Sunday, October 14, 2007

Minnesotans Against (some) Terrorism

In an op ed in today's Star Tribune, Mark Rotenberg tells us the Important Lessons to be learned for l'affaire Tutu. Among them is this:

Another lesson is about jumping to conclusions without evidence. Tutu's canceled invitation received international notoriety because many thought it was part of a pattern of widespread Jewish pressure to censor Israel's critics.

But President Dease demolished that idea. "I was under no pressure from any pro-Israeli groups or individuals, nor did I receive any requests from them to refrain from inviting Archbishop Tutu to speak," he declared. That an esteemed Catholic university leader would feel compelled to make such a public denial is sad testimony to an upsurge of sinister theories about Jewish power in America today.

The truth is that university campuses are awash with anti-Israel sentiment. Harsh critics of Israel -- including diverse Israeli and American Jewish voices -- are commonplace in academic settings. Their books receive broad popular attention in the United States, and their perspectives dominate international forums. It takes no courage to be an Israel basher and no effort to find anti-Israel literature and speakers on college campuses, in the media and on the Web. Those who bewail secret Jewish influences in American politics are not describing reality, but are dabbling in a dangerous cesspool of prejudice.

Mark Rotenberg is, boys and girls, full of doo doo. The "secret Jewish influences?"  These influences are quite open. This is from an article on the Zionist Orgnization of America's website that Spot linked to earlier:

The decision of a number of American universities to invite Archbishop Desmond Tutu as a featured speaker is deeply troubling, in view of Tutu’s long record of statements comparing Israel to Nazi Germany and complaining about what he called “Jewish arrogance.”

. . .

Speaking in a Connecticut church, Tutu said that “the Jews thought they had a monopoly on God; Jesus was angry that they could shut out other human beings.” In the same speech, he compared the features of the ancient Holy Temple in Jerusalem to the features of the apartheid system in South Africa. (Hartford Courant, Oct. 29, 1984) Tutu has also asserted that “the Jewish people with their traditions, religion and long history of persecution sometimes appear to have caused a refugee problem among others.” (South African Zionist Record, July 26, 1985)

. . .

Tutu has also openly compared Israel to Hitler and apartheid: “I’ve been deeply distressed in my visit to the Holy Land; it reminded me so much of what happened to us black people in South Africa … I have seen the humiliation of the Palestinians at checkpoints and roadblocks, suffering like us when young white police officers prevented us from moving about … “I say why are our memories so short? Have our Jewish sisters and brothers forgotten their humiliation? Have they forgotten the collective punishment, the home demolitions, in their own history so soon? … The apartheid government was very powerful, but today it no longer exists. Hitler, Mussolini, Stalin, Pinochet, Milosevic, and Idi Amin were all powerful, but in the end they bit the dust. Injustice and oppression will never prevail.” (Ha’aretz, April 29, 2002)

It takes a lotta damn gall, make that chutzpa, Rotenberg, to claim, as you do, that criticism of Israel is "dabbling in a dangerous cesspool of prejudice." The rhetoric of Israeli apologists like Rotenberg becomes more shrill and clumsy as the case against Israel's treatment of the Palestinians builds and becomes more apparent to the American public. Israel is apparently desperate enough to enlist the help of the apocalyptic fools in the American evangelical community. [thanks to Eva Young for the link]

And what should you make of the claim that no one pressured St. Thomas to "uninvite" Desmond Tutu? How about this:

"We had heard some things he said that some people judged to be anti-Semitic and against Israeli policy," says Doug Hennes, St. Thomas's vice president for university and government relations. "We're not saying he's anti-Semitic. But he's compared the state of Israel to Hitler and our feeling was that making moral equivalencies like that are hurtful to some members of the Jewish community."

St. Thomas officials made this inference after Hennes talked to Julie Swiler, a spokeswoman for the Jewish Community Relations Council of Minnesota and the Dakotas.

"I told him that I'd run across some statements that were of concern to me," says Swiler. "In a 2002 speech in Boston, he made some comments that were especially hurtful."

During that speech, titled "Occupation Is Oppression," Tutu lambasted the Israeli government for its treatment of Palestinians in occupied territories. While a transcription clearly suggests his criticism was aimed at the Israeli government ("We don't criticize the Jewish people," he said during the speech. "We criticize, we will criticize when they need to be criticized, the government of Israel"), pro-Israeli organizations such as the Zionist Organization of America went on the offensive and protested campus appearances by Tutu, accusing him of anti-Semitism.

This is from the same speech quoted by the Zionist Organization of American and linked above.

The City Pages article continues:

Hennes says the input officials received from "the Jewish community" in this case was confined to Swiler and a few rabbis teaching within St. Thomas's Center for Jewish-Christian Learning. "I think there's a consensus in the Jewish community that his words were offensive," Swiler reiterates.

That was news to Marv Davidov, an adjunct professor within the Justice and Peace Studies program.

"As a Jew who experienced real anti-Semitism as a child, I'm deeply disturbed that a man like Tutu could be labeled anti-Semitic and silenced like this," he says. "I deeply resent the Israeli lobby trying to silence any criticism of its policy. It does a great disservice to Israel and to all Jews."

Marv Davidov is apparently one of those "self-hating Jews" you read about once in a while, boys and girls!

As a Minnesotan against terrorism, Mr. Rotenberg, let Spot ask you a question: how is Jewish terrorism against the British during its occupation of Palestine any different than Palestinian terrorism against Israel's occupation of Palestinian lands? You would perhaps find it useful to read a little on Immanuel Kant's categorical imperative.

Friday, October 12, 2007

Don't move, or the Iraqi gets it!

Spotty, you know that Katie had a new column yesterday entitled What happens when America leaves? Just ask S. Vietnamese.

Yeah, so?

You haven't written anything about it.

Hadn't planned to, grasshopper.

Aw, c'mon Spotty. There are some people who expect and want you to comment on Katie's column.

As the great philosopher king Mick Jagger said, grasshopper, you can't always get what you want.

He also said that sometimes you just get what you need. Maybe there are people who need you to comment on Katie.

Oh, all right.

