates that income taxes alone cannot ameliorate the regressivity of other tax categories. A well crafted property tax proposal could be targeted at the wealthiest and help Dayton achieve his goal of ensuring the wealthiest in Minnesota pay their fair share of taxes.

Follow me on Twitter @aaronklemz

Erik Paulsen is afraid of Jim Meffert

The man who tries to comb his hair like Jim Ramstad but votes like Michele Bachmann won’t agree to meet face to face with Jim Meffert for a debate in front of voters. Update: added language in italics.

There is a term of art for this in political circles. (The sensitive among you may wish to avert your eyes.)

Chickenshit cowardice

Professor David A. Schultz recently called Jim Meffert a terrific candidate for the Third District. And that he is.

We’re trying to get a repeat appearance by Jim at Drinking Liberally, but here’s a video of some of his remarks when he came to DL before the DFL endorsing convention:

There are two kinds of Republicans

On the provenance of the Tea Party

Bonnie Erbe of Scripps New Service splashed around in the shallow end of the reasoning pool in a piece that burdened today’s op-ed section of the Star Tribune. According to Erbe, the rise of the Tea Party is cause for introspection by both major parties (that’s how Doug Tice summarized it in the hed, anyway). A subtext of the piece is that the Tea Party is some kind of new, separate force in American politics. Nonsense. The Tea Party is the creature of Dick Armey, Rupert Murdoch and the Koch brothers.

They’re just Republicans with a really, really bad case of the vapors:

So that’s one kind of Republican. The Tea Party Republican. Then, you have your non-Tea Party Republicans, like this:

Tom Horner- Targeting the middle ground - StarTribune.com_1278868094518

Tom Horner photo from the Star Tribune

Wednesday, September 15, 2010

Emmer's Budget Ax: Higher Education

Mark Dayton's got a math problem. Horner has a vagueness problem. Tom Emmer has a real problem - his cuts cause real pain to real people. To some extent, this will be true of the budget resulting from electing any of the three. At least Dayton's honest about that and his priority is clear, seek revenue sources instead of blindly cutting.

Emmer's political calculation is that by leaving K-12 education alone (and acting like the nearly $2 billion that Tim Pawlenty "borrowed" from school can be deferred for years) he can hack away at other categories in the budget. Health and Human Services, the second largest and fastest growing budget category, suffered the greatest dollar cuts (and yes, they are cuts no matter how much Emmer insists otherwise.) But Higher Education and Local Government Aid came in for devastating cuts that no rhetorical sleight of hand can dismiss.

If Emmer's budget were to become law, public higher education in Minnesota would be transformed forever. And I do not mean transformed in a good way. It will become increasingly unaffordable and force a contraction in capacity at the very moment that students are flocking to retrain and retool. Higher education is an engine of economic development in a state that badly needs it. To slash away is more than short-sighted, it's criminally negligent.

If Emmer's budget were to become law, Minnesota's tuition rates would skyrocket. They would be the highest in the country or very near the top. Emmer's proposal to cut higher education would reduce the state appropriation to $2.5 billion. That's a $312 million cut. But wait, it gets worse.

For the purposes of clarity, consider how this might impact the Minnesota State Colleges and Universities system. Under the current two-year budget, MnSCU received $1.129 billion from state appropriations, approximately 43% of the overall higher education budget of $2.812 billion. That means MnSCU's share of the cut would be about $134 million. That cut will come on top of the expiration of stimulus funds representing another $79 million. That's a cut of over $213 million for FY 2012-3, or a cut of $107 million per year. In percentage terms, this is a cut of 17.6% from MnSCU's FY2011 budget.

While it's hard to predict exact impacts, consider what was said last year:

MnSCU's chief financial officer, Laura King, said in the case of a 20 percent budget cut, her system would prefer to implement a series of fixes. King said they would include layoffs, higher tuition, enrollment caps and potentially closing some of MnSCU's 54 campus across the state.

"Whether it's higher tuition, enrollment caps, fewer course offerings, or reduced student services, our students will see those impacts," King said.

