Thursday, August 11, 2005

Bob is a really slow learner . . .

From Thursday's letters to the editor in the Strib:
Didn't work last time

Note to Coleen Rowley: If you plan to run for Congress under the "We need the rest of the world's help" banner, I suggest you review another Democrat who recently ran his campaign with a similar "global test" theme. You notice they don't call him President Kerry.

Bob Huge, Edina.
Let's see Bob, what have we learned since last fall's election? In your case, apparently nothing. Since pulling the lever or perhaps pointing at a name on a screen in November, a lot of folks have lately come to realize that the war in Iraq is a huge confidence game. But not you. Spot applauds you for having the courage of your confusion.

And by the way, Bob, your Congressman is Jim Ramstad. Coleen Rowley lives a long, long way from you. Don't worry.

Wednesday, August 10, 2005

Communis rixatrix strikes again . . .

Katherine Kersten loves to start her columns by picking as some festering sore that she thinks we've been neglecting. She did it again in her Thursday August 11th column.
On Sept. 11, 2001, nearly 3,000 Americans died a fiery death in Al-Qaida's attack on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon. On the first anniversary of the attack, Americans everywhere stopped as our nation honored the dead in a moving ceremony at Ground Zero.

But few memorial events are planned for the attack's fourth anniversary, which is just around the corner. Our collective memory of the horrific atrocity seems to be fading.
Pardon me? Memory fading? Yeah, we're just one huge national Alzheimer's patient, turning our head slowly and blinking uncomprehendingly as George Bush and the rest of his sycophant claque scream O GOD! MORE TERRORISTS! WE'LL SAVE YOU! JUST GIVE US YOUR CIVIL RIGHTS! WE AND HALLIBURTON HAVE IT UNDER CONTROL!

Spotty says it is time to call off the National Pity Party and stare reality in the face. By and large, we have acted badly as a nation since 9/11. We have taken our self-pity and turned it into bullying many of our own people and killing and maiming untold thousands of innocents abroad. Every time it was convenient to do so, the neocons have stabbed that raw national nerve, and it has made us crazy.

It made us so crazy that we believed it when George Bush told us we had to attack Iraq instead of finding the guy really behind the 9/11 attacks. It made us so crazy that Congress abandoned its responsibility to be the declarer of war. It made us so crazy that we deserted the collective security framework that we - and Minnesota's own Harold Stassen - helped establish after the Second World War. It made us dismiss, refuse cooperation, and humiliate the weapons inspectors who were trying to verify what we were saying.

And it made us so crazy that we are headed for financial oblivion.

So when Katherine Kersten comes around and wants to stick the electrode called 9/11 up your arse, Spotty says just say no.

Tuesday, August 09, 2005

The empty suit speaks . . .

There was an article today in the Strib about the first indictment in the UN Oil for Food Program. Absolutely inexcusable fraud.
A federal prosecutor investigating corruption in the $64 billion oil-for-food program issued the case's first criminal charges against a U.N. official, accusing a former Russian procurement officer of receiving hundreds of thousands of dollars in bribes from companies doing business with the United Nations.

Alexander Yakovlev, 52, pleaded guilty to three counts of wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and money laundering, said David N. Kelley, the U.S. attorney for the Southern District of New York. If convicted, he could face up to 60 years in prison.
The article goes on to mention a couple of additional names who may be indicted. The final report isn't in yet, but one name was conspicuous by its absence. George Galloway, the British MP that Normie so often and so viciously accused of fraud. This is the George Galloway of whom James Wolcott, one of Spot's favorite bloggers, wrote when Galloway appeared before Normie's committee:
Empty Suit Politician Walks into Propellor
Posted by James Wolcott

Based on what I saw on MSNBC (and congrats to them for going live), I would modestly venture that Norm Coleman and the Senate committee picked on the wrong guy when they picked on George Galloway (scroll down for "This Old Brit's"'s take). His rebuttal so exfoliated Coleman's short hairs that Fox News had to step in afterwards and downplay Galloway's rousing anti-Iraq war broadside as a rhetorical gambit.

God, does Galloway make our own representatives look mushmouthed and gutless.

05.17.05 11:48AM
Predictably though, Normie claimed - and is quoted in the article - that this one indictment and guilty plea prove he was right all along. We should ask MP Galloway what he thinks.