Katie's column linked above contains what is known among lawyers as the "parade of horribles." She invites her readers to imagine the terrible things that will happen if we withdraw from Iraq, based upon Katie's doubtful understanding of what happened in Vietnam after the last helicopter departed the American Embassy compound in 1975. Her implicit argument is that if you counsel withdrawal from Iraq, you will have blood on your hands. Assisting Spot in preparing a response is Bjarne Pedersen of Shoreview who penned this letter in the Strib today:

In response to Katherine Kersten's Oct. 11 column "What happens when America leaves? Just ask S. Vietnamese": Yes, we did leave South Vietnam after 10 long years, and with 50,000 plus of our fine young men and women dead, and many more wounded.

That war too was a trumped-up war, as admitted by Secretary Robert McNamara years later. The Bay of Tonkin incident was staged and led to the expansion of American troops in the region. Our leaders during that conflict also failed us, and got us involved in a deadly conflict without cause.

The South Vietnamese government was corrupt and ineffective, yet we supported it like so many other dictators we have stood behind because of their perceived usefulness to U.S. foreign policy. As a matter of fact, Saddam Hussein was supported by the United States during its war with Iran in the 1980s, and he was hailed as our friend. Yet, he was no less a dictator and a threat to the United States then, than when we decided to blame him for weapons of mass destruction.

Kersten draws a parallel to the two wars, Vietnam and Iraq, and the possible consequences if we were to pull out of this current conflict in Iraq. Yes, there probably will be some consequences to our withdrawal from Iraq, and yes, we are to blame for much of what has happened in that country too. It is easy for conservative columnists to forget that we attacked Iraq without cause, and killed a whole bunch of people (estimates to date run as high as 100,000). This has probably irritated the victims who survived and their families, and we should expect them to have a little animosity toward us for bringing this upon their country.

So, when I read articles by columnists such as Kersten, I am left to wonder where their heads are [Spot has an idea where!]. Do we just dismiss the facts, and move forward? What is next, attack Iran, North Korea or any other perceived threat to our country? I'm left with the feeling they are clueless, or completely fail to see through the carnage and tragedy of this trumped-up war.

When the Germans left Russia and France during the Second World War, collaborators were dealt with harshly, too. Katie, it's one of the things that the administration should have taken into account before embarking on the entire foolish exercise. The blood won't be on the hands of those urging withdrawal: it will be on the hands of those responsible for starting the war in the first place, including everyone on the right wing cheer squad who agitated for it. Oh, weren't you in favor of starting the war, Katie?

The real solution is to permit those Iraqis who are in danger for collaboration to emigrate to the US, but the right wing doesn't like that solution, either. Just think of all the Iraqi restaurants it will spawn!

One of the things that Bjarne does in his letter is to low ball the Iraqi deaths caused by the invasion. By some estimates, many more have died as a consequence:

Three misattributed clusters were excluded from the final analysis; data from 1849 households that contained 12 801 individuals in 47 clusters was gathered. 1474 births and 629 deaths were reported during the observation period. Pre-invasion mortality rates were 5·5 per 1000 people per year (95% CI 4·3–7·1), compared with 13·3 per 1000 people per year (10·9–16·1) in the 40 months post-invasion. We estimate that as of July, 2006, there have been 654 965 (392 979–942 636) excess Iraqi deaths as a consequence of the war, which corresponds to 2·5% of the population in the study area. Of post-invasion deaths, 601 027 (426 369–793 663) were due to violence, the most common cause being gunfire. [italics are Spot's]

The 650,000 figures is as of July of last year, more than a year ago.

If it is Katie's point that we bear responsibility for the maelstrom we created, Spot agrees. But it is something else to argue that it will be worse if we leave. It's been plenty bad while we we're there.

How's that, grasshopper?

Thanks, Spotty.

That didn't take long

Al Gore wins Nobel Peace Prize.

---wait three minutes----

Right Wing smear machine engages.

Well, the Frost family might get some peace now.

Thursday, October 11, 2007

Hitler® belongs to us! II

In the original post, Spot referred to a Jewish author, Richard Ben Cramer, who wrote about Israel's spiritual sickness since it began the occupation of Palestinian lands in 1967. At the time, Spot also had another piece on the subject in mind, but couldn't find it. Here it is:

1967 - The war that ended Judiasm

Lord, save us from miracles.

Like compliments, we crave them, but when they do come our way, we don't always know how to respond. We are let out of Egypt with nothing less than a full parting of the Red Sea, and what thanks will God get? A rave in Sinai, to which He is uninvited, and blasphemy in the form of a golden calf.

Forty years ago this week, just when it seemed that it would take nothing short of a miracle for Israel to survive the coming war, the betting here was that the miracle bank had run dry. Amid the pre-emptive grave-digging and the fraught goodbyes, this was a constricted, panic-choked, border-phobic gas chamber of a country - literally, the ghetto to end all ghettos.

When the miracle came, few stopped to recall the real motto of this nation: Be careful what you pray for.

From this distance, one could conclude that while the Jewish state survived the war, Judaism as we knew it - Orthodox Judaism in particular - did not. Rabbinic Orthodoxy, the Jewish people's sworn bulwark against change, would never be the same.

1967 was the war that would persuade rabbis that they could be generals - even, or especially, if they lived in Brooklyn. The taste of power being what it is, many rabbis would soon conclude that government - and occupation - were much too important to be left to elected officials.

If absolute occupation corrupts absolutely, no group would be more corrupted by Israel's presence in the territories than rightist rabbis.

The author of those words, Bradley Burston, writing on the 40th anniversary of the 1967 war in Haaretz.com continues:

With Messianic zeal, they [the right wing rabbis] set to dictating new commandments and enunciating new prohibitions, revolutionizing Judaism by casting the settlements as the building blocks of a Third Temple - all the while turning the settlement enterprise and territories as a whole into a new Golden Calf, a god to which the people as a whole would be forced to sacrifice.

The change had been immediate, and shocking. The Temple Mount had only been in Israeli hands for a few hours before then-IDF chief rabbi Shlomo Goren pleaded with the general who had captured Jerusalem's Old City, to order that the magnificent gold-domed Mosque of Omar be blown to bits.

"I was alone for a moment, lost in thought, when Rabbi Goren approached me," Uzi Narkiss told Haaretz in an interview a few months before his death in 1997. "'Uzi,' Rabbi Goren said to me. 'Now is the time to put 100 kilograms of explosives into the Mosque of Omar so that we may rid ourselves of it once and for all.'

