Sunday, September 16, 2007

There's Still Time to Vote!!!

My normal blogging home has a poll up and running. Go check it out. There are only a few days left to weigh in. Just click on the link and look to the upper-right sidebar for the question.

Saturday, September 15, 2007

More Boners from Boehner

From TPM:
"It's apparent that some Democrats and the far-left wing of their party are deeply afraid we are winning in Iraq now, and it's clear they will do anything they can -- including making false representations -- to ensure our troops come home after defeat, not victory," said Boehner spokeswoman Jessica Towhey.
It should be noted that Mr. Boehner's "small price" comment came on the heels of this question:
BLITZER: How much longer will U.S. taxpayers have to shell out $2 billion a week or $3 billion a week as some now are suggesting the cost is going to endure? The loss in blood, the Americans who are killed every month, how much longer do you think this commitment, this military commitment is going to require?
He was asked about dead Americans and he answered. There is no false representation.

It should also be noted that Mr. Boehner's far-left-being-afraid comment is just as troubling as Hillary's quote about a terrorist attack helping Republicans. I do not disagree with either Boehner or Clinton on their respective opinions. One of the saddest aspects of the current state of political affairs is that both parties stand to gain from the continued (and additional) loss of American life; Republicans with a terrorist attack and Democrats with an increasingly chaotic Iraq. Who knows, maybe we'll be "blessed" with both. (How's that for a hypothetical? Which sick version of America wins if they happen simultaneously? Democrats with a more chaotic Iraq or Republicans with another terrorist attack?)

Who cares. As long as the world's greatest college football team keeps on steamrolling opponents, all is good.

Too Funny

It's kind of sad, but I still keep a Google search open for "schiavo". This popped up yesterday:
THE VILLAGES, Fla. (AP) - Republican presidential candidate Fred Thompson gave no opinion Thursday when asked about efforts by President Bush and Congress to keep Terri Schiavo alive, saying he does not remember details of the right-to-die case that stirred national debate.

Thompson was asked in an interview for Bay News 9's "Political Connections" program whether he thought Congress' intervention to save the life of the brain-dead woman two years ago was appropriate.

"I can't pass judgment on it. I know that good people were doing what they thought was best," Thompson said. "That's going back in history. I don't remember the details of it."

He doesn't remember. Maybe he should ask his fellow Tennessean for a quick refresher.

Small Prices in Iraq

In honor of John Boehner, here are some of the small prices being paid in our Iraqi investment:

From MSNBC:
BAGHDAD - The number of suspected cholera cases in northern Iraq continues to rise, with 16,000 people now showing symptoms, the World Health Organization said Friday.
That's not too bad!

From CNN:
Sheik Jamal al-Sudani leads a group of volunteers with one of the most solemn tasks in Iraq: Collecting and burying the hundreds of unclaimed dead every month and giving them a proper burial.
That's a very small price to pay. No one even knows their names. I'm sure we couldn't pronounce them even if we did.

From the Guardian:
WASHINGTON (AP) - Religious freedom has sharply deteriorated in Iraq over the past year because of both the insurgency and violence targeting people of specific faiths, despite the U.S. military buildup intended to improve security, says a State Department report to be released Friday.
As long as any Christians aren't losing their freedom, I think we'll be OK with this one being defined as a small price.

These are all small prices folks. What is really important is this:
WASHINGTON, D.C. – Congressman John Boehner (R-West Chester) issued the following statement calling on House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-CA), Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-NV), and all Democrats to denounce the full-page advertisement from Moveon.org defaming General Petraeus that appeared this morning in the New York Times:

“Democratic leaders must make a choice today: either embrace the character assassination tactics Moveon.org has leveled against the four-star general leading our troops in the fight against al Qaeda, or denounce it as disgraceful.
It's time for you to REDiscover the Republican Party.

Friday, September 14, 2007

Meet Another Republican

John Cornyn:
Sen. John Cornyn (R-TX) has released a statement praising President Bush’s speech on Iraq last night, saying he is “pleased” that “troops will come home before the year’s end”

...

Yet last month, Cornyn was adamantly opposed to this drawdown. On Aug. 23, Sen. John Warner (R-VA) called on Bush to announce on Sept. 15 that approximately 5,000 troops “could begin to redeploy and be home to their families and loved ones no later than Christmas of this year.” Cornyn immediately put out a statement blasting Warner’s proposal
I can't decide whether or not this is a step up or down from his box turtle comment.