By the way, the amount of funds siphoned off by the indicted individual? About $900.000, hardly pocket change. Unless of course, you compare it to the eight billion dollars missing from the coalition provisional authority's coffers.

Monday, August 08, 2005

What's that noise?

Spotty picked up the StarTribune this morning (August 8th) and heard kind of a muffled noise from within it. As he unfolded the paper, the noise became louder and more distinct, kind of a triumphal, demented cackling sound. Both intrigued and a little alarmed, Spotty kept turning pages until he came to Katherine Kersten's column and there she was: BRRRUCK! BRRRUCK! BRRRUCK! Then Spot saw the title of the column, Judges, get ready for political arena.

Notice, gentle reader, the placement of the comma in that headline. The column is not a description of what is happening; it is an address to judges. Look out you bad boys (and girls)! We're coming for you! The column starts out this way:
Most Minnesotans pay scant attention to our state's judicial elections. Chances are, we see the wholly unfamiliar names of candidates for judgeships on the ballot, shrug our shoulders -- befuddled -- and skip them.

But last week, the federal Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals radically altered our state's rules on judicial elections. Now those races are likely to take on the rough and tumble of political campaigns.
The principal reason that judicial elections are a mystery is because incumbent judges are usually unopposed. Judges are appointed by the governor and must then stand for reelection periodically; Spotty recalls that his lawyer friend told him every six years. The big change?

Judicial candidates may now seek political party endorsement and personally solicit campaign funds. Generally, judges work anonymously which is the way most of them like it. In large judicial districts, like Hennepin or Ramsey counties, most of the judges on the ballot will be trial judges, not Court of Appeals or Supreme Court judges. Katherine continues:
Some Minnesotans are celebrating the Eighth Circuit decision, saying we'll finally learn something about the legal philosophies behind the names on the ballot. Others are concerned about outside influences on judicial independence. Both sides have plausible arguments.
After the brief nod to the fact that some people think this is a bad idea - Katherine has been listening to the people who think she is a plodding ideologue - she spends the rest of the article telling us why it is good. So, Spot assumes this means Katherine is in favor of Supreme Court nominee John Roberts answering every question about issue positions that might be put before him in the Senate Judiciary Committee. Spot will send a copy of this post to Katherine; let him know, will you? Then Katherine says:
But to vote intelligently, people must know how judges view the law, and elections should offer judicial incumbents and challengers as level a playing field as possible.

The Eighth Circuit labeled Minnesota's rules "remarkably pro-incumbent." Our system is so stacked in favor of incumbents that few sitting judges are ever challenged and fewer still are defeated.
Spotty first has to observe that it is pretty rich for a bunch of appointed-for-life federal appeals judges to express concerns about pro-incumbency.

Political campaigns are really well suited to informing the public about things like the festering sore of the abuse of judicial ditches in the state, the candidates' view of the enumerated exceptions to the hearsay rule, and the demise of the fellow servant rule. Just kidding.

What Katherine wants, of course, is for judicial candidates to stake out positions on hot button social issues that might come before a court, especially the Minnesota Supreme Court. This is a spectacularly bad idea. Civil rights are not supposed to be subject to political whim; the whole idea behind civil rights is that they belong to individuals and are protected from encroachment by a majority, which as Spotty has observed before, is sometimes just a mob.
Critics worry that special-interest money will now dominate our judicial elections. They have a point. But special interest money is already a problem. According to the Appeals Court ruling in 2000, Minnesota Supreme Court justices' campaigns raised a total of $505,000, while only two challengers -- whose combined funds totaled about $24,000 -- even raised enough to require disclosure.

A "substantial portion" of incumbents' war chests, the court said, came from lawyers and law firm-related political funds.
Lawyers give money to incumbents, always have. One of the principal reasons is that lawyers are invested in the stability and impartiality of the bench. Having to check a judge's political credentials before a trial will not encourage faith in a impartial bench, especially when a lawyer has to tell a client that a judge was endorsed by party A or B. Will political affiliation be grounds for a lawyer to obtain a change in judge or appeals panel? What if a judge solicits funds from a firm when a lawyer in that firm is trying a case in front of the judge?

You know, the DFL hasn't been appointing judges since Rudy Perpich was governor. A lot of the judges currently sitting have been appointed since then; you really would think that conservatives would have a little more faith in the people they have been appointing.