"I said to him, 'Rabbi, enough.'"

But Goren persisted. "'You don't grasp what tremendous significance this would have. This is an opportunity that can be taken advantage of now, at this moment. Tomorrow it will be too late.'

"I said, 'Rabbi, if you don't stop, I'll take you to jail.'"

Goren wasn't through. After the smoke had cleared, he addressed a military convention, calling it a "tragedy" that Israel had left the Temple Mount in control of Muslims: "I told this to the defense minister [Moshe Dayan] and he said, 'I understand what you are saying, but do you really think we should have blown up the mosque?' and I said, 'Certainly we should have blown it up.'"

The United States is the enabler of the rapacious elements of Israeli society. Organizations like the Zionist Organization of American and guys like Doug Tice want to keep it that way. But if we listen to them, and fail to insure that the Palestinians get their own place in the sun, there will never be peace in the Middle East. Unless all of the Palestinians are killed or die off.

Spot has a couple of more links for you on this subject. First is Norwegianity; Mark provides a little history of the relationship between the state of Israel and the apartheid government in South Africa. The second is Rob Levine's Rootless at the University of St. Thomas:

I say "rootless" because Dease doesn't have a clue about real morality and is a terrible decision maker. You might remember that St Thomas in the past has allowed right wing bigots to speak with almost no problem - Ann Coulter and Michelle Malkin (who defends the Internment of Japanese Americans during World War II) are two of the biggest offenders. When they were warned before Coulter spoke they shrugged it off, only to have have to eat crow afterwards. Then when Tutu was invited to speak, they apparently - in contrast to when right wing bigots speak there - were inclined to ask people in the community about him, never mind that Tutu is a Nobel Peace Prize winner and an internationally adored figure. How could anyone even think of dis-inviting Tutu?

It will take St. Thomas a long time to live this episode down. As Spot said earlier, he hopes that Archbishop Tutu sends his regrets to the new invitation that St. Thomas has apparently offered.

Wednesday, October 10, 2007

Hitler® belongs to us!

Adolph Hitler® is the registered trademark of the Jewish people, and as such, any reference to Adolph Hitler® may only be made in connection with the the genocide practiced against the Jewish people in the Second World War.

It kind of feels that way sometimes, doesn't it, boys and girls? Never mind that the Third Reich also invaded Czechoslovakia, Poland, France, Belgium, The Netherlands, Luxembourg, North Africa, Russia, the Ukraine and other Baltic States (and later in the war invaded Italy), bombed Britain mercilessly and annexed Austria. Never fear, my Jewish friends, there are plenty of WWII death and atrocities to go around!

But you see, boys and girls, Adolph Hitler® is Israel's non-expiring Get Out of Jail Free card. You can hardly blame it for not wanting to dilute the brand. But it is tiresome to Spot to have guys like Doug Tice wade in with pseudo-intellectual crap like this:

It’s time for another tiring episode of “Don’t Call Me Hitler!”

Because, if you hadn’t noticed, the dispute at St. Thomas over whether Desmond Tutu should be invited to speak on campus is, in significant part, a Hitler analogy controversy.

Some while back, we had an extended Big Question discussion about Hitler analogies and I proposed a rule for such rhetorical atrocities that in general seemed well received by readers here. Let’s put it to work:

St. Thomas has decided against a Tutu appearance because of objections from some leaders in the Jewish community, and it seems his offensiveness to them centers on a 2002 speech decrying Israeli “oppression” of Palestinians in occupied territories. Here’s a text available online….and here’s a transcript posted on startribune.com. The differences are minor.

The speech is not vitriolic, but there’s plenty in it for a defender of Israel to dislike — and for a critic of Israel to applaud. It appears this passage is the stinger:

“People are scared in this country [the U.S.] to say wrong is wrong. (applause) Because the Jewish lobby is powerful – very powerful. Ha, Ha, Ha ha! So what? So what! This is God’s world! For goodness sake this is God’s world!

“The Apartheid government was very powerful, but we said to them: Watch it! If you flout the laws of this universe, you’re going to bite the dust! (applause)

“Hitler was powerful. Mussolini was powerful. Stalin was powerful. Idi Amin was powerful. Pinochet was powerful. The Apartheid government were powerful. Milosevic was powerful. But, this is God’s world. A lie, injustice, oppression, those will never prevail in the world of this God….”

Tutu was surely guilty of piling on, if nothing else. Hitler and Stalin are bad enough — way bad enough. But dragging in third rate tyrants and war criminals like Milosevic and Mussolini is insulting on a whole different level.

At all events, the Nazi analogy rule applies. Someone might argue, as they commonly do in these cases, that Tutu was likening the Jewish lobby and/or Israel to Hitler (and company) only in a limited sense — not in terms of genocidal mania, but only as powers that ultimately proved resistible.

As the self-anointed policeman of the use of Adolph Hitler® analogies, Tice goes on to apply his own little rule about when they are appropriate. You won't be surprised, boys and girls, to find that Tice intimates that the analogy is inappropriately used to describe the Israeli treatment of the Palestinians. Shame on you Desmond Tutu!

Spot has some news for you Doug Tice, you unctuous twit: you have no standing to criticize Desmond Tutu on matters of his perspectives on oppression. It is a regrettable fact that by the birth of Israel—and especially after the '67 war—the oppressed have become the oppressors. Spot has not the time nor the inclination to provide the specification of the indictment here, save to mention the hundreds and hundreds of instances of collective punishment (illegal under international law) visited on the Palestinian people—and which are admitted to by the Israelis. It is not far-fetched to say that Israel is pursuing a policy of extinguishing the Palestinian people.

Read this from a 2004 Gary Kamiya review of a book by Richard Ben Cramer:

Richard Ben Cramer is not afraid of sacred cows. He bulldozed one of America's icons, Joe DiMaggio, in a bestselling
biography, and peeped into the stinky hopper in which the sausage of democracy is ground in his classic study of the 1988 presidential
campaign, "What It Takes." With "How Israel Lost: The Four Questions," Cramer, who won a Pulitzer Prize for Middle East reporting in
1979, has taken on perhaps the most explosive, emotion-laden subject in America: Israel

"How Israel Lost" is a mournful, passionate, hilarious lament for the endangered soul of a nation he loves. In a style that slips from the
wisecracking cadences of a Miami Beach hondler to the dispassionate observations of a veteran journalist to the moral outrage of a
world-weary humanist, Cramer argues that in the 20-plus years since he originally lived there, the Jewish state has suffered a cataclysmic
sea-change, a blow to its spirit all the more tragic for being self-inflicted.

