Tuesday, August 17, 2010

Chihuahuas with Flipcams

The Republican employment program known as Chihuahuas with Flipcams has reached pestilential levels. Candidate Mark Dayton complained about it. Here’s just a little bit of what he said:

"When you interfere with the ability of Minnesotans to walk up to another candidate and have a civil conversation, you have gone too far," Dayton wrote in a letter to state GOP chairman Tony Sutton. "It is intentional harassment, disruption of our campaign activity and intimidation of Minnesota voters." [italics are mine]

According to the Strib article, it was trackers at the recent Game Fair that prompted Dayton’s complaint.

As Dayton points out, and as at least one commenter in the Strib comments affirms, it’s the voter intimidation that’s the real problem. Many people simply don’t want to be captured on video and have it appear on the web. It is harassment to keep these people from talking to a candidate.

When he came to DL, Mark Dayton introduced the Republican tracker by name from the stage. The recording of remarks is not the problem here; it’s the intimidation of ordinary citizens.

Monday, August 16, 2010

And u 2 R morons

Two twits in the Hot Dish Politics twitter feed:

u 2 are morons

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

A bold face liar would be someone who said something like Luke Hellier is brilliant!

A bald-faced lie, on the other hand, might be told by someone who looks like this.

BTW, 4 u @ hme, I knw dif twit/tweet.

A definitional matter

Recently, I got a link to something written by Tom Toles, a great cartoonist and writer. But he wrote something about cucking stools, saying that “cucking stools” were not “ducking stools.” Believe it or not, I put some research into this issue before I started the blog, and I found several references explaining that they were different names for the same thing. Here’s one of the best:

def-of-cucking-stool

Cucking stools were also called the “stool of repentance” or an “engine of correction.” They were the punishment of choice for a “common scold,” or in Latin, the communis rixatrix.

They were primarily intended for the humiliation of the dunkee, but could be deadly in the hands of the wrong operator. You can tell from the Latin — well, maybe you can — that only women could be “common scolds.” Bakers or butchers who gave short weight were also sometimes subjected to a dunking. We try to observe some gender equality in selecting our objects for ridicule here at the Stool, as the banner suggests.

Barbour, Santorum & Perry

That’s the double-play team on the Republican party’s ball club in the instructional league. They’re the only ones that Governor Gutshot bested, however, in a recent poll in Iowa:

Pawlenty scored 1 percent in a poll of Republican presidential hopefuls released Monday by the Iowa Republican, putting him in a distant tie for sixth out of 10 candidates in the poll.

Former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee, who won the 2008 Iowa caucuses, led at 22 percent, followed by former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney at 18 percent, former House Speaker Newt Gingrich at 14 percent and former Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin at 11 percent. [Sarah Palin polls eleven times as well, proving once again why John McCain picked her as a running mate over Pawlenty.]

The one bit of good news for Pawlenty is that three potential candidates included — former Sen. Rick Santorum, Mississippi Gov. Hayley Barbour and Texas Gov. Rick Perry — failed to reach the 1 percent threshold.

Pawlenty has been the governor of the state closest to Iowa of any of the hopefuls — for eight years. Nobody south of, say, State Highway 9, seems to have heard of him.

Sunday, August 15, 2010

Emmer: We need more Excel Dairies


Tom Emmer wants to send a fruit basket to Rick Millner. He's the kind of job creator that Tom Emmer likes. His large dairy operation has been oppressed by busybody regulators who seem to care more about water and air quality than the jobs and economic growth he creates. He should be Emmer's poster child for the impact of overzealous regulation. After all, his dairy operation is the only one in recent memory to have its permit revoked by the job hating bureaucrats at the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency. But you won't hear his name invoked by Emmer, because Rick Millner was the CEO of Excel Dairy.

Excel was a 1,600 head dairy operation near Thief River Falls owned and operated by the Dairy Dozen, a South Dakota company. That picture at the top? That's one of the three manure lagoons at Excel. Almost from the moment it opened, the stench of manure overpowered neighbors, who complained to the MPCA. But it wasn't simply an odor problem. Excel's manure pits were emitting hydrogen sulfide gas, a neurotoxin that has killed hundreds of people. According to Excel's permit, emissions of hydrogen sulfide were limited to 30 parts per billion. Neighbors who did their own air quality tests found levels as high as 1000 parts per billion, so high that in Summer 2008 the Minnesota Department of Health told them to evacuate. They lived a nightmare existence of being forced out of their homes or choosing to live with air quality so bad that short-term health effects were happening and long-term health problems were possible according to state toxicologist Rita Messing. You didn't need to tell the neighbors that the health impacts were real. They'd been reporting nausea, headaches, shortness of breath and exhaustion for years. But why not listen to one of them describe their struggle?