Katherine criticizes remarks made by Alan Page:
Page stated that a neutral, independent judiciary is the key to justice. Politics, he suggested, is for elected politicians. Judges merely apply the law and enforce rules, like referees at a football game.

Are contemporary judges just impartial referees? Far from it. Many are engaged in ambitious social-engineering projects.

Let's apply Page's referee analogy to the issue of abortion. In 1973, in Roe vs. Wade, the U.S. Supreme Court yanked the issue away from legislatures and legalized abortion nationwide. In 1995, Minnesota's Supreme Court piled on. In Doe vs. Gomez, the state court forced the Minnesota Legislature to appropriate tax money to pay for abortions for poor women -- something federal courts have never required.

On abortion, judges, far from acting as referees, have put on helmets and shoulder pads, intercepted the ball, and run in one direction down the field -- ejecting other players, both Republicans and Democrats, from the game.

The people had no say.
Katherine, you should really be on the sports desk. You wield wooden metaphors with the best of them.

Our favorite communis rixatrix just cannot come to grips with the fact that many people do not agree with her on many social issues. One control freak's ambitious social engineering projects are another person's civil rights. According to Katherine, judges are just a bunch of delinquents in souped-up cars, cruising the streets looking for disputes to settle their way. Which is absurd of course.

Courts only handle cases brought to them. And by and large, there are volumes of precedent that guide and govern the court's decision. By definition, there are at least two points of view. And neither point of view wants to learn that the judge is predisposed to decide against it. They people shouldn't have a say, at least not in the conventional majoritanian sense. Some day the worm will turn and the shoe will be on the other foot. (See, Spotty is good with metaphors, too.)
Judicial independence is a vital aspect of our heritage. But if judges persist in acting like politicians, by usurping the role of our elected representatives, they'll find it hard to convince us not to treat them like politicians.
Katherine is not the least bit interested in judicial independence, quite the opposite. She and all the conservative bug-eyed control freaks just want to be able to beat a judge with a political cudgel if he or she doesn't toe the line.

Saturday, August 06, 2005

Spotty has nothing to add . . .

From an article in a Kentucky newspaper:
PRESTONSBURG - The Iraq war has been a divisive issue in America for more than two years now, but a shooting at an Eastern Kentucky flea market this week might have marked the first time a dispute over the war has resulted in a death.

A quarrel between two firearms vendors at a Floyd County flea market on Thursday allegedly led both men -- described as "good friends" -- to draw guns. Douglas Moore, 65, of Martin, who supports the war, shot and killed Harold Wayne Smith, 56, of Manchester, who opposed it, investigators said.

And of course, it was the fault of the opponent of the war:
Moore was questioned at the Floyd County Jail, but he was released without being charged after Kentucky State Police said it appears he acted in self-defense.

Apparently, violence broke out only after an eloquent argument between the two men:
"Harold was talking about the 14 people that were killed in Iraq the other day and Doug said that just as many people were killed on the highways here," Hamman told the paper.

There is still a need to be quick on the draw in America:
After a scuffle, Newsome said he saw Smith stand beside the snack shed, pull a small pistol out of his pocket, cock the hammer and say, "I'm going to blow your ... brains out."

Witnesses said Moore pulled a .38-caliber pistol from his pocket.

"Doug was just quicker," Harold Hannah of Salyersville said.

And with a hint of admiration, no doubt.

Caption this . . .


Photo from The Poor Man Cafe. Spot thinks he likes these guys.

And the faster the better . . .

From letters in the August 6th StarTribune:
Raising the white flag

Columnist Nick Coleman now contends the citizenry ought to rise up and start yelling about the Iraq war (Star Tribune, Aug. 5). In so doing, he demonstrates an appalling ignorance of recent history.

During the Vietnam War, the Communists, knowing they could not defeat us on the battlefields, came to believe they could win by simply outlasting us. To that end, their strategy became one of killing as many Americans as possible until the American people gave up and left. It worked.

Now some Americans want to make exactly the same mistake in Iraq that we made in Vietnam.

Thomas Malone, Minnetonka.

Spotty says that Tommy is the one who's appallingly ignorant of recent history. Robert McNamara and the Pentagon concluded early in the Johnson administration that the Vietnam conflict was unwinnable. Johnson knew this; it is probably the reason he didn't stand for office in 1968. Johnson did not want the war lost on his watch.