King also said that if they took only one approach, they could offset the cut by closing as many as 18 community colleges.

That's right - you'd have to close almost 18 community colleges to fix Emmer's gaping hole. Don't worry, maybe it won't be the one in your community.

Welcome to Tom Emmer's Minnesota. Let's hope people are paying attention.

Follow me on Twitter @aaronklemz


The marvelous pig

pigs for emmer This is Taylor Swine (get it?). She’s an Emmer spokespig, and although she is by all accounts a marvelous pig, too, she’s not the subject of today’s parable. Her picture was just handy.

A reporter got a tip that a farmer has an unusual pig on his farm, so the reporter drove out to the farmer’s place. As he approached the farm, he noticed some pigs in a lot, and as he got closer, he saw that one of them had two wooden legs. The reporter was anxious to find out about this pig came to have artificial legs.

He knocked, and the farmer came to the door. After introducing himself, he said, “That’s a pretty unusual pig you’ve got there. Can you him me about him?”

“Wal, sure,” replied the farmer. “That is a marvelous pig; let me tell you! A couple of months ago, the chimney started a fire in the house during the night. We were all asleep. That pig saw the fire, crashed through the gate, ran up here, and created a ruckus that woke us all up. If it hadn’t been for that pig, we’d probably all be dead. Yep, that’s a marvelous pig, all right.”

“That’s an amazing story!” exclaimed the reporter, “But what I meant was how did it come to have artificial legs?”

The farmer shrugged and said, “A pig that special, you don’t want to eat all at once.”

And so it is with Tom Emmer’s budget ideas.

From Dayton's spokesperson Katie Tinucci: "Rep. Emmer's plan will cut funding for Higher Education by 14%, K-12 Education by 14%, and Local Government Aid by 33%. He will thus cause huge increases in property taxes, higher college tuitions and seriously damage the quality of education throughout Minnesota. Furthermore, his drastic cuts in funding for Health and Human Services will restrict access to essential health care for those most in need."

He won’t eat the pig all at once, of course, just piece by piece.

Tuesday, September 14, 2010

Waiting for the Robert E. Lee

A tribute to states’ rights

Thanks to MNPublius for saving the Severson video from oblivion.

John Stacy, featured in the video, is a leader of the Houston 9/12 Project.

Update: A thump of the tail to Spot’s friend Eva Young for the link to the Legislative Evaluation Assembly. Eva blogs at Dump MIchele Bachmann and Lloydletta’s Nooz and Comments.

The resemblance is, well, just uncanny

Two Putt Tommy, Executive Producer

The inspiration for the video was this, in the Grand Forks Herald:

Because when Emmer speaks on the budget, he sounds deeper in denial than Saddam Hussein's famous spokesman, the one who kept insisting on Saddam's genius and triumph even as coalition tanks rolled up outside his ministry's door.

Update: We’re getting lots of traffic on this post; thanks again to Two Putt Tommy for posting the video originally at the link above.

You might also check out a new video – produced here – called Waiting for the Robert E. Lee. (It’s the post just above this one.)

Doug Tice tries to pull a fast one

Yesterday’s Strib had an op-ed, undoubtedly carefully chosen by public school education hater Doug Tice, and which was carried under a hed he probably wrote: For-profit education isn't the enemy. Hell it ain’t, Doug.

The op-ed was reprinted from The Economist. Well, yes, says the Economist, dodgy things do happen in the for-profit sector:

Yet recent government reports suggest that some of these colleges have a troublingly familiar business model: flogging a low-grade product to people who are paying with subsidized government loans. The Department of Education reported that most students at many of these universities were defaulting on their loans.

Similarly, an investigation by the Government Accountability Office found that even leading for-profit colleges such as Kaplan and the University of Phoenix had engaged in dodgy practices to recruit students and encourage them to borrow large sums to pay for their courses.

But, says the Economist, we mustn’t allow ourselves to be distracted from what is really at stake:

The principle? Concentrate on the quality of the education, not the ownership. All sorts of colleges seem to have been guilty of shabby marketing. They should be treated the same.