The pattern of violations at Excel Dairy went back as far as 2005, when they exceeded the permitted size of their herd and used unapproved methods to treat manure. They ignored order after order from the MPCA. It took the MPCA years to finally get around to actually checking the air quality downwind of Excel. Why? They only have five air quality monitoring devices for 1,000 feedlots. When you hear Mark Dayton refer to the MPCA as the Minnesota Pollution Cooperation Agency, think of Excel as an example par excellence of how ineffective it's been under Tim Pawlenty. At least the MPCA finally did what needed to be done this Spring and refused to issue a new operating permit for Excel. It only took five years of repeated permit violations.

But according to Tom Emmer, the problem is over-regulation. The Emmer plan? "[M]ove the regulatory structure for agriculture out of the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency and back to the Department of Agriculture." Oh, and to review regulations to look for examples of where "Minnesota’s standards [are] higher than federal standards."

As ridiculously drawn out as MPCA's response was, it's likely that if the Department of Agriculture had been in charge, nothing would have been done. How much emphasis on agricultural air quality enforcement do you think there would be in an Emmer regime? Even if they wanted to enforce air quality, they wouldn't have the expertise.

According to the Citizens League, livestock agriculture is "minimally regulated" by the federal government. Minnesota has over 30,000 registered animal feedlots. Only 1,100 of these are subject to federal permits, and of those, only 40 have individual federal permits. The state, and by delegation, 55 counties, do the vast majority of monitoring to ensure that these feedlots don't pollute the water and air. And this is a crucial task, as the collective (ahem) output of these operations is the equivalent of the waste produced by 50 million people. Relying solely on the federal standards would mean that 29,000 or so feedlots would be unregulated.

Worse still for the neighbors of Excel Dairy, the MPCA's foot dragging was better than they could have expected from the federal government. While the Excel situation was dragging on, the EPA was busy exempting air pollution caused by manure from reporting requirements. In other words, the federal standards wouldn't have required Excel to even report that their 33 million gallon manure pits were exceeding their permitted air emissions.

But back to that fruit basket. Here's Emmer's conclusion:
Farmers are the state’s first and best environmentalists because they depend on the land for their livelihood – the farm is their 401K. It’s time we offer a fruit basket instead of a rule book to any business wanting to grow and expand.
The vast majority of farmers do their very best to protect the environment and public health. And while it can be onerous to comply with regulations, bad actors like Excel demonstrate the need for fair and vigorous enforcement when they are violated.

Reviewing regulations to see how they can be more clearly explained and evenly enforced? Everyone supports that. But when Tom Emmer says he'd throw away the rule book, remember the story of Excel Dairy, since there will be more stories like that if he wins.

Follow me on Twitter @aaronklemz


(Note: On longer form posts like this one, I'll be using my new Posterous blog to organize and present the citations. Want to see? Click here to go to the "Works Cited: Excel Dairy" page.)

(Image Credit: Minnesota Pollution Control Agency, via MPR)

If oranges are good, are apples bad?

Katie?

No, silly; the fact that one is good does not mean that the other is bad. That’s stupid thinking.

Good. Thank you. Next question. If traditional marriage is good, is gay marriage bad?

Why, of course it . . .   [long confused pause] Yes it is. It definitely is.

Here’s the opening grafs of Katherine Kersten’s column in the Strib this morning:

Did you know that Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton are bigots? Ditto for the justices of New York's, Maryland's and Washington's highest state courts. And there are at least 7 million bigots in California alone, along with legions more across the country.

Their strange and aberrant delusion? They believe -- or say it's reasonable to believe -- that traditional marriage is a social good that serves our nation well.

Katie just wants company paddling in the bigot’s broth. I am sure you will search in vain for one of the people on Katie’s list who want to replace or eliminate “traditional” marriage.

The rest of the column is just the usual gibberish about activist judges, etc. & etc. That Fourteenth Amendment is really turning out to be bummer for conservatives like Katie!

General Petraeus to David Gregory: We’re making progress!

That was the message on Meet the Press this morning. But Robert Greenwald reminds us otherwise.

We’ve been expecting Petraeus to hit the medicine show circuit:

Defense Secretary Robert M. Gates signaled the military’s position recently when he said that the initial troop withdrawals next summer “will be of fairly limited numbers.” General Petraeus, who has kept a low profile for the past six weeks while conducting a countrywide assessment, is expected to amplify the message during the media offensive he will begin on Sunday, when he is to appear on the NBC News program “Meet the Press.” He is expected to say that the last of the 30,000 additional troops Mr. Obama ordered to Afghanistan last December will not arrive until later this month, and that the counterinsurgency strategy has not been given enough time to succeed.