The cause of Israel's malaise, Cramer writes, is very simple: Its 37-year occupation of Palestinian land. The occupation, Cramer argues, is
a gross and continuing injustice that has coarsened Israel's moral fiber, corrupted her politics and economy, and split Israeli Jews into
bitterly opposed, self-interested tribes who have lost all sense of allegiance to anything beyond their own needs. The occupation has also
had a deadly effect on Palestinians, stomping out the last embers of hope and creating a generation of sad, hardened children who know
Israelis only as soldiers with guns.

So get off your high horse, Mr. Tice, before you make an even bigger fool out of yourself.

N.B. Spot hears from source that St. Thomas is going to reverse itself on the Tutu visit. If Spot was Tutu—which he obviously is not—he definitely would not set foot on the St. Thomas campus. But, Desmond Tutu is a lot bigger dog than Spot.

[update]

The smear of Archbishop Tutu apparently began on the website of the Zionist Organization of America, which bills itself as "the oldest and one of the largest pro-Israel/Zionist organizations in the United States." This organization published a screed about a speech of Tutu's in 2002:

Tutu has also openly compared Israel to Hitler and apartheid: “I’ve been deeply distressed in my visit to the Holy Land; it reminded me so much of what happened to us black people in South Africa … I have seen the humiliation of the Palestinians at checkpoints and roadblocks, suffering like us when young white police officers prevented us from moving about … “I say why are our memories so short? Have our Jewish sisters and brothers forgotten their humiliation? Have they forgotten the collective punishment, the home demolitions, in their own history so soon? … The apartheid government was very powerful, but today it no longer exists. Hitler, Mussolini, Stalin, Pinochet, Milosevic, and Idi Amin were all powerful, but in the end they bit the dust. Injustice and oppression will never prevail.” (Ha’aretz, April 29, 2002)

The quote is truthful. It isn't an open comparison of Israel and Hitler. ZOA and Tice are upset that Tutu infringed their Adolph Hitler® brand.

In his post, Doug Tice "challenged" Desmond Tutu to explain his remarks. What utter chutzpah! Spot is quite sure that Desmond Tutu knows an oppressive and apartheid government when he sees one. It is dissembling Israel apologists like Doug Tice who need the history lesson.

[/update]

[further update] Spot recommends this post and its comments at A Tiny Revolution. [/further update]

FLIP FLOPPER!

Word from Eric Black is that Jim Ramstad may unretire. It took Paul Wellstone twelve years to decide he wanted another term. It took Ramstad what, two weeks?

Remember DFLers, what is sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander.

Tuesday, October 09, 2007

An update from Janet!

Janet has updated the scolding post about layabout children that Spot mentioned here:

On Monday, The St. Paul Pioneer Press carried an article on the necessity of children doing chores around the home, not for money but responsibility and carrying their share of the load. The article includes suggestions and tips. It appears one of the major excuses for not requiring kids to do chores is that parents want to spend time with their kids without "nagging" them. We're not helping our kids be relieving them of all responsibility related to living spaces.

A major chore is picking up toys, games, etc. and no one wants to do it - maybe because there are so many of them. A simple solution here is to gather all the toys, games, etc. and give away at least 50% of them. Problem partially solved.

All right, buster! Pick up those toys or Teddy here buys the farm!

You didn't make you bed again! It goes on the auction block in the front yard right after school. And no, you may not bid on it. You have to watch, though.

Where's your hamster? I fed him to the cat. Changing the litter in the cage is a Saturday morning job, and you didn't get around to it until nearly one o'clock.

Sigh. Spot hopes that the scholarly Janet is not in the psychology department. Or a parent, for that matter.

Rape and pillage II

Alternate title: Barbarians at the Gate

In the original Rape and pillage post, Spot wrote a little about one block in Edina's efforts to keep the barbarians—speculative builders of neighborhood soul-killing monster houses—out. That post included a short video that the residents of the block recorded for presentation to the Edina City Council. Here is the video again:

After initial signals from the communications people at the city that the video could be presented, the council decided at the meeting not to show it. Here's the council deliberation:

Sorry; really sorry.

Nearly as interesting to Spot, however, was a discussion that took place later in the meeting. During a presentation by the "Massing Task Force," a truly Orwellian moniker for a group whose spokesman didn't seem to think that massing was really so bad, there was some discussion among the council members of just "letting the market solve the problem."

Spot is sad to have to inform the council that "the market" isn't going to solve the problem, unless you consider wholesale destruction of neighborhoods as a solution. It is sort of like putting foxes in the henhouse as a "market-based solution." It is a notion so naĂŻve that it scarcely warrants discussion, but the idea that the market place is a benevolent force that will always work for the public good has gotten traction in some circles.

Well, it doesn't. The market place is a good at allocating private goods, but not at promoting or preserving public ones. The private interest, the spec builder who comes in, buys a lot and "scrapes" it to build a house that rips a hole in the neighborhood, must be compared the the public interest, the immediate neighbors interest in light and air, and the neighborhood's interest in preserving the aesthetic character of the neighborhood. The market place will never vindicate the public interest here. Never.

That's why we have zoning laws. Zoning laws exist to vindicate the public interest. And the people on that block in Edina selected council members and a mayor to enact ordinances appropriate to their protection. These are the people, many of whom have been around a long time, who vote, pay taxes, and raise families in the community, not the fly in and fly out builder.

Here's what the city has done so far:

•Edina, Minn., a Minneapolis suburb filled with rambler-style homes from the 1940s and '50s, changed its zoning in June after a spate of teardowns in the past three years. The city requires larger setbacks on narrow lots to limit the size of new homes, says Cary Teague, planning director.

"We were seeing a lot of builders tearing homes down and bringing in fill to build up the house for a walkout basement," he says. "Now, it can't be raised more than 1 foot from the existing foundation."