Why yes, we hear about the shysters at the University of Minnesota admissions office all the time! Not to mention MNSCU and those sly marketers at places like St. Olaf or Hamline. Complete dens of inequity. That’s silly, obviously, and there’s been darn little reporting of a liberal arts college recruiter out beating the bushes to round out this year’s class of English majors.

But let’s focus on quality for a moment. One way that’s useful is to see if the students are able to earn enough money to pay for their education. Seems fair, doesn’t it? Well, if you’ve been reading Aaron’s posts on for-profit colleges, you know a much larger percentage of them don’t, based on student loan default rates.

Here’s part of a response Aaron left to a comment by a for-profit educator:

There's no way that 2 year programs in business or law enforcement that charge over 14,000 dollars a year are affordable on the wages of the careers that they are trained for. That's why the student loan default rate is so much higher for for profit college students compared to public higher education students. Important information about cost is largely concealed from students and the public. For edification, go to the Minnesota School of Business website http://www.msbcollege.edu/ and try to find out how much tuition costs per semester. Go ahead, look for it. Now go to Century College's website http://www.century.edu/ and click on the "Future Students" tab. See if you can find out how much tuition is.

Part of the reason for this is the fact that, again as Aaron points out in the same comment:

However, what we know from looking at the 10-K forms of Corinthian Colleges, Career Education Corp., and the Apollo Group is that marketing and recruitment are at least 1/4 of the expense of operating a for-profit college. If MnSCU schools spent 1 in 4 dollars on advertising for students, there would be a revolt.

And that doesn’t include the profit, either.

Monday, September 13, 2010

And Arne Carlson prefers his oatmeal unsalted!

Vote for the third hand

Standing in front a throng of three dozen supporters perhaps trucked in from the Dorothy Day Center, Arne Carlson today announced his fervent support for middleman Tom Horner. The Vikings roster is bigger than the crowd for the announcement.

In a moment of apparent confusion for the former governor, Carlson said, “You can’t tax your way to success; on the other hand, you can’t cut your way to success.”

“Tom Horner is the third hand.”

Okay, he didn’t really say that last sentence. But he might just as well have said it.

Horner does agree with Mark Dayton that we need to raise more revenue; Horner just wants to do it regressively, by broadening sales taxes to include clothing and at least some (more) services. Let’s ask our Tea Party friends what they think of that:

tax my underwear

Seems like a nonstarter with the Tea Party, eh? Most of them are Emmerians (or is it Emmerites? cast your vote in the comments) anyway, so it is not likely this the group Horner is after.

In spite of Carlson’s, um, glowing words, Horner does seem to represent a deadly status quo for Minnesota, more of a “more of the same” candidate, stretching all the way back to the Carlson administration: a series of trimmers and tuckers and hemmers and hawers. And “put offers;” Carlson is not entirely free from blame here, either.

Since Horner is in the news today, I thought I’d put up some links to old posts (older to newer) here at the Stool about Tom Horner.

Tom “I’m in the middle” Horner, Spot’s foot (on Rachel Stassen-Berger’s description of Horner as a centrist)

Tom Horner, meet the Tea Partiers! (Dean Barkley says, “Come on over!” to the Tea Partiers)

The tuba trio (Horner on health care)

And the dead shall be raised . . . Incombustible! (Horner throws his chapeau in the ring)

Jesse Ventura without the charisma (Horner is endorsed by an empty room)

Dr. Spin will see you now (or Southbound in the Tom Lane, about the tip credit)

The eighth grade campaign (Horner’s juvenile campaign)

Tom Horner’s big lies (no further description needed)

There’s one other link I’d like to mention; it’s to a post about the relative fairness of sales tax and income tax increases: Taxing Harry and Louise.

Double voting: the latest non-scandal that Voter ID can't fix


Double voting. Felons voting. ACORN. Despite a voting system that is the envy of the nation in transparency, accessibility, and accuracy, conservatives will never relinquish the belief that Minnesota is rife with electoral fraud and abuse.