And the violence is getting worse, not better.

Update: General Petraeus says he doesn’t want to preside over a graceful exit. Be careful what you wish for, General.

Saturday, August 14, 2010

You can run, but you cannot hide!

I’m looking at you, Tom Emmer.

You cannot imagine, boys and girls, how long I’ve been waiting to throw that line back in Stonewall Emmer’s face. Emmer, along with Mark Dayton and Tom “Mama Bear” Horner, made an appearance on Almanac on Friday night. Stonewall was asked, point blank, Do you support a bill to amend the Minnesota Constitution to prohibit gay marriage?

And he dodged it, like the man he is.

His excuse was, Well, it’s not an issue for a Minnesota governor. We’ll get into that in a moment, but for right now, I want you to consider how candidate Emmer, who has been against gay rights for his entire legislative career, couldn’t own up to his record on the tee vee. Neither of the Almanac hosts were willing to follow up and say, Wait a minute, Tom, of course you support such an amendment; you authored one of the damn bills!

Here’s the bill in question, Stonewall, since you seem to have forgotten it:

1.6    Section 1. CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT PROPOSED.
1.7 An amendment to the Minnesota Constitution is proposed to the people. If the
1.8 amendment is adopted, a section shall be added to article XIII, to read:
1.9 Sec. 13.Only a union of one man and one woman shall be valid or recognized as a
1.10 marriage in Minnesota. Any other relationship shall not be recognized as a marriage or its
1.11 legal equivalent by the state or any of its political subdivisions.
1.12    Sec. 2. SUBMISSION TO VOTERS.
1.13 The proposed amendment must be submitted to the people at the 2008 general
1.14 election. The question submitted must be:
1.15 "Shall the Minnesota Constitution be amended to provide that the state and its
1.16 political subdivisions shall recognize marriage or its legal equivalent as limited to only the
1.17 union of one man and one woman?

Maybe Tom is just being forgetful, like proposing a  measure for Minnesota veterans that actually already became law over his objection a few years ago?

Maybe someone has been impersonating Tom Emmer in the House? Do you think?

I don’t think so either.

He states on his campaign web site that he opposes gay marriage.

He’s also been a fan and financial supporter of Bradlee Dean and the Junkyard Dog Band, or whatever it is they call themselves, a virulent anti-gay “ministry” (I almost gag when I write the word), whose slogan is You Can Run But You Cannot Hide. The sartorial disaster Emmer is pictured here with a couple of band members at the Republican State Convention:

Do you see the flames surrounding the slogan? Can’t you almost smell the roasting gays? Ummm. Roasting gays on an open fire! You know, that might just be on the new Bradlee Dean Christmas album.

But sad to say, Stonewall is right about one thing. If a bill to amend the Minnesota Constitution passes both houses of the Legislature, it goes on the ballot for a referendum whether the governor supports it or not. You might think about that when you’re thinking about getting off the couch and doing a lit drop for your local DFL legislator.

Thanks to Eva Young for the legislative information.

Site renovations are nearly complete

The biggest change is the adding of social networking buttons to the foot of each post. That required an updated template, and well, one thing led to another. Avidor’s cucking stool graphic will likely return in some fashion.

We’d appreciate your feedback and especially hearing about any problems you may encounter.

Update: Well, that’s it for now, folks. We hope you like it.

Friday, August 13, 2010

Officious intermeddlers extraordinaire


Now this is funny. After spending 138 pages telling the intervenors in Perry v. Schwarzenegger case over the constitutionality of California's Proposition 8 that it really is none of their damn business if gay people marry each other, Judge Walker drove the point home in his order that gave only a very short stay pending appeal.

Recall, if you will, that the State of California officials named in the suit didn't defend it. The defense was mounted by the intervenors, a group of "official" proponents of Proposition 8, who sought a decision that held that the State officials were bound to enforce the law and prohibit marriage between same-sex couples. These proponents have now sought a stay of the decision during the appeal process. Like they did in trial, it is expected that the State defendants will sit back and not participate in the efforts to uphold Proposition 8. This leaves only the intervenors as potential appellants.