PS: Please keep in mind that while he may now support what he previously opposed, John Cornyn supports the right of the troops to die in bunches for whatever side of the issue he currently thinks is the most politically expedient for him to be on.

Ladies and Gentlemen, Your Republican Party

As you watch this, keep in mind that this is a video produced by Republicans as a pitch for you to buy into what they have to offer.

Maybe it is no longer possible...

...for the man to speak more than five minutes without lying.

Now that it's all said and done...

A few things to remember about the Petraeus hearings.

1st, the surge's goals, as outlined by President Bush way back in January, were clearly not met:
"To establish its authority, the Iraqi government plans to take responsibility for security in all of Iraq's provinces by November. To give every Iraqi citizen a stake in the country's economy, Iraq will pass legislation to share oil revenues among all Iraqis. To show that it is committed to delivering a better life, the Iraqi government will spend $10 billion of its own money on reconstruction and infrastructure projects that will create new jobs. To empower local leaders, Iraqis plan to hold provincial elections later this year. And to allow more Iraqis to re-enter their nation's political life, the government will reform de-Baathification laws, and establish a fair process for considering amendments to Iraq's constitution." - President Bush, Jan 10, 2007
2nd, General Petraeus' recommendations for drawing down troop levels were not based on the data presented in his report:
So much for "conditions." Under questioning from Sen. Jack Reed (D-RI), Gen. Petraeus conceded that his timetable for ending the surge by July 2008 is due to the five extra active-duty Brigade Combat Teams coming to the end of their scheduled deployments and the lack of available units to keep U.S. troop strength at 162,000.
3rd, after nearly 7 years into a presidency marked by hyper-partisanship, Mr. Bush's speech was little more than a whinny call for everyone to suck it up and support his view of the war in a show of "bipartisanship":
Whatever political party you belong to, whatever your position on Iraq, we should be able to agree that America has a vital interest in preventing chaos and providing hope in the Middle East.
He later added, "as long as the way you choose to express this position matches up with what I want." (Paraphrased.)

4th, after rolling out a report that magically aligned with everything he had already been saying, and after giving a speech that magically aligned with the report that aligned with what he had already been saying, Mr. Bush announced that he had a new way of marketing what he had already been saying:
WASHINGTON — Eight months after President Bush made public a plan he hailed as the "New Way Forward" in Iraq, he's announced a new plan, this one called "Return on Success."

The new plan was reminiscent of last year's "Operation Together Forward," which called for U.S. troops to secure neighborhoods in Baghdad and hand them over to Iraqi security forces. It bore similarities to an even older plan commonly articulated with the catchphrase "as they stand up, we'll stand down."
Wow!!! It even has a catchphrase!!! Of course, this new plan will come complete with a season finale staring David Petraeus.

On a finishing note, what is really sad about all of this is not that everyone buys into this garbage (they don't), but that the only reason something like this can work is because Republican support for the war has stabilized and Mr. Bush knows that he has a built-in audience where this sort of nonsense has more appeal than a Viagra commercial does to Fred Thompson.

Wayne Brady Thinks Everything Is GREAT!!!

Here's what came on Fox in place of the Democratic response last night: Don't Forget the Lyrics. All of the other networks stayed with their coverage until the response finished up.

Thursday, September 13, 2007

Must Watch

BBC report on the Dover trial and ID:



You can watch the second, third, fourth, and fifth parts on YouTube by alt clicking on the image.

You can follow up your viewing with Why Darwin Matters, River Out of Eden, and these fine websites:

Evolution Society
Talk Origins
National Center for Science Education

There is no "debate" between Darwinism and ID. There is no scientific legitimacy to ID. Evolution IS and you need to know about it.

Here's an easy initial test for your Darwinian knowledge:



Hint: Google "domestic banana" and "wild banana." Natural selection truly is a wonderful bitch.

Faux News

I don't get cable so I had to sift through the local channels for Bush's speech. (Side note: How much does TV suck?!) All of the networks ran a description of the speech as something like "President's Speech to the Nation". Except one. Fox News ran "Iraq: Moving Forward." Are you kidding me? They were also the only network to not air the Democratic response.

Can we stop pretending that Petraeus is anything but a Republican partisan (and an unprofessional one at that)? We have months and months of build up for the report; he gets to the Hill sans a written report; finally agreeing with everything that Bush has been saying for the last 6 months. Bush then goes on TV and says that the "new course" in Iraq will be based on Petraeus' recommendations (which, as mentioned before, are no different from anything that he has been saying for the past 6 months; not to mention the fact that they are not based on conditions on the ground or have any known methodology.)