In the latest in a series of ginned up non-stories, the Star Tribune today ran an AP story about alleged "double voting" where residents of Minnesota and Wisconsin supposedly voted in both states in the same election. In this case, the ginned up non-story involves approximately 35 name matches that were deemed to be potential cases of double voting, a grand total of two people in Menomonie who've been charged, and a healthy dose of innuendo about college campuses. No convictions. And at least several cases that have already been dismissed upon further investigation.

Obviously, these people must have voted for Al Franken.

Just like the "felons voting" non-story, this story illustrates three truths about voter fraud. First, when people throw massive amounts of resources at discovering widespread voter fraud in Minnesota they come up with a tiny handful of cases. Second, the "solution" of requiring photo identification wouldn't solve any of the example of fraud that they discover. Third, Republicans really, really can't get over Sen. Franken's election.

How would requiring ID have stopped Ms. Sample from voting absentee in Minnesota and in person in Wisconsin (or the reverse)? It wouldn't.

How would requiring a driver's license stop Ms. Sample from voting if she is a felon on probation? Once again, it wouldn't help.

How would requiring a Minnesota ID stop Ms. Sample from voting is she is a non-citizen? If Gayle is a permanent legal resident (but non-citizen) she'd be eligible to get a drivers license.

Is it important to catch folks who abuse the voting system and vote illegally? Absolutely, but the innuendo that there's some sort of hidden epidemic of illegal voting going unpunished is false. Minnesotans should be proud that Minnesota's registration system results in nation-leading voter turnout. Minnesotans should be proud that our paper optical scan ballots allow an accurate and verifiable recount. We lead the nation in voter access, transparency, and accuracy. The relentless Republican assault on the integrity of our voting system, voting officials, and voters demonstrates a profound contempt for Minnesota's small-d democratic values.

(Image Credit: Minnesota Department of Motor Vehicles)

Follow me on Twitter @aaronklemz

Sunday, September 12, 2010

Innocence lost

Oh, Katie, what is it now?

CG4A_WWII_glider_hook_up_5 Ingemar Holm, Jim Johns, and Dale Johnson (and a few others) thought the newspaper columnist was coming out to interview them for a human interest story about their retirement hobby: restoring vintage aircraft. Their current project is a CG-4 military glider. According to Johns, it was the only military aircraft made in Minnesota (although, I believe, Bombardier made Hurricanes, and perhaps other planes, too, for the RAF and Canadian Air Forces in Thunder Bay just to our north).

It could have been a nice story about some WW2 airplane buffs getting together for the camaraderie and some historical preservation. They probably didn’t reckon that the columnist in question, Katherine Kersten, would use them as a prop in yet another chapter in her life-long  polemic, You’re All Just a Bunch of Layabouts! But now, at least, they know.

Kersten cannot tell a story — or at least try to anyway — without beating us over the head with its Larger Meaning.

When Katie doesn’t have a group of Muslims (surprising, given the date), gays, or other minority group to scold, she’ll turn to video games or the sloth of some people as a subject, just to stay limber.

Here’s Katie’s lede:

On a typical evening we flop down, flip on the 36-inch flat screen, click the mouse, text, tweet, or feast on Facebook. The more adventurous among us grab virtual swords and enter the explosion-filled, fantasy universe of games like World of Warcraft, where we achieve instant superhero status.

We're megaconsumers of passive entertainment, spoon-fed by faceless folks in Hollywood or at companies like Sony. It's fun. It's relaxing. But when we log off, we often have a nagging question: Have we just wasted a lot of time?

And Ingemar, Jim, and Dale thought this story was going to be about them! Holm gets introduced in paragraph three, and we do learn some tidbits about the glider and the restoration effort along the way:

The CG-4 has an 84-foot wingspan, and is largely "glued, taped and tied" together, requiring 15 miles of cord and 10 miles of electrical tape.

Doesn’t that create a vivid picture in your mind? Such writing craft. If you’re a fifth grader.