But there's a problem with the appeal being prosecuted by the intervenors. Judge Walker openly questions whether they even have standing to appeal the decision:
Proponents argue that irreparable harm will result if a stay is not issued because “a state suffers irreparable injury whenever an enactment of its people * * * is enjoined.” ... Proponents, of course, are not the state. Proponents also point to harm resulting from “a cloud of uncertainty” surrounding the validity of marriages performed after judgment is entered but before proponents’ appeal is resolved. Doc #705 at 10. Proponents have not, however, alleged that any of them seek to wed a same-sex spouse. Proponents admit that the harms they identify would be inflicted on “affected couples and * * * the State.” Id. Under the second factor the court considers only whether the party seeking a stay faces harm, yet proponents do not identify a harm to them that would result from denial of their motion to stay. (Bold emphasis added)
In other words, Judge Walker let these busybodies intervene at the trial, but they now have to show that they have some real, tangible interest beyond their own prejudices that would enable them to not only seek a stay, but to even proceed with an appeal.

They haven't come up with one yet, so it seems doubtful they can do so at this stage.

Tim Pawlenty wants 13 Minneapolis cops to lose their jobs

That's not hyperbole, he wants to fire them. And he wants a whole bunch of other people in Minnesota to lose their jobs too.

Pawlenty says the rich need to keep their Bush tax breaks. And I do mean the rich, the tax cuts he wants to extend are for income above $250,000. The annual cost? $40 billion.

But how to pay for that tax cut?
Pawlenty would spend unused funds from the economic stimulus package and reduce federal spending -- including in areas that include entitlement programs such as Social Security -- to finance the extension of the tax cuts.
Oh, okay. That money is "unused" you say? VP Biden's economic advisor Jared Bernstein has a few things to say about that:

. . 94 percent of the Recovery Act is either in tax cuts, payments, or projects under contract. Of the remaining 6 percent, half has been awarded and contracts are being finalized - and half is in the final stages of the award process. So when critics like Rep. Boehner talk about stopping the spending, they’re essentially talking about taking away middle class tax cuts, leaving unemployed workers unexpectedly high and dry without an unemployment check, halting road and bridge projects and leaving them unfinished, leaving contractors unpaid for the work they’ve already done and more.

Let's take a look at some of the "unused" Recovery Act projects in Minnesota that Tim Pawlenty would end to pay for his tax breaks for the rich.

(At least) 13 police officers in Minneapolis have been rehired after being laid off. A partially "unused" ARRA grant has put them back on patrol. Tim Pawlenty would fire them.

A $12 million grant to the Mayo Clinic to improve the use of electronic health records and develop the Health IT infrastructure of the future? Tim Pawlenty would redistribute that back to the job creators of this country.

Road construction projects? Stop them now, before they actually get finished. Keep the Camden Bridge closed. Don't finish rehabilitating the Aerial Lift Bridge in Duluth.

All of these are initiatives that Pawlenty has given lip service to during his 8 year reign. He bashed cities for laying off cops after he cut LGA. He and Newt Gingrich advocated electronic health records as a cost saving tool. And he sure talked a good game about bridge maintenance after the 35W bridge collapsed into the Mississippi River, but apparently that's all waste, fraud, and abuse too.

Lest you think I'm just extrapolating without good reason, Pawlenty was very specific about all of this:
He said he wants Minnesota to reject federal stimulus dollars still due the state because the funding makes state agencies more dependent on money from Washington and perpetuates ones with structural issues.
When it comes down to it, Tim Pawlenty wants to lay off Minnesota police officers, community health workers, and construction workers to give a tax break to the rich. It's not about "dependence on Washington." After all, Tim Pawlenty was happy to accept stimulus money to balance the budget, even while he was bashing it. Anyone who's watched him "govern" for the last eight years shouldn't be surprised a bit.

(h/ts to Dan Burns, Political Animal, and Political Animal commenter #3 DJ)

Follow me on Twitter @aaronklemz

Thursday, August 12, 2010

Rybak learns his lesson about endorsement


I don't want to pile on in the discussion/debate/bloodshed about the DFL endorsement that's followed the loss of the latest DFL endorsee for Governor. But I do want to point out that in at least one case, future seekers seem to be adapting to what they learned.

One of the features that I find most problematic about the present endorsement system is the enormous advantage it gives to legislators seeking endorsement, particularly those in the leadership. Not only does the superdelegate system give a significant voting bloc to DFL legislators, they are also important persuaders who have a significant influence on other delegates sitting at the table.

To some extent, that should be embraced. They are elected officials and they run for the only partisan offices in Minnesota other than the constitutional offices. But in practice, they dominate the endorsement process and bias the results.