Best news gleaned from the speech: Petraeus will be back with yet another report in March. That's 6 months from now for those of you unfamiliar with Friedman Units.

We deserve this. We really do.

Bigoted?

If you follow Ms. Kersten's reasoning (from the BBC):
Police in the Belgian capital, Brussels, have arrested two far-right political leaders at a protest against the "Islamisation of Europe".

Police clashed with some of the 200 demonstrators and dozens more people were reported to have been arrested.

The mayor of Brussels had banned the protest, held on the sixth anniversary of the 9/11 attacks on the US.

...

The mayor of Brussels, Freddy Thielemans, banned the protest last month for fear it would cause problems with the city's immigrant population.
That last sentence is dressed up quite a bit. By "immigrant population" they mean "angry Muslims." (Which, knowing very little of the SIOE and their mission, seems to have have validated the entire point of the protest.)

What is going on here? Is Brussels' "immigrant population" telling the secular government of Belgium that it better perk up and listen because those who slander Islam need to be threatened? Is the secular government of Belgium responding by bartering away part of its free society to an unprovable faith equipped with dogma that seeks to deny anyone the right to resist it? Or is this group a bunch of xenophobe bigots?

Day 3 of the Griffin-Gate

It's not a direct hit, but the Catholic League once again takes aim at Kathy Griffin:
“The next time someone tells me that the Catholic League shouldn’t be worried about bigots like Kathy Griffin—‘we have a war going on,’ they thunder!’—I’ll be sure to tell them what passes as the ‘Top Story’ at Newsweek.”
Here's a link to the 'Top Story'.

Rerun Season at the Strib

It appears that Katherine Kersten has mailed in a recycled column today. Choosing to substitute the good judges of the Iowa courts for those of Massachusetts in fear mongering about the demise of marriage, her good readers are subjected to the tiresome arguments that if we fail to enshrine bigotry against gay and lesbian people in our State Constitution, we'll never be able to practice it.

Spotty may be off in a far away doghouse this week, but we can recycle, too!

Kersten has her expectation of what a marriage should look like, and woe be unto anybody that suggests something else. She even says so in the concluding paragraph of the piece:
Minnesotan believe that gays and lesbians have a right to live as they please. (Well, clearly not all of them do.) But they don't believe that gays and lesbians have the right to redefine the institution of marriage for everyone else.

So in the end even Katherine Kersten admits this is an issue of civil rights and equal protection. Heterosexuals have something that gives them an advantage they don't want to give up. Just like every privileged class in the history of the world.

Set Like a Watch

In hindsight, I should have seen this coming:
In the Equality Minnesota poll, 61 percent agreed with the statement: "Minnesota already has a law banning same-sex marriage; we don't need a constitutional amendment." A year before, a poll conducted for Minnesota for Marriage found that 61 percent of Minnesota residents would vote for the amendment.

Thousands of Iowans can now tell you that a law is not enough.

This is a big subject for Ms. Kersten. A quick google search shows several of her columns on the subject and her blog page has a link list called On Marriage and the Family. At the very least she should have her facts down.

Yes and no.

First the nos. Since she is a lawyer, this transition is kind of disingenuous (at best):
In Hanson's view, Iowans had no rational basis for supporting such a law.

Hanson based his decision on the Iowa Constitution, ruling that the state's marriage law violated its equal protection and due process provisions.
I guess if she had written, "Iowans supported a law that was ruled to have violated their own Constitution," it would have diminished the majesty of her remaining work. She then goes on to tell her audience that if the judicial system works in the way that it is supposed to work, Iowa's marriage law could be a thing of the past. This is truly frightening stuff.

My only other factual quibble with Ms. Kersten is what she has to say about Dean Johnson. Mr. Johnson wasn't done in for gay marriage reasons alone. His unwillingness to keep the outdoors amendment alive did not play well in Willmar and it should play into any consideration of the reasons why he lost his election.

I suppose there may be some other things in there that I am unaware of. I'm not a lawyer and I don't really follow this issue so I'll have to pass judgment to someone like MNO to talk about Ms. Kersten's claims about 1/2 the country's marriage laws being attacked by a small group of activists, and that these activists are seeking out activist judges to agree with them (sort of like the activist creationists who clog up our court system, I suppose.)

The rest of the column actually works. She makes an argument and it flows logically from proposition to conclusion: Judges are overturning laws that you thought were "safe" and it is likely that if you don't do anything to change (enshrine in the Constitution) a law that you like, it will get changed (stricken down) for you.