But no Katie story is worth telling unless someone can be made to feel guilty about it:

What differentiates these men's hobby -- inspired by childhood games and projects -- from our electronic playland? Unlike our frenetic digital amusements, their use of leisure time requires patience, resourcefulness, self-discipline and perseverance.

It just makes you want to take up scrimshaw, doesn’t it?

Katie always like the big, wistful finish and a question left unresolved, and she doesn’t disappoint today:

In 25 years, how many of us will be equipped to take on the kind of creative project these men are engaged in? When we get drawn into our passive, seductive electronic world, are we just indulging in a few hours of misspent leisure time, or is there something more at stake?

This is the point in a Kersten column where I often feel sorry for her kids, because this is a woman who lays guilt with a trowel.

Or, as one local wag put it in describing the column, “Because every time you go online, a puppy dies.”

Friday, September 10, 2010

Emmer's Budget Ax Starts Swinging

Tom Emmer's vaunted education plan was unveiled today. And like everything else about his budget it was full of half-truths, distortions and unintended consequences.

The biggest distortion of all as was that he would "hold K-12 education harmless" by continuing the $13.3 billion allocated in the last biennium. Of course, this doesn't account for the nearly $2 billion "shift" that would not begin to be repaid until 2014. In addition, other folks have reported that the $13.3 billion figure also understates actual K-12 spending by $500 million. EDIT: Emmer's campaign stated later that this was a "typo" and corrected the figure to $13.8 billion.

Tom Emmer's reform agenda for education, supposed to increase accountability while decreasing mandates (think about that for a minute) is currently no more than a word salad (accountability, excellence, performance, effective) with a side of vagueness dressing.

But my concern is with what was at the end of his proposal, to shift MFIP Child Care Assistance and Basic Sliding Fee Child Care Assistance to Early Childhood Education (ECFE.)

ECFE is a valuable program, well worth the investment. But raiding child care funds to pay for it is the wrong revenue source.

For one thing, the majority of child care funding through these programs is provided through federal matching grants. The state child care programs that would be cut would yield $108,139,031 using the FY2009 budget, but would then lose $116,755,581 in matching federal dollars. In other words, for every state dollar spent on child care, we would lose more than a dollar in federal money. In fact, the Basic Sliding Fee child care assistance program has a nearly 2 to 1 federal match, so cutting $35,781,231 in state funding would lose $69,660,222 in federal TANF and CCDF funds.

Like everything else Emmer proposes, this half-baked idea would cause Minnesota to lose even more of its share of federal tax dollars its residents pay. Depending on the size of the shift he proposes, it could also cause the loss of child care assistance for over 16,000 Minnesota families.

Follow me on Twitter @aaronklemz

Move the mosque or the Quran gets it

That’s Terry Jones to Imam Feisal Abdul Rauf, the cleric who plans to build the Islamic center in lower Manhattan a couple of blocks from “Ground Zero.”

GAINESVILLE, Fla. -- Terry Jones, the Florida minister who set the world on edge with plans to burn copies of the Quran on Sept. 11, said Thursday that he had canceled his demonstration because he had won a promise to move the mosque near ground zero to a new location.

But hours later, upon hearing from the project's leaders in New York that no such deal existed, Jones backed away from his promise and said the bonfire of sacred texts was simply "suspended."

The sudden back and forth suggested that the controversy he started -- drawing pointed criticisms from President Barack Obama and an array of leaders, officials and celebrities in the United States and abroad -- was not yet finished even after multiple appearances before the news media on the lawn of his small church. Jones seemed to be struggling with how to save face and hold onto the spotlight he has attracted for an act that could make him a widely reviled figure.

The parson apparently actually believed he was negotiating to move the center:

What swayed him, he said, was not the risk to Americans or foreigners but rather the promise that the Islamic center in New York would be moved.

"This is for us a sign from God," he said.

As Jones walked back into his office, he said that the idea of the mosque as a bartering point came to him only after he had announced his "International Burn a Quran Day" in July. He said he had no regrets.

"We have accomplished what we think God asked us to do," he said.

Which all makes Jones, the former German cultist, just another delusional crackpot in the sweep of the history of religious-inspired violence.