In a CNN interview, McNamara said this about the Vietnam conflict:
This was much more a civil war than a war of aggression. I'm not arguing that there wasn't an element of aggression in it; I'm not arguing that the Chinese and the Soviets might not have tried to use South Vietnam as a launching pad to knock over the dominoes of Malaysia and Thailand and Indonesia and whatever. But what I am arguing is that the conflict within South Vietnam itself had all of the characteristics of a civil war, and we didn't look upon it as largely a civil war, and we weren't measuring our progress, as one would have in what was largely a civil war. ...

It is said that the military operated with one hand tied behind their backs. To the extent that that refers to a restriction on land invasion by U.S. forces on North Vietnam, that's true. But today, General Westmoreland, who was the commander in Vietnam at the time, says that while at the time he felt he was constrained, he now understands that that was an effort by the president to prevent the U.S. coming into open military conflict with China and the Soviet Union. And Westmoreland says, "Thank God we avoided that. That was a correct policy at the time." Could more military pressure have been applied, in the sense of more bombing of the North? In one sense, no. We dropped two or three times as much bombs in North and South Vietnam as were dropped by all Allied Forces throughout World War II against all enemies. It was a tremendous air effort. But there are certain things bombing can't accomplish. They can't break the will of people under certain circumstances. They didn't break the will of the North Vietnamese. And it cannot stop the movement of the small quantities of supplies that were necessary to support the Viet Cong and the North Vietnamese forces in the South. They didn't, and it couldn't; and no additional amount of money [or] bombing could have. ...

As early as December 1965, I reported to the President that I believed there was no more than a one-in-three chance -- at best a one-in-two chance -- that we could achieve our political objectives, i.e. avoiding the loss of South Vietnam, by military means.

Well, Tommy boy, that sounds a awful lot like Iraq, especially the civil war part. I guess we're just about as good at politics in the Middle East as we are in Southeast Asia! If we had followed Stay the Course Bush's policy in Vietnam, John McCain and the rest of his buddies would still be in the Hanoi Hilton.

Spotty is all in favor of making the same mistake in Iraq as we finally did in Vietnam. But then, Spotty is not so contaminated with hubris that he believes that the United States is so exceptional that it always wins.

Tags:

Friday, August 05, 2005

What's the unifying theme?

What do a tap dancer, Elmer Gantry, and Ayn Rand have in common? Spot's not sure, but Jim Ramstad channeled all three in his appearance at the town hall meeting in Edina on Wednesday night.

The Congressman fielded several questions about his support for private accounts for Social Security. He dodged them all, sometimes even adroitly, resolutely refusing to commit himself on the desirability of one thing or another as a solution or even part of a solution. He wouldn't even engage with the crowd in a discussion of the merits of different proposals. Ramstad said we have a problem, and that's it.

Speaking of the crowd, most of the people in attendance were well, older. In fact, Ramstad commented that most of the people in the audience didn't need to worry about Social Security privitization. Some one called out yes we do, we have children and grandchildren.

That's the tap dancer.

There was one moment while Ramstad was discussing improvements in the unemployment rate that one man said that he had been laid off several months before and that he was in danger of being laid off at his temporary job. He demanded to know what Ramstad was going to do about it. Ramstad strode from the podium, shook the man's hand, and promised to help him. Ramstad then said that the economy was doing well, but that so long as one of his constituents who wanted a job didn't have one, he would continue to work.

He also played to the crowd on mental health insurance parity and renewal energy sources.

That was Elmer Gantry.

Ramstad also spent some time defending "the president's tax cuts" and their role in growing the economy. As Spotty mentioned earlier, several members of the audience castigated Ramstad for the role of the tax cuts in the current budget deficit. And they didn't buy Ramstad's line that it was 9/11's fault.

Ayn Rand wrote the feel-good conservative cult classic Atlas Shrugged. It's sort of like the Left Behind series for economic conservatives. The book is Rand's defense of unbridled capitalism, hyper-individualism, and minimal taxation of the wealthy. Here's a Cliff's Note article on the book. Spotty will write more on Ayn Rand sometime.

This was, of course, the Ayn Rand moment.

Thursday, August 04, 2005

Back to the old lingo . . .

Spotty told you that the global struggle against violent extremists or G-SAVE, would never fly.

Stop worrrying, and learn to love the bomb.