Today, RT Rybak filed the paperwork to form RYPAC, a PAC to fund Minnesota legislative candidates. This is a strong sign that Rybak is not giving up his statewide political ambitions. It's also a canny response to the current endorsement system. While Rybak, or Chris Coleman, or any other mayor who seeks endorsement will be operating at a structural disadvantage, raising money for legislators will help. Additionally, Rybak has a talented and committed core of supporters. If he starts to use these folks to support candidates in key races and is successful, he'll begin to accumulate more influence with legislators. That was his achilles heel in 2010.

Follow me on Twitter @aaronklemz

(Image Credit: Rybak's Facebook page)

Defending the defense

Alternate title: Princess Helium and the Pathetic Bag of Wind

And now, for something entirely different.

In Koua Fong Lee’s motion, there were a couple of theories advanced about why a new trial should be ordered. First was the claim that there was new evidence about unintended acceleration in Toyota automobiles similar to the one that Lee was driving. Second was the clam that his original lawyer, Tracy Eichhorn-Hicks, provided ineffective assistance in trying the case.

I’ve said quite a lot about the unintended acceleration issue, and the prosecutor’s reaction to it, and nothing, really, about the ineffective assistance of counsel issue, because I am not sure that it is fair to tag Eichhorn-Hicks with that claim. The judge seemed to be willing to do that, but I have my own reservations.

My discomfort on this issue grew last Friday night, when on Almanac, Mary Lahammer interviewed Ron Meshbesher, a witness on the issue of ineffective assistance of counsel at the hearing. Lahammer is much better at searching expressions than searching questions, and she let Meshbesher prattle on about how absolutely, Eichhorn-Hicks screwed up. Eichhorn-Hicks should have been on this unintended acceleration business right from the get go.

Well, wait just a damn minute.

Several minutes earlier, the same intrepid reporter interviewed Emily Gurnon of the Pioneer Press. Gurnon, who had apparently covered the original Lee trial, said that she was listening to her car radio some time after the trial, and she heard, for the first time, about unintended acceleration problems in some Toyota models.

She put two and two together, and as a result, she called Lee’s new defense lawyer, and Koua Fong Lee is a free man today. (Lee apparently hired the new lawyer for the sentencing phase, where Lee got the eight years.) Well, good on her. One could not be anything other than elated by the scene that Jon Tevlin describes: Lee sitting in his living room in his bare feet eating popsicles with his kids.

But did it occur to Lahammer to say, “Wait a minute, Ron, nobody ever heard anything about unintended acceleration in Toyotas until after the trial. What about that?” Well, heaven forfend!

Such a question would, of course, come disturbingly close to actual journalism, so we can be sure that Lahammer wouldn’t ask it.

The accident involving Lee that ultimately took three lives took place in 2006; Lee was tried in 2007.

I invite you, however, to do an internet search for articles that go back to before the trial that discuss unintended acceleration in Toyotas. When you find older articles, they will look like this:

ROCKVILLE, Md. — Carol Mathews, 60, has been driving since she was 12 years old on a South Dakota farm. So when her 2002 Lexus ES 300 ran into a tree as she pulled into a restaurant parking space last fall, she was pretty sure she wasn't the problem. She says it was the third time the car lurched forward without her help.

Marlene Fett, 70, swears she hadn't touched the gas pedal when her 1988 Lincoln Town Car plowed into a carousel outside an Arkansas Wal-Mart in 1995. The crash killed 6-month-old Nathaniel Chapman and seriously injured his then-2-year-old brother, Jonathan.

Was it the car or the driver?

The question lingers 15 years after federal auto safety officials said so-called unintended or sudden acceleration was caused when drivers stepped on the gas instead of the brake. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration's 1989 report was in response to well-publicized complaints that models sold by Audi and other automakers would take off on their own from a standstill, travel several feet and usually crash.

I encourage you, boys and girls, to try a search yourself.

Given the state of the public record — or rather the lack of it, really — of documented, proven cases of unintended acceleration at the time, it is unlikely that the trial judge would have permitted Lee’s original defense lawyer to argue unintended acceleration to the jury. The prosecutors would have argued that it was just tin foil hat stuff. Toyota wasn’t exactly getting the word out, either.

Given the fact there was no particular reason at the time to suspect the car, it also seems that there was little reason to conduct — and probably no money for — an extensive forensic examination of the car.

Remember, in his motion for a new trial, Lee had the benefit of experts who were also looking at Toyota unintended acceleration cases on the civil side, as well as a lawyer from Texas who was on Toyota’s case, so to speak. These people were not available to Eichhorn-Hicks when he tried the case originally, nor, apparently were they available to Lee’s new Minnesota lawyer immediately post-trial.