Update: The title of the post was inspired by a discussion at Drinking Liberally last night. One of the regulars observed that conservatives were trying to make an equivalence out of the mosque locating and the Quran burning, and that dependable bag of grievance and resentment Debra J. Saunders did it this morning in the Star Tribune, in a column titled  Christians vs. Muslims: the Double Standard:

When the controversy involves the ground zero mosque, the elites cite the First Amendment; when the controversy draws on the free-speech rights of the devout, editorial page editors switch to the issue of tolerance.

Let me translate. Saunders is saying that Imam Feisal Abdul Rauf equals Terry Jones.

The imam:

The Quran does not speak about Christianity or Judaism. You will not find that word once mentioned in the Quran. But you'll find many, many instances of Christians and Jews, because the definitions the Quran uses are human-based definitions. Not conceptual definitions; very much it speaks about the realities. So God, for example, is creator. God is seeing. God is knowing. God is all-powerful. You don't have words of concepts as much. God is beautiful. So the ascriptions or the descriptions or the adjectives are what are used to describe the creator. Religion is defined by the relationship between God and man. And Islam is the submission and the acknowledgment of the human being to the creator.

Parson Jones:

Capture

I guess you’re right Debbie; I see it now.

Thursday, September 09, 2010

No Time to Subsidize Profit: Minnesota Facts

The numbers speak for themselves. While Minnesota has significantly cut funding for public higher education in Minnesota, state aid has freely flowed to for-profit private higher education. Congressional attention has been focused on the questionable recruitment practices and loan repayment rates of for-profit colleges. However, Minnesota policymakers have not been nearly as aggressive in investigating our own burgeoning for-profit college industry for the same practices and problems. In fact, Minnesota's been among national leaders in transferring state student aid money to this industry.

Consider the following four charts depicting the growth in Minnesota's state tax dollars flowing to for-profit companies operating colleges in Minnesota. These companies include publicly traded national for-profit college chains (such as University of Phoenix, Corinthian, and Career Education Corporation) and a couple of very large privately held for-profit colleges based on Minnesota (such as Minnesota School of Business and Globe College) Here are the top 10 schools that received Minnesota State Grant funds in 2009.


The interest of these national chains is understandable. Minnesota is a national leader in the amount of State need-based student aid that goes to for-profit colleges.


As you can see, Minnesota is #5 in the total amount of need-based aid going to for-profit colleges. In this 2008 survey by the National Association of State Student Grant and Aid Programs, Minnesota also ranked in the top 5 in the proportion of state need-based aid that goes to for-profit colleges.

The amount of federal and state need-based financial aid going to Minnesota for-profit colleges has increased dramatically from 2004-2009.



And the growth of the number of students at for-profit colleges receiving state need-based aid money has outpaced students at all other institutions.


The powerful Minnesota Chamber of Commerce has prioritized protecting this source of revenue for the for-profit college industry. One of their listed "2009 Legislative Accomplishments:"
We defeated a proposal to make for-profit higher education institutions ineligible to receive state grant dollars.
Here's the Chamber's higher education agenda:
Minnesota should invest 30 percent of the state higher education appropriation in programs that distribute resources directly to consumers, thereby giving them access to the higher education opportunity that best fits their individual needs. The best way to give consumers choice in higher education is to allocate the revenue to the Minnesota State Grant Program – the state’s need-based aid program – to help lower- and middle-income students access and afford a college education or additional training beyond a high school diploma. The remaining 70 percent of the appropriation should be invested in the public institutions. The state should expand the parameters of the Minnesota State Grant program whenever Congress expands Pell grant funding to maximize grants in Minnesota.
If adopted, this proposal would triple the biennial allocation for the Minnesota State Grant program and pay for it by cutting support for public higher education commensurately.

Why is it that Minnesota lags behind the national realization that the for-profit college industry is doing a disservice to their students and is public money poorly spent? It's because the powerful Chamber, patron of Tom Emmer, has spent resources and political capital protecting the industry.