Homes as small as 1,200 square feet are being replaced with homes of up to 6,000 square feet. One just sold for $1.8 million, Teague says [with evident pride, says Spot].

Teague, a past president of the National Procrastinators Club (okay, Spot made that up), points with pride to the fact that setback on sidelots have been increased. Apparently so much that only a 5,500 square foot house can be built next door to Sandy Carlson! This is progress!

From the same USA Today article, here is what Atlanta is doing:

The Atlanta City Council approved a zoning ordinance last week that bans the construction of giant homes on small lots. In a compromise to appease builders, real estate agents, residents and planners, the city links the size of a home to the size of the lot. That allows big homes on big lots and small homes on small lots.

This is known, boys and girls, as a FAR, or floor area ratio limitation. Minneapolis has one now. But the big thinkers in Edina have apparently considered but rejected the idea. A FAR is the foundation of any meaningful anti-McMansion initiative. Apparently, the City of Edina isn't really serious about the problem.

Monday, October 08, 2007

Checking out the Borg

On the internets, boys and girls, there are just a few political or public policy sites, especially the blogs, that don't just rely on the printed word or the occasional tip.

That's what you do, mostly, isn't it Spotty?

Well, yes, grasshopper, but this post is not about Spot. Now, go sit in the corner, you impertinent little pup. Where were we? Oh, yes.

There are sites that do original and investigative research. One of Spot's favorites has long been Media Transparency, from our fair city, that does great work on conservative philanthropy and its effect on the media, education, and even liberal religious institutions. There are several good contributors to Media Transparency; Bill Berkowitz, who some of you may know from other venues, is an especial standout.

One of the writers, Rob Levine, who lists himself last on the roster, is actually the motive force behind Media Transparency and its sibling site, Cursor.org; the latter being a news aggregator that has been around about as long as anyone in the aggregator biz.

Is this going anywhere, Spotty?

Yes, grasshopper, it is. Rob Levine has a blog that he calls The Triumph of Conservative Philanthropy. Rob has a new post up about the integration of conservative philanthropy and the media right here in River City. Rob is a pretty good dot connecter himself:

As I have argued in numerous venues, the CAE is a "think tank" in name only; it is really an extension of the Republican party, and a cog in the larger conservative movement. The fact that a good friend of theirs is the political editor at the Trib, and one of its founders is a news columnist are indicators of a strong influence on the definition of news in the Twin Cities. Kersten herself often works in tandem with Powerlineblog; frequently you'll see a particular topic covered by Johnson or Hinderaker, only to have the story appear in Kersten's column shortly thereafter. It works the other way, too. In another post just above the one referenced in this post Johnson links to three recent Kersten columns warning of the anarchy awaiting the country for tolerating Critical Mass bike rides.

Power Line wrote about the bicyclists, too? Boy, Scott Johnson is One of Three and Katie is Zero of One from the Borg, aren't they Spotty?

You watch too much television grasshopper.

Sunday, October 07, 2007

Cyclophobia!

Katie may be more afraid of bicyclists than Muslims. Hard to believe, boys and girls, especially since the majority of bicyclists, at least in the Twin Cities, aren't brown. Katie's latest column is the second one on in a row about the pitiless abuse of minivans and SUVs and their suburban occupants by a mob—a mob, Katie swears—of bicyclists!

Critical Mass, the loosely organized bicycle group that ties up rush-hour traffic once a month in Minneapolis, has demonstrated who rules our streets. But Minneapolis isn't the only place where the Mass mob has strong-armed the police and City Hall, and left outraged motorists fuming but impotent.

Today, Critical Mass cyclists cow commuters in more than 300 cities, from Denver to Rio de Janeiro, according to the San Francisco Chronicle.

The ride got its start in San Francisco (where else?) in 1992 with about 50 cyclists. Authorities there looked the other way as riders ran red lights and snarled traffic. Soon, the event was drawing hundreds, even thousands, of riders.

And therein lies a cautionary tale for Minneapolis.

We know, of course, that anything that started in San Francisco can't possibly be good.

Katie has dropped a couple of broad hints about what she thinks that the Minneapolis police should do:

Today, ugly confrontations are a fact of life in the City by the Bay, and traffic is a bad trip on the last Friday of the month. Cyclists sometimes scratch or beat on cars, taunt or spit at motorists, and come close to running down pedestrians.

[ . . . ]

How did San Francisco get into this state of anarchy?

The city ran up the white flag 10 years ago, after a pitched battle in July 1997 set a pattern of capitulation.

Katie, of course, is made of sterner stuff. She would not hesitate to crack some heads in the name of a quicker commute! Spot thinks that Katie's real problem is that she is afraid that the local constabulary isn't going to be sufficiently tyrannical during the Republican National Convention next summer, perhaps inconveniencing some of her buds.

Meanwhile, Avidor sent Spot a great parody of Katie's last column on the bicycling mobsters.

Tom Maertens is angry

At the Democrats. And who could blame him? Please read A Party of Eunuchs.

Technorati Tags: ,

Please sir, can I have some more?

Spot is a latecomer to SCSU Scholars, especially the offerings of the Iron Maiden, Janet. It's been Spot's loss. Today, Janet lamented about this:

Spoiled Kids

On a recent bike ride through our neighborhood I saw examples like the following. Mom works outside the home, as does Dad. They have two boys, about ages 10 and 12. Guess who does the yard work?

Dad mows the grass; mom sweeps if off the road and walkways. Apparently the kids were told to walk the dog so they got on their bikes, put the dog on a leash and "walked" it for maybe five minutes. Both kids returned home and are now in the house. Meanwhile, Mom and Dad are finishing the lawn activities.

Want to guess when these two boys will become responsible?

Janet's right. By the time kids are ten, they really should be yoked to a plow. If they aren't put in the harness by then, they might not grow up to be the same joyless plodder you are, Janet. That would be tragic.

Spot has a piece of advice for you Janet: mind your own damn business. You are the kind of person that helped define the term "common scold."