How do you turn a story about suffering and courage into a preachy polemic? It's easy really. Just turn the story over to Minnesota's premier communis rixatrix, Katherine Kersten. She did it again today, August 4th. We're coming up on the 60th anniversary of the dropping of the atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. In a column entitled The Bomb saved innumerable lives, Katherine first tells us about the cruelty of the Japanese war machine. It was unimaginably cruel. She actually interviewed a couple of vets from the Pacific theater of WWII; they have gripping stories to tell.

Spotty says that if you are interested in accounts like these, you should read The Ghost Soldiers by Hampton Sides. It is the story of the Bataan death march and the rescue of the survivors of the march by Army Rangers at the close of the war. The Rape of Nankin by Iris Chang is also recommended.

After landing on Utah Beach and sloughing across Europe until VE Day, and then being sent stateside for ultimate redeployment for the invasion of Japan, Spotty's alter ego's dad was pretty glad the war ended when it did, too. However.

Katherine complains that we've forgotten about 1945:
As the 60th anniversary of "the bomb" approaches, we've largely forgotten conditions in 1945. Our children get ideas about the war from books such as "Sadako and the Thousand Paper Cranes," an elementary school favorite about a young Hiroshima victim. They learn of the bomb's horrors but not why it was dropped.
Never mind that World War II has been fought for sixty years by every movie star from John Wayne to Jimmy Stewart to George Scott to Tom Hanks to that mannequin from St. Paul. If you watch the History Channel, you would think that WWII is the only thing that ever happened. The Whiskey Rebellion, now that's been forgotten, but WWII? The statement is laughable.

Then, Katherine has to pick on the author of a book who lived through the Hiroshima bombing as a child and the teachers (all undoubtedly public school teachers of course) who assign it in class. Katherine is afraid that reading about the suffering of innocents other than ourselves will teach empathy, clearly an undesirable trait in young Americans.

It isn't even clear that the atomic bombs were solely responsible for the end of the war. In an article in the online version of US News and World Report, the Japanese surrendered on August 15th, and their surrender may have had as much to do with the fact that Russia declared war on Japan on the 9th of August:
While there's no doubt that the bomb that was dropped on Hiroshima 60 years ago profoundly changed the world, it's less clear than ever that it was the decisive measure it has long been portrayed to be. In a recent book, Racing the Enemy, which draws on Russian, American, and Japanese archives, Tsuyoshi Hasegawa, a professor of history at the University of California-Santa Barbara, argues that it was the Soviet Union's declaration of war on August 9 that ultimately prompted Japan's August 15 surrender. That move dashed the hopes of Tokyo hard-liners that the imperial house could be preserved and that unconditional surrender--as demanded by the Allies--could be avoided. "The official history of the Japanese imperial headquarters states very laconically that the second atomic bomb on Nagasaki didn't have any influence on the outcome of the surrender debate," says Hasegawa, whose book is one of the first to make a detailed study of the political interplay among the Soviet Union, Japan, and the United States in 1945. "Japan had already suffered massive destruction greater than that caused by the atomic bomb, and the leadership was more concerned with the final status of the emperor than civilian casualties."
You can read the whole article here. The Russians, my God, the Russians.

The article also explains why Hiroshima and Nagasaki were chosen for the bomb drops:
Five months earlier, American planes had dropped more than half a million canisters of napalm on Tokyo, killing between 100,000 and 200,000 people--roughly the same number of casualties as in Hiroshima and Nagasaki--and laying waste to more than 16 square miles of the city. Similar raids decimated most of Japan's major cities in the final months of the war. Indeed, one of the reasons Hiroshima and Nagasaki were selected was that they were among the only cities untouched by conventional bombing. The effect of the new bomb would be more evident on virgin targets.
In other words, these two cities were of no evident military or industrial value, since they had not been bombed before.

Spotty's purpose is not to rehash the decision to bomb these two Japanese cities. He does wish that Kersten had at least some capacity to understand that things aren't always black or white, good or bad.

Technical announcement . . .

The Cucking Stool has switched over to the Haloscan commenting system. In making the switch, the old Blogger comments seem to have evaporated into the ether. If you had a comment to a post that you thought was especially pithy or funny, you will have to resubmit the comment. Spotty regrets the inconvenience.

That is all.