It's time that Minnesota started paying attention. Unlike MN2020, I am not comforted by the absence of Minnesota for-profit companies on the list of those investigated by the GAO. The same national chains operate here. At a minimum, the investigative resources of the Legislative Auditor, turned recently toward MnSCU, need to be turned on the for-profit college industry. And it is about time that Minnesota joined the majority of states that spend little or no state tax money subsidizing their profits.

Follow me on Twitter @aaronklemz

Aaron Klemz is an Instructor in the Communication Department at Century College in White Bear Lake, Minnesota. His views are his own, and are not the views of his employer.

Drinking Liberally: soap box edition

soapbox

We don’t have a guest at Drinking Liberally, but it’ll be a “soap box edition,” so bring an issue you want to get off your chest. Practice up; I may record a few of you.

That’s tonight (September 9th) from six to nine at the 331 Club in Northeast Minneapolis.

Generalissimo Tony Speaks

The Suttonese Libelization Army is on the move!

MinnPost photo At a “news event” yesterday, RPM chair Tony Sutton proclaimed that Mark Dayton’s income was “a little odd.” Apparently, Sutton brought all of his forensic accounting skills to bear on that one! The generalissimo has concluded that there is a South Dakota trust involved, and he has questions.

This is funny (“funny” funny, not “odd” funny) on a couple of levels.

First, Sutton owes his “situation” to a guy who recently moved his savings and loan from Minnesota to South Dakota while keeping the name TCF Bank.

Second, while working as the treasurer of the sheltered workshop for accountants known as the Republican Party of Minnesota, he made such a mess of things that they’re still trying to sort them out.

But Sutton is convinced there is something afoot here, even though as Eric Black reports at the link, Dayton has been more forthcoming with financial information than either Republican Emmer or Republican Lite Horner. And Dayton has paid Minnesota income tax on the income he receives from family trusts.

Republican don’t want to pay taxes on income they do receive, but they seem to think that Democrats should pay taxes on income they haven’t received.

Bizarre.

MinnPost photo.

Why they hate us

More news - from the foreign press - about why Muslims and Afghans hate the US. From the Guardian,
US soldiers 'killed Afghan civilians for sport and collected fingers as trophies'
Soldiers face charges over secret 'kill team' which allegedly murdered at random and collected fingers as trophies of war
Of course, Minnesotans can be excused from not knowing these things - I'm betting you'll never see this story in the Star Tribune.  More from the story:
Twelve American soldiers face charges over a secret "kill team" that allegedly blew up and shot Afghan civilians at random and collected their fingers as trophies.
Five of the soldiers are charged with murdering three Afghan men who were allegedly killed for sport in separate attacks this year. Seven others are accused of covering up the killings and assaulting a recruit who exposed the murders when he reported other abuses, including members of the unit smoking hashish stolen from civilians.
Those are our American "heroes," according to the traditional media formulation. This is a supposed liberal president's idea of a "good war."

Wednesday, September 08, 2010

Nothing but blue sky do I see!

If [the poor] would rather die, they had better do it, and decrease the surplus population. (Ebenezer Scrooge, a Christmas Carol)

Both are sentiments — at one time or another, anyway — of today’s financial quack writing in the Star Tribune.

Kevin A. Hassett was a co-author of Dow 36,000, a book published in 1999, shortly before the dot com bubble burst. Oops!

The experience apparently sobered ol’ Kevin (who has dropped the “A,” maybe in a effort to reinvent himself), because he’s got a Grim Reaper thing going now.

Economics teaches that full employment would be reached if wages adjust downward, to a level that better reflects current circumstances. At lower wages, employers would desire more workers. Labor markets generate persistent unemployment only if wages are sticky, failing to fall as demand declines.

A number of reasons help explain why wages don't and won't drop, beginning with federal and state minimum-wage laws.

Gosh, he sounds like Andrew Mellon, the hero of a post here yesterday!

It is perhaps churlish — not to mention unnecessary — to observe that it is improvident indeed to take economic advice from so spectacular a fool as Kevin (A.) Hassett.