Friday, October 05, 2007

We've grown accustomed

From an excellent post at Inside Minnesota Politics about Michael Brodkorb's tactics:

We've grown accustomed to the lies and distortions coming out of Brodkorb's media enticing rumor mill. Thank goodness the media has learned its lessons and doesn't take what he says as gospel. Star Tribune reporter Mark Brunswick was smart enough to check out this latest distortion with Sarvi's campaign first and left Brodkorb's smear out of his printed story. Brunswick knows what a lot of other media folks now know, Brodkorb's intent is to misinform for political gain.

It made Spotty think of this: 

The right wing, on maneuvers

Recognize any of these guys?

 
Rifle Rebound - The best free videos are right here

And in 2007, the chances are even better!

John Kenneth Galbraith wrote this many years ago:

A speculative outbreak has a greater or less immunizing effect. The ensuing collapse automatically destroys the very mood speculation requires. It follows that an outbreak of speculation provides a reasonable assurance that another outbreak will not immediately occur. With time and the dimming of memory, the immunity wears off. A recurrence becomes possible. Nothing would have induced Americans to launch a speculative adventure in the stock market in 1935. By 1955 the chances are very much better.

As Spot writes this, the DOW is at about 14,100, up over 100 points for the day. Spot wonders what part of "speculative bubble" that the public doesn't understand. One might think that the recent experience of the real estate market would be a cautionary tale, but apparently it isn't, at least for many. Including the Fed. Here's the text of of a September 18th press release:

The Federal Open Market Committee decided today to lower its target for the federal funds rate 50 basis points to 4-3/4 percent.

Economic growth was moderate during the first half of the year, but the tightening of credit conditions has the potential to intensify the housing correction and to restrain economic growth more generally.  Today’s action is intended to help forestall some of the adverse effects on the broader economy that might otherwise arise from the disruptions in financial markets and to promote moderate growth over time.

[It looks like the stock market is beginning to tank because of tightening credit, which is obviously provoking margin calls. We want to help investors live in a fantasy world a little longer.]

Readings on core inflation have improved modestly this year.  However, the Committee judges that some inflation risks remain, and it will continue to monitor inflation developments carefully.

[Inflation really isn't so bad, especially if it helps Wall Street continue to fleece investors.]

Developments in financial markets since the Committee’s last regular meeting have increased the uncertainty surrounding the economic outlook.  The Committee will continue to assess the effects of these and other developments on economic prospects and will act as needed to foster price stability and sustainable economic growth.

[Things look kinda bad. This subprime mortgage business has got a lot of people spooked, including a lot of foreign investors. But we'll throw gasoline on the fire as needed to keep it roaring. We'll ultimately run out of gasoline, but we'll worry about that when the time comes.]

Voting for the FOMC monetary policy action were: Ben S. Bernanke, Chairman; Timothy F. Geithner, Vice Chairman; Charles L. Evans; Thomas M. Hoenig; Donald L. Kohn; Randall S. Kroszner; Frederic S. Mishkin; William Poole; Eric Rosengren; and Kevin M. Warsh.  

In a related action, the Board of Governors unanimously approved a 50-basis-point decrease in the discount rate to 5-1/4 percent.  In taking this action, the Board approved the requests submitted by the Boards of Directors of the Federal Reserve Banks of Boston, New York, Cleveland, St. Louis, Minneapolis, Kansas City, and San Francisco.

Spot's comments are italicized in brackets.

Spotty, do you really think that the stock market is a speculative bubble?

Yes, Spot does. After all, a corporation's worth is really based on what it earns. Stock prices deal with expectations about earnings, but those expectations have gotten way out of whack. Consider a couple of graphs from Robert Shiller's Irrational Exuberance, published in 2000:

 

It kinda goes off the chart at the end there, doesn't it Spot?

Yes. These data only go through 2000, but the situation today is much the same as 2000.

What's going to happen, Spot?

That's the sixty-four dollar question, grasshopper. Here's what James Kunstler had to say recently:

     With gasoline prices still skulking in the neighborhood of $3-a-gallon, despite oil priced above $80-a-barrel, political and economic leaders can pretend a little while longer that things are okay on the real life American scene. But between the dollar tanking in response to the Federal Reserve's Easy-Money-for-Big-Players policy, and the start of the home-heating season, you can be sure we are headed up to the $4-a-gallon range for happy motoring fuel before New Years.

     There is still broad disagreement among commentators as to whether we are headed into a wild inflation or a grim deflation, but the emerging pattern looks to me like a big ocean wave that gathers itself into a high cresting peak and then collapses under its own weight -- that is, a technical wild inflation resolving into the low slop of people unable to buy anything. However you cut it, and from whatever angle you look at it, the bottom line will be a steeply lower standard of living for most Americans.

Bruce and Techno, Spot thinks this will also affect the militarism of the United States, but it could go either way.

Thursday, October 04, 2007

Katie, this is Janet

You all know Katie, boys and girls. You know Janet, too, if you have been reading SCSU Scholars or Spot's comments about Janet and the Gathering of Eagles.

Where to begin? Okay, we'll start with Katie's column on the bicycle mob. Katie is really cheesed because the cops don't wade in a break some heads during the monthly Critical Mass ride:

Now we know who's in charge of Minneapolis streets. It's a loosely organized group of serial lawbreakers called Critical Mass. Last Friday, 600 or so took over city thoroughfares, breaking traffic laws with impunity while police stayed in the background.

Every month, Critical Mass cyclists ride through rush hour traffic in cities across the country. Some insist the ride is just a "celebration." Others acknowledge a political agenda: they want to enlighten the rest of us -- greedy capitalists that we are -- about the joys of bike riding so we can join them in saving the planet.

We really do have trouble, right here in River City, boys and girls, because:

Are you rushing to catch the last few innings of your son's baseball game?

Trying to get to the show you promised your wife for her birthday?

Critical Mass doesn't give a rip. Tough luck for you, Mac, because you're a gas-guzzler and I'm living green.

Katie, Spot knows that bicyclists are such a pain whenever you're out in your Lincoln Navigator and talking on the cell phone, but did it ever occur to you that the people on bikes are just lobbying for their own little spot in the sun? Because most encounters between the gas guzzlers and bicyclists end up like this:

So, Katie, maybe the Critical Mass rallies will penetrate you consciousness and make you be a little better about sharing the road. Nah. Who is Spot kidding?