Wednesday, August 03, 2005

Spotty sniffs the air . . .

. . . and smells roasting political flesh.

Congressman Jim Ramstad is holding a series of town hall meetings this week; tonight's (Wednesday) was at the Edina City Hall. The overflow crowd ranged from hostile all the way to skeptical of the Congressman's remarks. Ramstad was clearly on edge, even in the friendly confines of Edina.

There were a number of topics raised: social security privitization, tax equity, the jobs climate, CAFTA, defense spending, and Ramstad made reference to the war or terra.

Regarding the global war on terra, Jim, apparently you didn't get the memo. It's no longer the global war on terror, or GWOT, it's G-SAVE, the global struggle against violent extremism. God that's catchy. We've spent over $250 billion fighting a war that the administration now says doesn't exist?

Spotty doesn't think it is going to work, though, because the new slogan just doesn't have the boogie man quality of the global war on terra. Ramstad trotted out the war on terra to justify the enormity of the budget deficit and the budget shennigans to account for George's grudge match with Saddam off budget. The crowd didn't buy it and made that pretty clear to Ramstad. There was a guy there from the Edina Peacemakers who chewed out Ramstad pretty good; a couple of cards with some military budget facts were handed out at the meeting. Spotty will put them in another post.

In fact, stay tuned for more about the meeting in the next day or two.

Compasssionate Conservatism


Another great cartoon from Non Sequitur. The little ramp in front of the wheel chair says "Stem Cell Research Ramp."

Tuesday, August 02, 2005

Even Norm was impressed . . .


I signed my name!

That's the caption this picture got on a blog called Dependable Renegade that specializes in wicked captions from photos in the news. Spotty says check it out.

Spotty is cowering under the bed . . .

Juan Cole of Informed Comment tells the scariest bedtime story that Spotty has even read.

Spotty! Bad dog . . .

Spotty is feeling rather uninspired, so he has been slumming at the ever-reliable Powerline for material. As usual, it does not disappoint:
I spoke on a "blog" panel yesterday afternoon at the Young America's Foundation National Conservative Student Conference program for college students in Washington, D.C. My fellow panelists were LaShawn Barber of LaShawn Barber's Corner and Mark Tapscott of Tapscott's Copy Desk. (Mark has already posted a report: "A fine time on Young America's Foundation panel on blogs.") Alex Mooney of the National Journalism Center moderated the panel and provided lavish introductions.

My strongest impression was of the quality of the ladies and gentlemen attending the program. They were beautiful and handsome, respectively, as well as smart and engaged. Their questions during the program were challenging, and their questions after the program were even more challenging. File under: "Hope for the future."

Ian Schwartz is proprietor of The Political Teen. Ian has posted "Scott Johnson, LaShawn Barber and Mark Tapscott at YAF conference" complete with video images and a video link.

Posted by Scott at 06:30 AM
In other words, it was a giant conservative circle jerk. (Spotty, bad dog! This is a family blog!) Ok, sorry. It was a giant conservative cluster f***. (Hey! You know what happened to James Dobson's dog, don't you? Knock it off!)

Scott's observation discloses something really important about the conservative mindset. It is all about us! Look at how good we are! We are quality persons!

In truth, a lot of them are really emotionally needy people with a continuing need of proving to themselves that they have a leg up on the competition (everybody else). It's sad really. Not to mention delusional. But it has an effect on virtually everything the US does, from foreign policy on down. As Paul Krugman wrote in the NYT a few days ago, Americans tend to believe that we do everything better than anyone else. That belief makes it hard for us to learn from others.

Think about Katherine Kersten. Have you ever read a person more in need of proving, twice a week usually, the existence of a Quality Person's Club and her memebership in it? Perhaps it was emotionally-distant parents or a loveless marriage.

Monday, August 01, 2005

Caution: Wonk alert . . .

Spot's feeling lazy in the heat, so he'll pick of an easy one from the letters in the August 1st StarTribune:
Estate tax and slavery

According to the Star Tribune, the estate tax is needed because of the revenue the government receives. It claims this is good fiscal policy.

However, you neglect to state that the estate tax is an additional tax on money that has already been taxed. The government just wants to double dip on a pool of money.

The editorial also denounces the conservative activists for making a moral argument against the tax. So sound fiscal policy should trump morality? By that logic, then slavery should have been acceptable, because it was sound fiscal policy.