Let's cut to the chase. While her reasoning, for once, may be sound, her argument's fatal flaw (aside from the might makes right crap) is displayed late in the game (italics are mine):
Some politicos claim that the marriage amendment is unnecessary because the Minnesota Supreme Court has already ruled on, and rejected, same-sex marriage. But that case, Baker vs. Nelson, was decided 36 years ago -- long before judges dreamed that elite opinion-makers would one day denounce male-female marriage as mean-spirited bigotry.
Ms. Kersten plays a neat trick here. She begins by talking about majority opinion being in support of Minnesota's current marriage law; however, by the end of her column she is using words like bigotry and assault to describe the minority opinion and its action against the majority.

You can't just make the leap from "a lot of people believe in X" to "Y's action against X is bigoted." There has to be something in between and that something has to be a valid indicator of bigotry. If we were to run around demanding that each and every majority opinion be protected against bigotry...well, here are some popular things that Americans believe:
- Nearly two-thirds of Americans believe that the Bible holds the answers to all or most of life's basic questions, yet only half of American adults can name even one of the four gospels and most Americans cannot name the first book of the Bible.
- In a 2004 study of Bible literacy among high school students, most evangelical participants were not able to identify "Blessed are the poor in spirit" as a quote from the Sermon on the Mount.
- Only one-third know that Jesus (not Billy Graham) delivered the Sermon on the Mount.
- A majority of Americans wrongly believe that the Bible says that Jesus was born in Jerusalem.
- When asked whether the New Testament book of Acts is in the Old Testament, one quarter of Americans say yes. More than a third say they don't know.
- Most Americans don't know that Jonah is a book in the Bible.
- Ten percent of Americans believed that Joan of Arc was Noah's wife.
You can find these troubling statistics (and many more), in the first chapter of Stephen Prothero's excellent book Religious Literacy: What Every American Needs to Know--And Doesn't.

As you can probably guess by my selection of statistics, the pink elephant in Ms. Kersten's column is religious faith. I won't claim to know the reasons why it was left out of her column, but I know, you know, the editors know, and her readers know that religious faith is the bridge between majority opinion and claims of bigotry. There is no other option. Sure you can claim that single parent families do not fare as well as ones with a mom and a dad, or that married parents can help reduce crime, but these are observations and arguments up for debate, not innate qualities like race or gender.

Ms. Kersten needs religion to square this circle and she knows that she doesn't need to explicitly write it down in her column for people to understand what she is talking about. (This, it could be argued, is the most justifiable faith present in this entire debate.)

I have a theory about why conservative Christians are more likely than their more liberal countrymen to fear what is commonly called "Islamofacism". By explaining it I will also explain what is wrong with Ms. Kersten's column. (Hint: It has to do with the seriousness they place in their own holy book and their current lofty social status here in America.)

The reason why Ms. Kersten is opposed to homosexual marriage is because her holy book tells her that being gay is wrong. Her opposition to homosexuality is part of her faith. I don't care whether or not you agree with this statement on the grounds that the Bible doesn't really say that homosexuality is bad; the fact remains that the Bible is widely interpreted as being hostile to homosexuality and its adherents act accordingly in honest fidelity to their God. To assume that they would do otherwise for the enjoyment of non-believers is absurd.

The question now becomes: Where do religious adherents go with their beliefs? How do you act upon the declaration that homosexuality is a sin?

The underlying assumption in Ms. Kersten's column is that her truthful belief in the sin of homosexuality is part of her religious faith; and that this faith is protected by the first amendment; and her identity is incomplete without her Christianity, so therefore any shot across the bow of this belief can be interpreted as anti-Christian bigotry or anti-Christian racism. This is a horrible notion that must not be allowed to continue, if only for the simple fact that Christianity is not the only faith with a shovel that can dig deep in this hole.

What are you going to do about the problem of belief and action? To the majority of religiously illiterate Americans, it doesn't seem quite so bad when we're talking about gay marriage, but what about a bunch of jokers jumping around with Molotov Cocktails and machetes because someone had the nerve to draw up some cartoons about an illiterate businessman who was visited by three angels in the desert? At what set of ideas is this ignorance and bigotry pointed? By what set of principles can a reasonable person come to these sorts of conclusions?