This is where Janet comes in Katie. Maybe she could get a contingent of the Gathering of Eagles to, er, police the next Critical Mass outing. These guys and gals like to break heads:

Want to know how an incredibly unpopular radical faction whose leader claims autocratic sway over a population that despises him plans to stay in power? By brute force, what else? Right now, they're employing brownshirt-style "private" thug bands to intimidate – and beat up – critics of the regime's criminal war. Soon – after some "security incident" or another, real or concocted – we will see military troops (and those contract militias, of course) on the street, taking over from the thugs.

You think "it won't happen here?" Wake up and smell the bilgewater, Sparky; it's already happening. As AfterDowningStreet reports, just three days after a gang from the militarist group "Gathering of Eagles" (better known as "Bootlickers of Power") physically attacked the father of an American soldier who was killed in Iraq, the Leader himself had the top henchmen of the group join him for breakfast on the White House lawn. As the picture shows, Bush went out of his way to give the touchy-feely treatment to Bootlicker Chris Hill, who took part in the vicious attack on Carlos Arredondo at an anti-war protest in Washington, D.C. last month.

It is hard to overstate the significance of this presidential embrace. Sure, one might argue that Bush himself had no idea what the Bootlickers were doing, in his name, at the protest. (Although when it comes to anything that augments his power, inflates his self-esteem and punishes his enemies, Bush usually displays an intimate, detailed grasp of the subject.) But it is certain that Bush's minions and handlers in the White House knew exactly what Hill and his fellow Bootlickers had done. Their "liberation" of a picture of Arredondo's dead son from his "peacenik" father was trumpeted loudly through the rightwing media; the Bootlickers were lauded as heroes for this bold action. And the White House knew exactly what it was signaling – and to whom – when it arranged this special honor and photo op for the Bootlickers: "Well done, thou good and faithful servants! Let's see more of this!"

Janet, of course, is down with the Gathering of Eagles:

Anarchist anti-war protestors spray-painted the steps of the US Capitol in January. Another anti-war protest being organized by a coaltion [sic] of radical leftist and anarchist groups is "gathering near the Vietnam Veterans Memorial" on March 17th.

Although the organizers deny any intention to "defile" the Memorial, I will be joining A Gathering of Eagles, which plans to be present to protect the Vietnam Veterans Memorial.

So you see, Katie, what you need to do is import some thugs. W would undoubtedly approve.

Wednesday, October 03, 2007

Rape and pillage

Some neighborhoods in Minneapolis and elsewhere—including Spot's hometown, Edina—have been ravaged by speculator-developers who come in, buy a city-sized lot, "scrape" it, and put a huge, awkward, McMansion in its place. These people have no concern for the nest they are fouling, because they won't live there—or next door. And much too often, city councils fiddle while the neighborhood burns.

Official inaction has fueled a lot of citizen anger. In Minneapolis, there was a campaign that resulted in some changes in the zoning ordinance to prevent the phenomenon called "massing." Richard Moe describes it in his op ed piece in the Strib this morning:

But while visitors [here for a convention on historic preservation] may not notice it, something else is happening here, and it's not good. Residents who care about this place have every right to pat themselves on the back for their preservation achievements in recent years -- but they must see that big, important chunks of their heritage are still in danger of being spoiled or lost altogether.

Take the riverfront, for example. The rediscovery and ongoing revitalization of this attractive and history-rich area is one of the best things that's happened in this city in my lifetime. But now there's a very real possibility that the rebirth of this long-ignored enclave could destroy the very qualities that make it appealing. Almost every week brings an announcement of a splashy new construction project, and too many of them are too big, threaten to block views of the river, consume precious open space, and otherwise overwhelm the scale and character of the area. The riverfront's popularity shouldn't be allowed to strangle it just as it's coming to life. It may be a truism, but it's worth remembering: You can't revitalize a neighborhood by destroying it.

That same statement has a special resonance in neighborhoods that are experiencing tear-downs. This practice of demolishing an existing house and replacing it with a bigger one is the most serious threat faced by older neighborhoods since the heyday of Urban Renewal, and it has hit the Twin Cities hard. Recent Star Tribune articles describe a "citizen revolt" in embattled neighborhoods in southwest Minneapolis, Edina and Minnetonka -- and no wonder: Mini-mansions get awkwardly shoehorned into established communities where they just don't fit. As bulky new structures get built right up to the property lines, trees disappear and yards shrink, and neighbors find their sunlight and views blocked. Economic and social diversity are reduced as rising property taxes drive out moderate-income or fixed-income residents and affordable "starter homes" disappear. Historic character gets smashed to rubble and hauled off to the landfill. [italics are Spot's]

Smashed to rubble and hauled off to the landfill. That's a pretty accurate description of what is happening. Now, Spot has heard about a neighborhood in Edina that is rising in anger over another rending of the community's fabric. They've produced a really good video that the city council apparently refused to watch last night:

 

Spot says make some noise about this boys and girls, before it happens on a lot near you.

[update] Spot should probably mention that Richard Moe is also the author of The Last Full Measure, an account of the heroic First Minnesota Regiment during the Civil War. [/update]

Huffing and puffing

Do you remember, boys and girls, when Professor Banaian got all testy about someone (well, it was Charlie at Across the Great Divide) questioning whether ISPs should be permitted to censor messages? The King drew himself up and thundered "They are private businesses!" Spot commented on Charlie and the King's discussion in ISPs as utilities. The issue of censorship of messages on what amount to common carriers is a very real one. Here's another example:

On the face of it, last week’s brouhaha over Verizon’s censorship of NARAL appears to be the result of a simple corporate bungle, an “isolated incident” caused by a misinterpretation of “a dusty internal policy,” as corporate spokespeople put it. But behind this corporate snafu is an unhappy marriage of two much larger issues.

Thousands grew outraged last week when Verizon threatened to censor their private communications. Expert Lea Shaver of Yale Law School’s Information Society Project reports that advocates of legislation designed to prevent censorship on the net have been concerned about the censorship potential of Verizon’s internal policies for some time but were dismissed as paranoid. Verizon is also a principal sponsor of the key corporate interest group opposing such legislation.

The King is so busy worshipping at the altar of his tin god "the market" that he is blissfully unaware of the erosion of his political freedoms, including especially freedom of speech. Pity.