Stephen Lose, Coto de Caza, Calif.
It is the highlighted language that Spot wants to well, highlight. It is such a stupid argument that it could only be made worse by some idiotic reference to slavery. Never mind.

A lot of accumulated wealth, particularly in the hands of those people wealthy enough to have an estate tax burden, is actually untaxed capital gains on wealth appreciation. One of the things that happens when someone dies is that the basis of their property is adjusted - usually up, sometimes way up - to the fair market value in the hands of the heirs.

So, let's pretend that Daddy bought some shares of say, Google. He paid $100,000 for the shares, but when Daddy died, they were worth ten times that, a million dollars. Wow, pretty good investment! If Daddy sold the shares the day before he died, his estate would owe capital gains (income) tax on $900,000. If, however, Daddy died with the shares in his safe deposit box, there would be no income tax and the heirs would get their basis "bumped" up to $1 million. (Don't sell, Daddy, please don't sell!) Then, it would only be any gain above the $1 million on which the heirs would have to pay income tax. Neat!

You know what your tax basis is if you can't prove it? Zero. That 's one of the reasons for adjusting basis to fair market value when a person dies. Sometimes the heirs would have a devil of a time proving Daddy's basis, as in the case of real property where capital improvements made over the years add to basis but are hard to establish.

So, Stephen, would it be better to get rid of the estate tax but carry forward the basis in the assets to the heirs? Then, if they couldn't establish basis, they would get to pay capital gains on 100% of the proceeds of any eventual sale.

It doesn't always work this way, of course, but it does a pretty fair amount of the time. The only fair (and you want to be fair right, Stephen?) way to abolish the estate tax is to give their heirs a carry over basis from Daddy.

Sunday, July 31, 2005

Why do they hate US?

Here are the opening paragraphs of a post by Michael Smerconish on The Huffington Post:
Why do they hate us? It’s a question that I have avoided for close to four years. To entertain the issue seems to acknowledge that there could have been some rational justification for what occurred on 9/11, moreover, even addressing the issue sounds unmanly. Instead, this has been my mindset:

‘F ‘em. Who cares why they hate us. Regardless of what motivated an unprovoked attack, they need to die. All of them who played any role. As soon as possible. End of story. And, stop being such a wimp.’

I think my American hardheadedness is typical of many who seek justice and revenge, but mainly revenge.

Now I find myself re-assessing the situation. In large part, this is due to my having just spent a few hours with Michael Scheuer. You’ll remember him. He’s the guy who spent 22 years at the CIA, four of them as the head of the Bin Laden desk, and then resigned shortly after publishing Imperial Hubris under the byline of “Anonymous.”

He’s critical of the way the Administration is waging the war on terror, and the neocons in particular. (“Only the village idiot or a neoconservative could fail to see that we abjectly failed to estimate the impact on the Muslim world of a U.S. occupation of Iraq.”) He’s equally critical of our prior president, less you should think he plays partisan favorites. (“After al Qaeda destroyed two U.S. embassies in Africa on 7 August 1998, we rejoiced that the government now would annihilate al Qaeda. No effective action ensured.”) Further, he maintains that his agents gave the U.S. government 10 opportunities to capture Bin Laden pre-9/11.

Scheuer thinks we Americans continue to be sold a bill of goods, which fosters a misunderstanding of our enemy, and forestalls success in the war on terror. Specifically, we’re told that radical Islam hates us, and attacks us, for who we are and what we think, when that is not the case. It’s not McDonalds, Starbucks, lap dances and Brittany Spears – offensive though Muslims may find those hallmarks of American life. And it’s not about converting us to Islam. To the contrary, says Scheuer, what motivates radical Islam is American foreign policy. It’s our support for Israel, our troops on the Arabian Peninsula, our occupation of Iraq and Afghanistan, our support for Russia, India and China against their Muslim militants, our pressure on Arab energy producers to keep prices low, and our support for tyrannical Muslim governments.
Spotty just read this post, and it contains the thoughts of a genuine expert on bin Laden and radical Islam, Michael Scheuer. Spotty say go read the whole post. It explains better than Spotty did in Who Remembers DudleyDoright? why the idea that our enemy is free floating evil is hogwash.

Who remembers Dudley Doright?