If the error was so obvious, why wasn’t it raised by Lee’s new Minnesota lawyer right away?

I save my outrage in this case for the prosecutors who remained unwilling to the end, to consider the new evidence, the epiphany, that everyone had about unintended acceleration risk after the trial.

I understand why the new defense team (which included the lawyer hired for the sentencing and who also did not raise unintended acceleration until much later), needed to raise the issue of ineffective assistance of counsel. I can even see why they hired Ron Meshbesher to testify.

But it was a small and ungracious thing for Meshbesher to pontificate on Almanac.

On the other hand, for Lahammer to listen uncritically? Well, that was just business as usual.

A word to the commetariat

Reports are coming in from the field that some of you are having trouble logging on to the comment system. I feel your pain, because Echo sometimes logs me off unexpectedly and I have trouble logging on, too.

But if you have a Twitter, Echo, or a legacy Haloscan account, you ought to be be able to do it. Let me suggest this:

When you get to the “Leave a comment” window, click on the silhouette, and you’ll be prompted to log in. Select Twitter, or whatever. You’ll get a message from Twitter (if that’s what you’re using), saying something about Echo wanting access to the Twitter system. Click “yes.”

Now, here is where it might get tricky. After you say “yes” the application will try to redirect you back to the log on page. For some reason, that doesn’t seem to (always) work. Some browsers, Firefox for example, may say that redirection wasn’t allowed, but even if you click on the “Allow” button, it still doesn’t work.

What you want to do is just close the window that the Cucking Stool is open in. When you open it back up and go back to the “Leave a comment” window, you should be logged in.

If it still doesn’t work, email me at blogspotdog (at) gmail.com.

Wednesday, August 11, 2010

The smoke clears, revealing the crater

Okay, Tommy, just let it out. Tommy links to and quotes an excellent post mortem on the primary by MPR’s Bob Collins. Tommy is unstinting in his criticism of the DFL party after the loss by its endorsed candidate for governor, Margaret Anderson Kelliher.

I don’t have enough knowledge of the DFL party operation to affirm or disaffirm what Tommy has to say about remedies. But as Bob Collins observes, the next state central committee meeting ought to be a doozy.

But let’s return to the central theme of Tommy’s post: sixty percent of the voters in the DFL primary voted for somebody other than the endorsed candidate. In a lot of places, that would be called a stinging rebuke. It is one thing to get forty percent in a general election among three major party candidates (although that is hardly desirable, either); it is quite another when you get forty percent as the endorsed candidate in a party primary.

Money had something to do with it, of course, but if it was just money, Matt Entenza would have been the winner, rather than finishing a distant third. Obviously, it’s more than money.

People have said to me and written that Mark Dayton “disrespected the process.” Given what the process has produced for the DFL the last twenty-four years, I personally don’t blame Dayton for slipping out the back door of the compound before the party started.

When people say he “disrespected the process,” I think they usually mean he “disrespected me.” Not obeying the law of the pack. Just like the Cub Scouts. (And as Tommy recounts, the process rather disrespected Dayton, too.)

I had rather high hopes for the endorsement process this time around. There was reNEW.mn, an initiative of Take Action Minnesota, which set out to at least take the pulse of the supporters of the organization before making its endorsement. Early on, the idea had some juice.

The candidate who came out on the top of that heap, and by a pretty good margin, too, R.T. Rybak, in the end benefitted not at all from being the reNEW.mn frontrunner. The fact that he was the leading vote getter in at least one grass roots vote meant nothing at all at the convention.

When the convention was over, reNEW.mn just gave another “me too” endorsement to Anderson Kelliher. I have some affection for Take Action Minnesota, but I cannot see why anybody would bother to vote in another plebiscite it sponsors. Perhaps that’s harsh, but it turned out to be a genuinely meaningless exercise.

While we’re on the subject of endorsements, I think we need to also re-evaluate what they say about the electability of a candidate, if they say anything at all.

Tom Bakk had the endorsement of several of the construction trade unions because, surprise, surprise, he was a union carpenter. But it said nothing about Bakk’s general appeal as a candidate, which turned out to be, um, limited, or even whether the average rank and file carpenter supported him, because there were only a few who screened candidates and decided on the endorsement. I mean, crikey, everybody knows that.

Education Minnesota endorsed Anderson Kelliher, but take a lot of teachers aside, and they’ll tell you that MAK helped Governor Gutshot kick the can down the road on the budget deficit, including large “deferrals” of state school aid payments. Which will probably never be paid, especially by a governor who espouses a “balanced” approach. But at least we finished on time! Getting people involved in lit drops, phone banks, and GOTV activities is a tough sell when that is the record.