Related is the whole issue of 'net neutrality:

Common Cause firmly believes in net neutrality -- the  principle that Internet users should be able to access any web content they want, post their own content, and use any applications they choose, without restrictions or limitations imposed by their Internet service providers (ISPs).

Net neutrality is the reason this democratic medium has grown exponentially, fueled innovation and altered how we communicate.  We must make certain that for-profit interests do not destroy the democratic culture of the web.

When a private company can acquire right of way, a license to use public airwaves or bandwidth, or some other right granted by the government, it is not merely a "private business" any longer. It has public responsibilities for the authority granted to it. This is a proposition so simple that only an economics professor doesn't seem to understand it.

Tuesday, October 02, 2007

The King is cranky!

King Banaian missed his bagel klatch this morning, and he's clearly miffed. He drove his eighth-grade daughter to school, and then he had to drive back home for something she forgot:

This morning Littlest Scholar heads out the door to the car, checks the back seat to see that her football is in tow, and upon arriving to school tells me her diorama she had made last night had been forgotten at home. It must be brought now. Because of road and bridge construction, it takes me forty minutes to go home, retrieve the diorama and bring it to school.

This caused me to miss my normal bagel-and-coffee with friends. Should I charge her for this?

Of course you should, King! Children should be raised in as close to Skinner box conditions as possible. Spot is sure you have a pretty comprehensive scheme of carrots and sticks for raising your daughter anyway, King; Spot is surprised that you have to ask the question. It is apparent, however, that the professor's pique was compounded later in the morning when he got this message from his daughter's teacher:

Would you please be able to get (her) to school a few minutes earlier in the morning? We start our day at 7:40, and that has been when she has walked in the door the last few days. Maybe about 7:35 or so. Thanks very much.

What cheek! Imagine, a mere teacher asking his majesty the King to bring his daughter to school on time. Obviously, this was an affront to economics professors everywhere. So the King did what an economics professor would do: turn the fact that he can't get his arse out of the rack in order to get his daughter to school on time into a economics problem:

I'm a bit tempted to be flip with the teacher (who, btw, sent this at 7:45, so whatever was being done right at 7:40 didn't require his [Katie look: a male teacher] full attention.) After all, the bridge construction has changed traffic flows three times in the last four weeks, and predicting the time to leave the house to have her arrive at 7:35 is an estimate with much greater uncertainty now than in time passed [sic]. So I decided to reflect a little economics on the problem.

The teacher is undoubtedly lucky that Banaian managed to tamp it down! What follows is Banaian's description of the incentives that bear on his getting his daughter to school early (apparently bad, if too early), late (also bad, which seems to mystify, or at least disquiet, the King), or just right: a few minutes before the opening bell. One of the disincentives to be timely is this:

Indeed, since the school sends me a note equally for bring the child early or late, the credit I get for a 7:25 arrival is zero. Maybe something closer to 7:32 might bring a smile, hardly enough payment for forgoing that last article in the sports pages with my breakfast.

It's a mind bender to the King that the teacher would be so tedious about wanting students to be punctual.

Professor, if you're having breakfast, you don't need that bagel a little later, anyway.

Boys and girls, the professor has given us a splendid example of the difference between a responsible adult and one who has to be bribed to do anything.

Monday, October 01, 2007

Holding self esteem in low esteem

Anyone with a passing acquaintance with Katie's scribblings—and that's all Spot can recommend: a passing acquaintance; Spot's talking to you, Gump—knows that Katie is capable of writing a column without the smallest cognition that what she is writing is contradictory to what she wrote before. It is a charming quality that infuses Katie's writing in a memorable way. We have a nice example of the genre in Katie's column today: Shortage of male teachers shows need for truly wise guys.

Katie's lament de jour is the dwindling number of male teachers in elementary school. Why, they even have trouble finding men to teach at one of Katie's pet charter schools:

Finding male teachers is a challenge even at Boys Academy, a special program of Harvest Preparatory School, a K-6 charter school in Minneapolis. Boys Academy's student body is 100 percent African-American and about 80 percent from low-income families. Its faculty is 40 percent male, and all female teachers have a male classroom aide. But Eric Mahmoud, the school's president, says it's very difficult to find men to apply to teach kindergarten or first grade.

Why the school's Muslim president would talk to the anti-Muslim and xenophobic Katie, Spot has no idea. But never mind.

Katie goes on to say how difficult it can be to teach boys, the little barbarians:

Boys can be the bane of elementary teachers' existence. They are high-energy, impulsive and easily distracted, and have been ever since Cain clobbered Abel. Most would rather wrestle than trace letters at a desk.

Apparently, it's an original sin kind of a thing. Figures. Spot thinks that the boys were mean to Katie when she was in the third grade. What do you think, boys and girls?

Anyway, Katie does write with admiration about one male teacher at Harvest Prep, Erick Owens, who teaches third grade. And certainly based on Katie's description of Mr. Owens, he does sound like a very good teacher. Here's one of Katie's explanations:

Owens understands how to channel boys' energy because he was once a boy himself.

That's it! Why has no one ever thought of this before? Why, Spot remembers being eight or nine years old like it was yesterday! (It wasn't.)

Spot, we thought you said that Katie had written something contradictory. What is it?

Oh, thank you grasshopper. Here's the money quote. This is what Owens does sometimes:

He takes pains to keep the competition relatively equal. "If one team's behind, I give them a question that's worth more points so they feel good and keep trying."

Can you imagine that? He keeps the self esteem of his kids in mind? That's no way to raise social Darwinist hunter gatherers! Katie has put this self esteem nonsense in its proper perspective before; Spot has commented here and here (they are two posts that Spot really liked, by the way; he hopes that you'll check them out) about a couple of Katie columns on the subject where she wrote this:

Years ago, my daughter, then [in] second grade, jumped off the school bus one day with a badge pinned to her shirt. "[Blank] is special," it said, with her name filled in. But my daughter wasn't busting her buttons. "Mom," she told me, "if everyone is special, then no one is special."

Young as she was, my daughter grasped that there is something bogus about the self-esteem movement, which was then taking the education world by storm.

Katie, you must go back to Mr. Owens and explain to him that the only way to encourage children is to punish them when they don't do well.