On July 28th, Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice gave an interview to Jim Lehrer of NPR's News Hour. It was the usual political bob and weave, but Spotty perked up his ears at one part of the interview particularly:
JIM LEHRER: What about the additional element here that, increasingly, terrorism experts and Muslim experts are saying that the combination of Iraq and other foreign policy decisions by the United States are actually creating more terrorists every day than they are eliminating them.
CONDOLEEZZA RICE: When we are going to stop making excuses for the terrorists? The terrorists on Sept. 11 attacked the United States. We weren't in Iraq. We weren't even in Afghanistan on Sept. 11.
No, Condi sweetie, but we were in Saudi Arabia and countless other places in the Middle East, usually supporting repressive Arab regimes. We weren't "in" Iraq, but we sure were around it, lobbing bombs and missiles with some regularity. But maybe most significant all, was the uncritical US support of Israel and its treatment of the Occupied Territories; Arabs see the consequences of this on TV all the time, and they don't fail to take notice.
They have attacked in places that had no forces in either place. They've attacked all over the world. They've attacked in Morocco and in Bali and in Egypt and in London and in Madrid.
And in every case, the attacks were against what were perceived as western interests or proxies.
When are we going to stop making excuses for the terrorists and saying that somebody is making them do it? No, these are simply evil people who want to kill. And they want to kill in the name of a perverted ideology that really is not Islam, but they somehow want to claim that mantle to say that this is about some kind of grievance. This isn't about some kind of grievance. This is an effort to destroy, rather than to build.

And until everybody in the world calls it by name -- the evil that it is -- stops making excuses for them, then I think we're going to have a problem. And I hope that after the bombings of innocent people in London, innocent people at Sharm el-Sheikh, innocent children in Iraq, that people will call this by name and stop making excuses for these people.
The notion that there is a free floating force called evil is an ancient one. It is a useful notion, because it is a sure fire way to cut off debate about a difficult subject, and especially when you are trying to deflect any examination of your own conduct or decisions. If you can reduce a group of people to evil, the Other, then anybody who tries to criticize you is just plain crazy and immoral. Who's your witch doctor, Condi?

When George Bush began to speak of evildoers, it had an odd ring to an old dog like Spotty. He eventually figured it out: the cartoon Mountie Dudley Doright used to rail the against the evildoers all the time. A coincidence? Spotty doesn't think so.

We will continue to have a problem so long as we think we are fighting the boogie man.
No one is making them do it. They're doing it because they want to create chaos and to undermine our way to life.
People (and dogs) who are opposed to the US invasion and occupation of Iraq largely understand something that Condi apparently doesn't; the US cannot make the terrorists stop. We can huff and puff and rant and rave, but as more and more people are figuring out, it is non-productive or even counter-productive. But gee, that sounds so unfair! Maybe so, but we live in the world of "is" not "ought."

As far as ways of life are concerned, Islamic militants are a lot more concerned about how they perceive western influence, rightly or wrongly, to affect their way of life than they are concerned about our way of life. In fact, the militants are simply engaged in the same evildoer rhetoric that we are.

So, the smart things to do would be to adopt a crash program to reduce dependence on oil from the Mideast, spend money domestically to protect chemical and nuclear plants and our ports, and get out of Iraq now before we grind our armed forces into dust finer than the sand in which it is presently mired in a unwinnable war of attrition. Iraq is already descending into civil war. Iraq will inevitably follow the path of Yugoslavia when the repressive communist regime collapsed. The bright lights in Washington should have figured that out before we lit the power keg.

Oh yes, and one thing more. We could make our good friends the Israelis (and Spotty says that absolutely genuinely and without a trace of irony, really) deal fairly - and even humanely - with the Palestinians. The land grab on the West Bank under the Sharon government is shameful. It is often the case the oppressed and abused became the abusers and oppressors.

Friday, July 29, 2005

Minnesota Chain Saw Massacre . . .

Spotty was going to say a few words about this asinine post from Hindrocket at Powerline. It is about what a brilliant man George Bush is, and how the Asia Pacific Partnership on Clean Development and Climate, which the administration is negotiating, is so much better than that nasty old Kyoto Protocol.

While Spotty was navel gazing however - I'll bet you don't know where a dog's navel is - The Rude Pundit put up a great post, carefully dissecting Hindrocket with a chain saw. The Rude Pundit is, well it would be charitable to call him merely rude, but it is a great post you can read here.