The most important thing that can be said about my comparison of Islam and Christianity is that there is no slippery slope between the two. Action upon faith is an equal opportunity proposition whose factions are segregated not by any qualitative difference in method, but only by the grotesque boundaries set by this, that, or the other True Lord. (That and the secular thought that "moderates" them wherever they happen to catch hold.) According to the teachings of the illiterate businessman mentioned above, the fact that I do not believe he heard what he says he heard, and that there is an equal amount of proof for the belief that he is capable of receiving divine revelation as there is for my pet fish, means that I can (and should) be treated like an animal. Am I bigoted for being truthful? Am I bigoted for being unable to believe? Am I bigoted for not wanting to be an infidel? Am I bigoted for saying that those who violently act upon this very clear religious directive are insane? I don't accept Mohammed as a prophet. I'm not bigoted for doing so. Even more importantly, I can back up my case without an appeal to the unknown.

I guess it's all about whose ox is being gored.

I think Ms. Kersten knows that she can't explicitly bring religion into the debate because I think she is smart enough to follow this argument through. I think that one of the reasons why the hard religious right fears Islam is because, unlike Christianity, Islam's believers believe their holy book to be the inerrant word of God. Now that's some bigotry! Ms. Kersten's reasoning digs a big hole. There are other things out there that would be all too happy to continue her work at a much swifter pace and to a much deeper level.

Enjoy the dig.

Wednesday, September 12, 2007

Whoops

I don't think General Petraeus was supposed to say this:
So much for "conditions." Under questioning from Sen. Jack Reed (D-RI), Gen. Petraeus conceded that his timetable for ending the surge by July 2008 is due to the five extra active-duty Brigade Combat Teams coming to the end of their scheduled deployments and the lack of available units to keep U.S. troop strength at 162,000.
Why is this important?

The whole Petraeus kabuki show depends on President Bush making a recommendation for a draw down of troops based on data presented by the general in his report. For all of his smarts, Petraeus screwed the pooch by pulling out the one card that was holding the whole deck up. How did he do this? By clearly stating that his recommendation for the draw down of troops has nothing to do with the conditions outlined in his very own data. I repeat: nothing.

BTW: The president still has to go on the TV tomorrow night saying otherwise.

The White House immediately jumped into action with this amazingly dishonest attempt at spin (because the president's entire speech/plan/etc depends on it):




I can't believe there are people out there who are still buying this.

Holy Balls, She Blogs Too

This is disturbing. Not only does she eat up valuable newsprint real estate, but it looks like Katherine Kersten slaughters ones and zeros in her spare time. I know, I know; I'm a little late to the game with her blogging. I just thought there would be no way the Strib would allow her to write more than she already does.

Her latest post is a doozy. I think it contains multiple layers of meaninglessness (if such a thing is possible.) Go read it and weep. The first comment says it all:

mark a says:

September 12th, 2007 at 8:15 am

What was the point of this post?

Answer: Just to rub it in. (Pause for effect.) Just to rub it in.

Day 2 of the Standoff

From the Catholic League (Day 1 here):
Responding to complaints from the Catholic League, the Academy of Television Arts & Sciences has decided to censor the vulgar remarks that comedian Kathy Griffin made when receiving her Creative Arts Emmy for her show, “My Life on the D-List.” Last Saturday, Griffin, upon winning the award for Outstanding Reality Program, blurted out a scripted remark, “Suck it, Jesus, this award is my God now.”

The Associated Press reports today that Griffin’s comment will be censored from the taped airing of the awards ceremony this Saturday on E! On Sunday, Fox will carry the live Primetime Emmy Awards show.

I pray to the god of YouTube that this clip be made available. Of course, the Catholic League leaves out the joke's set up:
“A lot of people come up here and thank Jesus for this. He had nothing to do with this,” Griffin said in her acceptance speech. “Suck it, Jesus. This award is my God now.”
Which is pretty damn funny.

On a personal note, I'd like to thank Jesus for this post. I couldn't have done it without you.

UPDATE: Here's Catholic League President Bill Donohue's last TV appearance:



Somehow, this chucklenut is able to scare the folks at the Emmy Awards into not airing Griffin's comments. More Catholic League whining here.

Tiger Woods Leads the Field by 52 1/2 Hippopotami

Tiger Woods currently leads Steve Stricker in the FedEx Cup by a little over 3,000 points. Tiger won the regular season FedEx point title over Vijay Singh by just over 11,000 points. Tiger could loose out on the $10 million grand prize if:
Stricker can win the FedEx Cup by winning at East Lake, which would be his second victory in these playoffs.

Mickelson could capture the cup if he wins the Tour Championship and Woods finishes lower than second alone.

Rory Sabbatini (No.4) and K.J. Choi (No. 5) have to win the Tour Championship and hope that Woods finishes out of the top 15
Is this making sense so far? There's more.