MAK also had the endorsement of MAPE, but the rank and file of MAPE remember that MAK floated the idea all state employees take a two percent wage cut -  even the guys cleaning the toilets at the rest stops. Ditto on the lit drops, phone banks, and GOTV activities.

Counting coup on union endorsements says less and less about whether a candidate is electable, or whether the rank and file will come out and help get the candidate elected. If you don’t believe me, just ask Skip Humphrey.

Having the money to have access to the airwaves obviously helped Mark Dayton. But it wouldn’t have mattered at all if he didn’t have a message that resonated with DFL voters.

It is that simple.

A cul-de-sac off memory lane

Who made these predictions?

If I had to pick the top three [DFL contenders for the nomination], they'd be Bakk [early casulty], Coleman [never ran] and Kelliher — in, of course, alphabetical order.

o  O  o

Former U.S. Sen. Mark Dayton — Like Entenza, he is likely to have enough personal resources to be financially competitive in a primary. However, his public support was waning rapidly during the final years of his Senate term.  If Dayton found an issue (such as prescription drug costs, which he used in 2000) he could gain minimal traction, but he still is not likely to win.

Dayton did find some issues: seniors, education, and forthrightly talking about the need to raise revenue and how to raise it.

Mark Dayton has restored himself with an economically populist message. In the last debate before the primary, when asked why voters should choose him, Dayton responded "I will raise the most revenue." And that is the most straightforward and honest thing I've heard on the campaign trail this season.

“Oh dear!” say some; he’s fomenting [spell checker helpfully offers fermenting] class warfare! The class warfare, however, has been mounted by the wealthy on the rest of us, and they’ve been winning it.

It surprises me not at all that the candidate who seems to understand that essential truth, and said so directly, won the primary.

And who was the author of the predictions? You’ll have to follow the link.

Maybe that 11AM unity press conference will happen after all


UPDATE: Kelliher concedes, 11:15 AM

UPDATE:


UPDATE: Or ... not. No concession as of 10 AM by Kelliher, 3 PM presser scheduled.

With the lead of Margaret Anderson Kelliher shrinking with every precinct that reported, what had seemed a significant lead early in the night became a razor thin margin . . .


And then, it flipped:

The lead lengthened as precincts reported from northeastern Minnesota, as Duluth (home to Dayton running mate Yvonne Prettner Solon) reported, and it became more apparent.

The AP called the race for Dayton shortly after midnight. Around 12:45 AM, Kelliher stated that they were going to wait and make sure that all the votes we're counted. Dayton followed with a cautious presser that sounded like a candidate who knows that he can't afford to anger Kelliher's activist base. But with the lead lengthening at 1:20 AM to near 5,000, outside the boundary of the automatic recount, the choice to sleep on it seems to presage a morning decision to concede. Perhaps that 11 AM Unity press conference will happen on time after all.

If things hold, it looks like the endorsement has once again failed to yield a Governor for the DFL. It's time we get together and try to solve this problem. The amount of resources spent in the furtherance of what's become a quadrennial exercise in self-flagellation is obscene. But that's another post.

Mark Dayton has restored himself with an economically populist message. In the last debate before the primary, when asked why voters should choose him, Dayton responded "I will raise the most revenue." And that is the most straightforward and honest thing I've heard on the campaign trail this season.

We will get to see the epic battle between the only statewide campaign in the U.S. leading with "tax the rich" as a message and a libertarian who would slash government. More than any time in recent memory, this election will feature classic themes of liberalism and conservatism. It will offer a clear choice on economic philosophy and government. It will be a battle royale for the soul of Minnesota.

It has the potential to be the most negative campaign in the history of the State of Minnesota. And it will be a close election. Only the unified efforts of Minnesota's DFL can win. In this election season that has been characterized by anger, it will take a motivated party to mobilize supporters. It will be a challenge to match the momentum of the right.

The task of the DFL is to find its focus and turn its gaze back toward Tom Emmer, because he must be defeated. This is more than a "ten year election," this is a generational election, a choice between retrenchment and progress.

Follow me on Twitter @aaronklemz

Tuesday, August 10, 2010

“I’m going back to Allen”

Ring. Ring.

Hello. Emmer here.

[beery voice, echoing] I’m going back to Allen.

[muttering, then:] Hi, Mark, I’ve been meaning to call you. I’ve decided to make a change in my campaign manager.

I know, but it’s too late; I quit.

Mark, it’s Tuesday; I announced the new campaign manager over the weekend.