This weekend the PGA tour will head off to the Tour Championship in Atlanta. This tournament will consist of the top 30 players from the previous 3 playoff events. Like the past three tournaments, the Championship has 50,000 points on the line. Unlike the past three tournaments, the Championship awards 10,300 to the winner (as opposed to the previous prize of 9,000.)

In order to qualify for the four tournament playoff, each regular season PGA tour event was assigned 25,000 FedEx Cup points that were spread between places 1 and 70. At the end of the year, the leader (Mr. Woods) had his score reset to 100,000 and the last place player (some nobody who finished in 144th place) was reset to 84,700. (Note: not all players played in all 3 playoff events. Mr. Woods had enough points at the beginning of the playoffs to not compete in the 1st tournament. Mr. Michelson had enough points at the end of the 2nd tournament to not play in the 3rd.)

That's it. That's how the whole thing works. Did anything jump out at you? How about the fact that the entire point system is arbitrary? Tiger's 112,733 points are nearly meaningless and they sure don't neatly correspond to any recognizable performance indicator like greens in regulation, average score, average finish, and so on and so forth. Why 9,000 for a winner? Why not 5,000? How about 36? What about 3 nipples and a handshake?

Tiger pretty much lapped the field during golf's regular season. He earned a magical 30,574 points in 13 tournaments. Yes, this tells us he is good in relation to other players but it does so in a way that is not tied in any meaningful way to actual golfing reality. (Note: Tiger is so good that even when the numbers are cooked, there is no way for him to not come out on top.)

Mr. Singh, the lowly second place finisher, finished the year with 19,129 points. He achieved this score by participating in 23 tournaments. That's roughly 832 points per tournament for those of you playing at home. If you compare that to Mr. Woods' ridiculous 2352 points per tournament, you can begin to see how silly and meaningless this entire ranking system is. It becomes even more nonsensical as you make your way down the rankings.

In 3rd place with 16,691 points is Jim Furyk. His points per tournament average is 878. In 4th place with 16,037 points is Phil Michelson. His points per tournament average is 891. In 5th place with 15,485 points is KJ Choi. His points per tournament average is 737. This bassackwardness continues down the line; 10th place Adam Scott finished with 11,196 points but his average beat out 5th place Choi 746-737.

Again, this ridiculous point system has no basis in a reality-based description of performance. None. Which brings me to General Petraeus.

The General came prepared with a bunch of slides that he claims were vetted by two intel organizations. These slides show the flow of foreign fighters (none from Saudi?), weekly attacks in Iraq (taken at seemingly random intervals--ex. July 6th, 07 is followed by July 27th, 07--and does not correlate with numbers from previous years), civilian deaths (which are at odds with other studies), "ethno-sectarian" deaths (undefined methodology), caches found and cleared, and so on and so forth.

Getting around to the point, General Petraeus seems to be suffering from Fedexcupatitus: a condition marked by a distinct gap between the world people perceive and the numbers used to describe what they see.

Petraeus' numbers make absolutely zero sense set against a backdrop of unimaginable violence. "Ethno-sectarian" violence is down but the question of overall violence remains unanswered; Iraqi violence is reportedly down, but only measured in weeks picked seemingly at random and with no correlation to prior data; the surge is "capping" violence but we have no idea what will happen when the cap is removed; and so on and so forth.

Take a look at Petraeus' numbers. Forget about the fact that we don't know where he got his data from, where his data is, or the methodology used in its collection and interpretation; why does any of this indicate progress? Why these numbers? What do they have to do with achieving the political solution? The military solution? What is the greater context of these numbers? (Senator Hagel was the only Senator who came close to asking these questions.)

President Bush will speak to the nation Thursday night about the need to drawdown troops in Iraq. He will likely point to the data given in the Petraeus report. What does the data mean? Petraeus himself acknowledged that the drawdown depends on deployment length, not the data on the charts. We simply can't maintain current levels of deployment. For all practical purposes, President Bush will tell us that we need to drawdown troops in Iraq because the surge has worked and violence has dropped by 42.3 Hippopotami.

Tuesday, September 11, 2007

Will President Bush remember 9/11 by going over the best plans one more time?

From early 2002:
Committing our military into harm's way is my last choice. I say -- I talk about military options as the last option, not the first option, because I understand the consequences. But I want you to know that if we have to commit our military -- and we may not have to, but if we have to -- then we'll have the best plans. The full force and fury of the United States military will be unleashed. And make no mistake about it, we will prevail. (Applause.)