Doesn’t matter; I quit.

[sighs] All right, if it makes you feel better.

[with a catch in his voice] You don’t really care how I feel. I’m going back to Allen, did you hear me say that?

Allen?

[vehemently] Allen Quist! He’d never treat me like this!

Mark, Allen isn’t running for anything. He also took a shellacking as the endorsed Republican when he ran against Arne Carlson in the primary in 1994.

He did? Well, let that be a lesson to you, too.

I’m sorry, Mark, I don’t follow you.

[long pause] Well, when you abandon people, bad things happen.

What’s that supposed to mean?

[little sob] I thought we were such friends in the House. We used to vote together on lots of stuff.

I know; I’ll miss that.

No you won’t. I trusted you. I’m sending your stuff back.

Stuff?

You know; the paperweight, the hockey stick, stuff.

That’s okay, Mark, keep it. As a token.

Noooooo! I want to send it back.

All right, suit yourself.

You’ll pay for this, you know.

And how is that?

I’ll tell all my friends that you aren’t a real conservative.

[voice rising] Tell me why you think that will stick, Mark.

Well, just look at my replacements: RINOs, backsliders. One of those guys even helped Arne Carlson beat Allen — our Allen — in that primary you were talking about.

Well, true. But look, Mark, I’m going to level with you. Tony said it was either me or you going into the pool. Look at this as taking one for the team.

Not my team! What a bunch of backstabbers!

I’m sorry you feel that way, Mark.

That is how I feel. But at least I’ll be back in the House next year.  I won my primary race. No thanks to you! Worked my tail off for you, and this what I get. But you won’t even be in the building next year. Ha ha!

[angry] That was a cheap shot, Mark. Where are you calling from, anyway? You sound like you’re in a cave.

I’m at Moola’s Bar. [in Jordan]

Mark, it’s pretty late.

I very well know that, Mr. gubernatorial candidate! I’m celebrating.

Are there other people there listening?

Well, sure, lots of people; I said I’m celebrating.

Click.

Abomination!

No, not teh gays, but that’s undoubtedly what Tom Emmer and the boys from the You Can Run but You Cannot Hide ministry are talking about. This is a picture from the Republican State Convention.

abomination

No, the abomination here is the fact that Emmer doesn’t tie his tie so that it touches his belt. It just amplifies the real estate around his middle.

A thump of the tail to Dump Michele Bachmann for the link to the Maddow video (which you really should watch).

Monday, August 09, 2010

Peak civilization

We are past the zenith:

The lights are going out all over America — literally. Colorado Springs has made headlines with its desperate attempt to save money by turning off a third of its streetlights, but similar things are either happening or being contemplated across the nation, from Philadelphia to Fresno.

Meanwhile, a country that once amazed the world with its visionary investments in transportation, from the Erie Canal to the Interstate Highway System, is now in the process of unpaving itself: in a number of states, local governments are breaking up roads they can no longer afford to maintain, and returning them to gravel.

And a nation that once prized education — that was among the first to provide basic schooling to all its children — is now cutting back. Teachers are being laid off; programs are being canceled; in Hawaii, the school year itself is being drastically shortened. And all signs point to even more cuts ahead.

Those are the opening paragraphs of a Paul Krugman column today in the New York Times.

emmer flintstone We are turning our backs on modernity. In the name of something that guys like Tom Emmer call “freedom and prosperity.” Small government. Indeed, so small that it can’t afford to keep the lights on.

In some circles, this is a victory. For the Canadians, maybe, or the Japanese, or even the Chinese. Because it surely isn’t a victory for us.

Less safe, less mobile, and less educated. This is not a promising development. Emmer is the Missing Link to our past: the Stone Age.

You can see the competing visions in our own governor’s race. On the one side, there’s Emmer and the other 18th century thinkers like Craig Westover, who think that every dollar that the public collects and spends is a dollar wasted; it disappears down a hole somewhere never to be seen again. And roads and bridges, and schools, and potable water and treated waste water, and cops, and public health, and state parks, and universities just appear out of nowhere. They also believe in the Big Rock Candy Mountain.

These people are, let’s be frank, damn fools.

On the other side, to a greater or less degree, are the DFL candidates for governor. I think that Mark Dayton has been the most forthright in the message: the cure for anorexia is not to eat less. But compared to Emmer, they’re all geniuses.

It’s a fish or cut bait political season. I think you have to decide which vision you subscribe to; a vote for a middle of the road, muddle through, neither fish nor fowl candidate is just indecision, moral cowardice. Sometimes, you have to go home, son, and make up your mind.